Update 44 is now available for testing on the PTS! You can read the latest patch notes here: https://forums.elderscrollsonline.com/en/categories/pts
Maintenance for the week of September 23:
• PC/Mac: No maintenance – September 23

Suggestion: Improving Crafting and Incentivising Content

dvstansb14_ESO
dvstansb14_ESO
✭✭✭
ESO currently does a reasonable job of blending and balancing armor/weapon crafting with world-dropped sets. When creating a character build, there are pros and cons to each, and often a good build will involve mixing crafted and world-dropped pieces. One area that could be improved is the lack of style choice with world-drops and the resulting style constraints/clashes when mixed with other sets (crafted or otherwise).

On the one hand, some players may prefer the unique (and possibly rare) look of of a particular world-drop set, on the other, some may want the stats/perks of the set, but in a different cosmetic style - others may only want the look of a rare-drop, but with different stats. These trade-offs may be intentional, but I see them as negatives as they reduce the player's freedom of choice regarding armor builds. A good example is the "Elf Bane" set, which has very compelling stats for my main character, but is only available in the Argonian style, which I personally dislike.

My suggested solution is to use a method similar to the somewhat recent addition of dropping rare crafting styles via "motif pages". Rather than (or in addition to) dropping set pieces, a "single use schematic" for a piece could be dropped instead (or extracted from the piece by a crafter). With this schematic, a crafter could then build the corresponding armor piece that would be imbued with the stats/perks from the schematic, either in the style associated with the schematic or in whichever racial/rare style the crafter knows. Alternatively, the schematic could be used to to craft an armor piece at a unique crafting station to get the stats of that crafting station, but with the cosmetic style of the schematic. The schematic would act as a sort of style/bonus "material" in the crafting UI and would be consumed in the crafting process.

With this approach, we can retain the value of both world-drops and crafting while giving players more freedom to tailor their gear both functionally and cosmetically. By "value" I mean this incentivises existing and new content/DLC for both gear-drop players and crafting-oriented players in that both can receive rewards useful for their purposes. This seems like a win-win solution to me.




  • CirithValaria
    CirithValaria
    ✭✭✭✭
    Personally I would like to see 2 things:

    1st.
    This for crafters who like to craft their own sets and want to design their own unique looks from various options.
    http://forums.elderscrollsonline.com/en/discussion/121362/master-crafter-new-perk-for-crafting/p1

    2nd.
    Dyeable, overall better quality and more unique Crown Store costumes for those who want to: hide their undesired dropped set looks / want to hide their crafted armor since they don't want to use time designing their style / to hide sorcerers bound armor / disguise their true gear in pvp etc.

    With this its a win-win for ZOS and for players.
    Just my 2cents...

    EDIT: By all means I'm not saying your idea is bad - it's well thought, solid and offers good customization options for dropped gear in a way that fits eso. + Insightful :)
    Edited by CirithValaria on November 14, 2015 1:57PM
    Motto:
    “What we have done for ourselves alone dies with us...
    What we have done for others and the world, it remains and is immortal...”

    About me:
    @Cirith-Valar'ia & @Lilith-Valar'ia (in-game)
    | hardcore-casual | pc-eu / ps4-eu | pve | pvp | player since early beta | subscriber since early-launch |
    | The Sanctum Sanctorum - founder & guild master |

    Characters:
    @Cirith-Valar'ia(pc-eu)
    Cirith Valar'ia | Dunmer (F) | Lady of Light, Templar DD (stamina) | (ex)VR 16 | Aldmeri Dominion (Master Crafter - all crafts, traits & styles.)
    Nezghul Sithis | Breton (F) | Winter Ward, Warden Tank (magic) | lvl 50 | Aldmeri Dominion
    Hakrate Hecate | Orc (F) | Dying Light, Templar DD (stamina, PvP) | lvl 50 | Aldmeri Dominion
    Tummien-Vesien-Tulkki | Argonian (M) | Blood Shield, Nightblade Tank (magic) | (ex)VR 16 | Ebonheart Pact
    Valonkantaja | Argonian (F) | Healer of the Hist, Templar Healer | (ex)VR 16 | Ebonheart Pact
    Tulenvalaja | Argonian (M) | Guardian of the Hist, Dragonknight DD (magic) | (ex)VR 16 | Ebonheart Pact
    Kuolon-Raatojen-Kaitsija | Argonian (M) | Corpsekeeper of the Hist, Necromancer Tank (magic) | lvl 20 | Ebonheart Pact
    Kal-Mah | Argonian (F) | Spawn of Wamasu, Sorcerer Tank (magic) | (ex)VR 16 | Ebonheart Pact
    Puutiainen | Bosmer (F) | Horny Ravager, Sorcerer DD (stamina) | (ex)VR 16 | Daggerfall Covenant
    Musta-Surma | Khajiit (F) | Nightpawler, Nightblade DD - thief/murderer (stamina) | (ex)VR 16 | Daggerfall Covenant
    T'Sok Shiar | Altmer (F) | Touched by Daedra, Sorcerer DD (magic) | (ex)VR 1 | Daggerfall Covenant (Master Cook - all recipes.)
    S'auron | Khajiit (M) | Poison Paw, Dragonknight DD (stamina) | lvl 50 | Daggerfall Covenant
    (1100CP)

    @Lilith-Valar'ia(pc-eu)
    Lilith Valar'ia | Dunmer (F) | Phœnix, Dragonknight Healer | lvl 25 | Aldmeri Dominion
    Stormpaw | Khajiit (F) | Cpt. Pirate Puss, Sorcerer DD (stamina) | lvl 25 | Aldmeri Dominion
    Iliath Valar'ia | Dunmer (F) | Storm Ward, Sorcerer Tank (magic) | lvl 25 | Aldmeri Dominion
    Haudantakainen | Argonian (M) | Pale Avenger, Nightblade DD (magic) | lvl 25 | Ebonheart Pact
    Kira Tal'Shiar | Breton (F) | Warrior of Light, Templar DD (magic) | lvl 10 | Ebonheart Pact
    Sunpaw | Khajiit (M) | Crescent Moon Guardian, Templar Tank (stamina, PvP) | lvl 40 | Daggerfall Covenant
    Shangri Shadowtusk | Orc (F) | Shadowtusk, Nightblade DD (stamina) | lvl 50 | Daggerfall Covenant
    (180CP)

    @CirithValaria(ps4-eu)
    Topaz-dar | Khajiit (F) | Mysticat, Sorcerer DD (stamina) | lvl 5 | Aldmeri Dominion
    Her-Frozen-Heart | Argonian (F) | Frozen Shield, Warden Tank (magicka) | lvl 5 | Daggerfall Covenant
    Neazgûl | Redguard (F) | Bear Matron, Warden DD (stamina) | lvl 50 | Daggerfall Covenant
    (160CP)
Sign In or Register to comment.