Maintenance for the week of May 25:
• [IN PROGRESS] ESO Store and Account System for maintenance – May 27, 6:00AM EDT (10:00 UTC) - 4:00PM EDT (20:00 UTC)
• [IN PROGRESS] ESO Store and Account System for maintenance – May 27, 6:00AM EDT (10:00 UTC) - 4:00PM EDT (20:00 UTC)
Something happening which concerns me and other players
xxxDrDoom
✭✭
Hi,
Not sure if this is the right place or not to post this. I'm a PS4 player. And I would like someone from Zeni to address this. It has become a huge issue and is artificially inflating prices as the issues become one of price fixing, threats to players, etc.
There is a group of players on the PS4 who have created a monopoly on the trading stalls. I'd have no problem with this except here is what is happening. This small group, and it's just a few players, create dummy guilds and recruit all week. They then take these dummy guilds, and buy every trader in Wayrest, Raw'l Ka, Mournhold, and a couple other cities. They buy these spots for cheap (because they have threatened other guilds who might otherwise bid on carts), and then after the reset Monday morning, they then auction off or sell the trader carts to other members of their guild alliance. This is done by disbanding the guild, which opens the cart for the bidder/buyer to take over the cart for the week. I do have names, and can bring forth a lot of people who have been threatened, etc.
What happens then, which is also of concern, is the traders are told what prices they can sell materials at. Particularly purple and gold upgrade materials. If you do not conform to their pricing model, you are kicked from the guild.
I have read the terms of use, and while this is not addressed, I do think and hope you will consider this behavior not in the spirit of the game and look into it. If you need more information, please email me. I do not want to name names in a public forum.
Please feel free to move this wherever, as long as someone from Zeni see's it to address.
Thanks
DD
Not sure if this is the right place or not to post this. I'm a PS4 player. And I would like someone from Zeni to address this. It has become a huge issue and is artificially inflating prices as the issues become one of price fixing, threats to players, etc.
There is a group of players on the PS4 who have created a monopoly on the trading stalls. I'd have no problem with this except here is what is happening. This small group, and it's just a few players, create dummy guilds and recruit all week. They then take these dummy guilds, and buy every trader in Wayrest, Raw'l Ka, Mournhold, and a couple other cities. They buy these spots for cheap (because they have threatened other guilds who might otherwise bid on carts), and then after the reset Monday morning, they then auction off or sell the trader carts to other members of their guild alliance. This is done by disbanding the guild, which opens the cart for the bidder/buyer to take over the cart for the week. I do have names, and can bring forth a lot of people who have been threatened, etc.
What happens then, which is also of concern, is the traders are told what prices they can sell materials at. Particularly purple and gold upgrade materials. If you do not conform to their pricing model, you are kicked from the guild.
I have read the terms of use, and while this is not addressed, I do think and hope you will consider this behavior not in the spirit of the game and look into it. If you need more information, please email me. I do not want to name names in a public forum.
Please feel free to move this wherever, as long as someone from Zeni see's it to address.
Thanks
DD
10
-
remilafo✭✭✭✭Really? such cut throat behaviour..
what actual threatening is happening? It's not like anything can actually be done to you?
2 -
myrrrorb14_ESO✭✭✭✭✭Clever scam. But I don't see how it would work. Couldn't just anyone bid on the stand once the guild disbands? Why can't you just outbid the shell guild?1 -
xxxDrDoom✭✭I have been privy to some of the msgs. I'll leave it at that. They are threatening. What can be done? Hmmm. If a group owns guilds, and their traders, being threatened to not be able to join a guild or sell at a trader is threatening. Spamming their inbox is certainly against the EULA. Can anything be done physically, no. But this is a game, and threatening someone, or other people from playing the game in the way it was intended is an issue
4 -
Zerok✭✭✭✭This is the natural consequence of games that try to simulate an economy without some kind of antitrust mechanism.
It's working as intended.Zeerok (the sneaky ruffian) - LV50 Bosmer stamblade DPS (AD)
Gontrand de Bourbon (the greedy aristocrat) - LV50 Breton magsorc tank (DC)
Augustus Aquilarios (the imperial claimant) - LV50 Imperial stamDK PvP (EP)
Zeerokk (the AD zealot) - LV50 Altmer magblade PvP (AD)
Lianna Storm (the inferno maiden) - LV50 Dunmer magDK DPS (EP)
Fights-With-Khajiit (the gullible faithful) - LV5 Argonian templar (EP)
Miner'va (the skooma addict) - LV3 Khajiit sorcerer (AD) - chaotic neutral
Siggy Thorvaldsson (the charismatic baroness) - LV50 Nord stamwarden tank (DC)1 -
xxxDrDoom✭✭Because of the threats made, people aren't bidding on stalls any longer. The stalls in Raw'l sold today for 1K. The folks doing this, were in area chat selling them for 1.4M and then bragging on how they were pocketing the money.
