Five is already too many. Current guilds would be stronger and able to offer more of everything if players weren't diluted across so many useless guilds. IMO the opposite needs to happen, but I have no clue how that would be accomplished at this point.

DangerMan wrote: »

Giles.floydub17_ESO wrote: »

Yea, no. Worst idea ever.

So tired of weak guild members. The only people that would be interested in additional guilds slots would be weak guild members. Users and not contributors.

Not really.

Right now I have:

2 Trader Guilds
1 PvP Guild
1 Mule Guild
1 End-Game Trial Only PvE Guild

I run out of traders slots so I need atleast two additional guild slots - 1 for another trader guild, and 1 for a general PvE guild.

These are issues relating to bigger problems with this game and shouldn't be hamfixed by simply adding more guild slots.
1. You need multiple trade guilds because there is only 30 slots. Solution - Request more slots to sell things.
2. You have a mule guild because for *** inventory space. Solution - Request crafting bags, more inventory space.

Asking for more guilds because you only want a few more spaces to sell things just dilutes this already diluted system further. I think everyone should get 3 guilds max. 1 PvE, 1 PvP and 1 Trade. Then fix the underlying problems to strengthen those.

I disagree, just because the system won't handle it very well. It may be good for you, but there's already too many Guilds and not enough Guild Traders, so if the biggest sellers get more Trading Guilds they'll force out other people. We need more Guild Traders to be sure, and I think an increase to at least 50 slots per Guild to sell with is in order, but having more Guilds is unnecessary and harmful. Not to mention the Guilds that are already there have a player limit which they're usually at, so in order for more people to have more Guilds, again people would have to be forced out to make room, likely the least active players. And that's not right, just because you play a little less than someone else is no reason to be ousted to make room for someone to have their 8th Guild.

I also agree with what someone else said about spreading players too thin across Guilds they don't participate enough in, with the limited number of players per Guild we actually need members that are properly active and participating. 5 is already plenty, and if it ain't broke don't fix it.

Sure, why not

dday3six wrote: »

I hate havin' to deal with 5. I'd rather just have an auction house that completely eliminates the need for trade guilds and opens the market. IMO the Guild Trader System is just in place to stifle the market and limit the redistribution of goods between players as a method to artificially extent content life.

I think one of the main reasons ZOS doesn't want an auction house and wants to keep the traders is because how big of a gold sink they are. 3-4mil bids on each trader on console in the big areas is a major major coin sink. Take that away with an auction house and you'll ruin the economy of the game. Prices will inflate like crazy!

I think it would be nice to have 1 per toon which would mean with buying a new character slot you then get an extra guild slot or maybe sell them seperately