0 -
myrrrorb14_ESO✭✭✭✭✭I have been privy to some of the msgs. I'll leave it at that. They are threatening. What can be done? Hmmm. If a group owns guilds, and their traders, being threatened to not be able to join a guild or sell at a trader is threatening. Spamming their inbox is certainly against the EULA. Can anything be done physically, no. But this is a game, and threatening someone, or other people from playing the game in the way it was intended is an issue
Messages that threaten are in fact against the rules and is an offense for which one can be banned. I would start with reporting it with a screenshot of the message.
Edit: I belong to a large trade guild on PS EU and have never been told to sell at a certain price. So at least not all guilds do this...Edited by myrrrorb14_ESO on February 1, 2016 4:30PM4 -
smacx250✭✭✭✭✭You use the word "threatened", which is one aspect that may be decidedly against the TOS:
You agree not to use any Service to:
...
Harass, stalk, threaten, embarrass, spam or do anything else to another user of any Services that is unwanted, such as repeatedly sending unwanted messages or making personal attacks or statements about race, sexual orientation, religion, heritage, etc.;
...
If you can elaborate on this to ZOS (probably not here - PM a mod and/or open a CS ticket), that may be helpful in furthering your case.
2 -
xxxDrDoom✭✭The problem with the message being posted, which I will do to Zeni directly if they are interested. Is that punishing one or two of the players of the group does not solve the problem. The groups behavior as a whole needs to be addressed.2
-
Fortunately there are no verbal threats so you should be able to document all of this.Tarkus Aquila - Imperial Templar
Klaaz - Khajit Nightblade
Fractiz - Altmer Sorcerer
Jonsir Vheti - Dunmer Dragonknight
Kills-With-Grin - Argonian Dragonknight
Myrddin the Mystic - Breton Warden
PS4 ESOTU Adventurer since June 20150 -
RedTalon✭✭✭✭✭
✭Depending on the threatening it would be against TOS on ps4 and in eso , is it real life's threats and such?
Recommend using this link and clicking on the additional support options to get a hold of ZOS
https://help.elderscrollsonline.com/app/home?region=Edited by RedTalon on February 1, 2016 4:33PM0 -
xxxDrDoom✭✭Great. Who is a Mod I can send this information to? Several of us have opened a CS ticket (maybe not with this level of detail), but it is not being addressed at a high enough level IMO.0
-
wayfarerx✭✭✭✭✭
✭✭✭I have been privy to some of the msgs. I'll leave it at that. They are threatening.
I'm curious to know exactly how someone threatens you in a video game. If they are making real-world threats then that's a crime and you should definitely be reporting those people. Otherwise they are doing what? Following you around and stealing resource node from you? Griefing you in PvP?@wayfarerx - PC / North America / Aldmeri Dominion0 -
vyrusb23✭✭✭✭✭They buy these spots for cheap (because they have threatened other guilds who might otherwise bid on carts), and then after the reset Monday morning, they then auction off or sell the trader carts to other members of their guild alliance.
What do you mean by threatened? How do they threaten other guilds?4 -
xxxDrDoom✭✭Again. I'm talking to the wrong people. I am not here to debate this with the masses, but want the attention of someone who has the power to make some changes in the game to behavior which I believe is against the TOS. And if it isn't in the TOS, then, maybe it should be.0
-
vyrusb23✭✭✭✭✭Again. I'm talking to the wrong people. I am not here to debate this with the masses, but want the attention of someone who has the power to make some changes in the game to behavior which I believe is against the TOS. And if it isn't in the TOS, then, maybe it should be.
I'm not trying to debate anything. I think we're actually really curious what you mean by threaten. You can't just say that they threatened a person or a group of people and not say how.
How did they threaten them? Bodily harm? Hacker attacks? PvP threats? We really want to know.7 -
wayfarerx✭✭✭✭✭
✭✭✭Again. I'm talking to the wrong people. I am not here to debate this with the masses, but want the attention of someone who has the power to make some changes in the game to behavior which I believe is against the TOS. And if it isn't in the TOS, then, maybe it should be.
Well if you post something in the General Discussion forum you can generally expect that people will discuss it. I just can't imagine a "threat" that I would get in-game where my response would be anything but "LOL, whatever newb." What makes the PS4 players capitulate to this kind of behavior?@wayfarerx - PC / North America / Aldmeri Dominion3 -
RedTalon✭✭✭✭✭
✭Again. I'm talking to the wrong people. I am not here to debate this with the masses, but want the attention of someone who has the power to make some changes in the game to behavior which I believe is against the TOS. And if it isn't in the TOS, then, maybe it should be.
You posted in a general forum so its open for debate sadly, like I said use the support sections of the website to get ahold of ZOS
https://help.elderscrollsonline.com/app/home?region=Edited by RedTalon on February 1, 2016 4:45PM0 -
Xendyn✭✭✭✭✭
✭✭Great. Who is a Mod I can send this information to? Several of us have opened a CS ticket (maybe not with this level of detail), but it is not being addressed at a high enough level IMO.
PM @ZOS_GinaBruno directly.Lag is ruinin' my 'mershun!
A society grows great when old men plant trees whose shade they know they shall never sit in.
There is only one good, knowledge, and one evil, ignorance - Socrates
Member of the Old Guard, keepers of the game's history
PC/NA2 -
smacx250✭✭✭✭✭If you have opened tickets, I'd suggest you PM someone like @ZOS_GinaBruno, pointing them to the thread, providing the ticket numbers, and including what ever additional information you may have on how the behavior may be violating the TOS.
Also, do you have any specific suggestions for altering the guild trader mechanics that would hinder such behavior, but wouldn't unduly negatively affect those that "play the trader game" without resorting to tactics that may violate the TOS? Ideally the game mechanics would prevent this kind of behavior, but that might not be reasonably possible.
0 -
sylviermoone✭✭✭✭✭Great. Who is a Mod I can send this information to? Several of us have opened a CS ticket (maybe not with this level of detail), but it is not being addressed at a high enough level IMO.
PM @ZOS_GinaBruno directly.
Seconded. This needs to be addressed, and PMing Gina is he best way I can think of to ensure that it is escalated to the proper folks.Edited by sylviermoone on February 1, 2016 4:52PMCo-GM, Angry Unicorn Traders: PC/NA
"Official" Master Merchant Tech Support
and Differently Geared AF
@sylviermoone0 -
NewBlacksmurf✭✭✭✭✭
✭✭✭✭✭When people are involved....these things happen.
I honestly don't want ZOS to get involved....let me explain why.
When anything gets to a point where it dictated by the Developer, then we are no longer playing the game.
-I think the value of this is for other groups to unite and not be bullied or just have a "Do Not Support" list.-PC (PTS)/Xbox One: NewBlacksmurf
~<{[50]}>~ looks better than *5010 -
Hope499✭✭✭✭Save your money and make your own guild/bid.
Sitting here crying and not explain anything wont help you, at all.
If enough people are upset then rally them up do something about it.
No one is breaking ANY rules, and if you dont want to explain what you mean by "threaten" then you are just going to have to deal with it or solve it yourself, ZOS wont do anything, because there is nothing TO DO.Tripped over my friends bra.....
....
....
..she is always setting booby traps!0 -
vyrusb23✭✭✭✭✭I guess this thread can be closed. Obviously it serves no more purpose.
Reported for lack of content.1 -
Lysette✭✭✭✭✭
✭✭✭✭✭It really depends on the kind of threat - just taking over the market by buying all the traders and say, you won't sell anything ever again, if you do not comply to our method of handling those things - is not a threat, but market pvp. It has to be actual offense which is ruining the game for others just for the sole purpose of ruining it without that there is reasonable gameplay behind it. If just manipulating the market would count as a threat, EVE online would be empty by now, market pvp is common there and market manipulations as well - so you will have ot be very specific with what kind of threats those are and they might not count as threats in the end - but just be market pvp - so prepare for good arguments and proof with it.0 -
xxxDrDoom✭✭Thank you. This is what I was looking for. I do not need to prove anything to any of you folks. But I do have proof. I am not here to look for drama, but am looking for someone who I can speak with, not in a public forum, who can do something about this. I have sent a msg to the admin.1
-
vyrusb23✭✭✭✭✭Thank you. This is what I was looking for. I do not need to prove anything to any of you folks. But I do have proof. I am not here to look for drama, but am looking for someone who I can speak with, not in a public forum, who can do something about this. I have sent a msg to the admin.
You could have come here and gotten people to support you and fight on your side. Instead, you came to General Discussion with claims of vague threats and no proof to support it, thinking that there won't be a discussion about it. People asked valid questions in a non-combative way, and your only response was "I don't have to prove anything to you people."
If you want to do something constructive, PM a forum moderator and ask them to close this absurd QQ thread.Edited by vyrusb23 on February 1, 2016 5:14PM5 -
wayfarerx✭✭✭✭✭
✭✭✭Thank you. This is what I was looking for. I do not need to prove anything to any of you folks. But I do have proof. I am not here to look for drama, but am looking for someone who I can speak with, not in a public forum, who can do something about this. I have sent a msg to the admin.
You could have come here and gotten people to support you and fight on your side. Instead, you came to General Discussion with claims of vague threats and no proof to support it, thinking that there won't be a discussion about it. People asked valid questions in a non-combative way, and your only response was "I don't have to prove anything."
If you want to do something constructive, PM a forum moderator and ask them to close this absurd QQ thread.
I'm not even asking for proof, just a simple example would make me happy.@wayfarerx - PC / North America / Aldmeri Dominion2
This discussion has been closed.