As if enchanting wasn't demoralizing enough already...

Natjur wrote: »

I thought it was just a display issue, try making a 'white' version of each and see.

I did. There wasn't any difference then either. I also tried health, stamina and a few other types. I haven't actually tried making two and putting them on my armor. When I get home this afternoon from work, I'll try that.

EDIT: Now that I think on it, from my quick experimentation, it looks like the weapon enchants for the negative glyph were different, but the armor/jewelry enchants were the same. I only tried armor enchants for the positive glyph. I'll experiment with that as well.

EDIT:

So I did a quick test now that I'm home. I first enchanted my heavy armor cuirass (which has exploration trait) with the Grand Glyph of Magicka (blue). Before the enchant, I had 16353 magicka. Afterwards, I had 16861. Which leaves me a total of 508 added. Which is different from what the UI says, 480. I then replaced/overwrote the enchant with the Superior Glyph of Magicka (blue). The stats didn't change at all. It too just gave 508 magicka. Out of curiosity, I also enchanted my greaves (with training trait) with the remaining Superior Glyph, which the UI said were supposed to give 480 as well. They gave 507.

Also, the weapon versions of the positive glyphs increased in stats. It's just the armor/jewelry that are staying the same.

Runefell wrote: »

So I did a quick test now that I'm home. I first enchanted my heavy armor cuirass (which has exploration trait) with the Grand Glyph of Magicka (blue). Before the enchant, I had 16353 magicka. Afterwards, I had 16861. Which leaves me a total of 508 added. Which is different from what the UI says, 480.

The tooltips do not take into account racial passives, skill line passives, slotted passives, Champion Points, etc. That is why you are getting 508 instead of 480. Lots of things can increase your magicka that are not tied to the enchantment itself. For example, Bretons and Altmer get 10% bonus magicka, Dunmer get 9% bonus magicka, wearing 5/1/1 armor weight distribution gives 6% bonus magicka, Inner Light skill gives 5% bonus magicka, each Mages Guild ability slotted gives 2% bonus magicka, each Champion Point spent in the Mage gives bonus magicka (1st point in Mage gives 1% bonus magicka but subsequent points start giving less and less). And so on. Through a combination of those you have gotten yourself about 5.833% bonus magicka so your 480 gets boosted to 508.

That does not explain why a Grand glyph would be giving the same amount as a Splendid glyph! But just pointing out why the tooltips differ from the values you get once applied.

Enchanting needs more love. Its the most expensive and hardest crafting skill to level and you get little benefit from it. Not surprised enchanting has these types of bugs; its a low priority for them.

I have to wonder if it is working as intended, for Pvp sorts to keep on even setting. Which is ridiculous and disappointing.

It is true the Monumental Glyphs (10-14) offer a slight increase to armor and jewelry glyphs. Don't get too excited though.

Don't get me started on how the Enchantment Writ rewards were on par with the level completed UNTIL rank 9 potency. Now the reward is level 5glyphs, and NO runes. EVER.

Is anyone even paying attention to Enchanting??

Nestor wrote: »

Morimizo wrote: »

Don't get me started on how the Enchantment Writ rewards were on par with the level completed UNTIL rank 9 potency. Now the reward is level 5glyphs, and NO runes. EVER.

I have been getting a Kuta about every 3rd writ on my master Enchanter. Then again, my L1 and L3 Potency Enchanters are seeing Kutas about the same rate (maybe 1 in 4 from writ containers), about 1 in 6 from the surveys they get. Note, days will go by with no Kuta's to speak of, so not saying this is a reliable source for them, just one that has a decent chance of paying out.

But I have not noticed much in the way of Runes from Enchanting Writs, other than Aspects. Usually it's a Green Glyph, a Leveled Soul Gem and sometimes a Kuta or a Survey.

The experience you share is what I also had before hitting Potency 9 for Enchanting, which is why I think it is weird. Why would a Major Glyph (level 5) be of much interest to a Master Enchanter? Sure, you can get a minimal amount of inspiration through extraction (assuming you're not 50), but the likelihood of USING it is quite low. And when, at Level 8 Potency, I received Splendid Glyphs (which is appropriate), This is why I suppose that someone is asleep at the switch.

And I was getting a Kuta every 3 days or so (which is great luck of course), but since 2.0.6 patch (and reaching lvl 9), nothing. Not any aspect stone at all. I couldn't help but ask, "Why did I bother to level the potency?" At least in terms of the Writ reward.

Nestor wrote: »

Morimizo wrote: »

Why would a Major Glyph (level 5) be of much interest to a Master Enchanter?

Come to think of it, I have not received a Monumental Glyph on my Master Enchanter. But, he is only VR6, so I am getting the level of Glyph of my character.

I do agree that the Glyph we get should be tied to the Potency level, not the character level. We have to make the Monumental for the Writ.

I just decon them for the Jejota's anyway.

Speaking of which, why are Greens the best Glyph we can get from a writ? We should have a chance to get Blue or Purple or even Gold at higher levels of writs.

I currently am VR8, and getting Major Glyphs in the reward, so at least for me, not tied to character level.

And the occasional higher-rarity glyph would be nice, but agree it's not setup that way apparently.

Tbh, I stay away from Blacksmithing, Clothing, and Woodworking writs because the cost never balances out the reward; Provisioning MIGHT give a good recipe or set of purple ingredients; Alchemy is just for the tiny gold amount; and Enchanting has now became the same--a small gold payout.

This sounds jaded, but I expect a full nerf to Provisioning Writ rewards to compensate for the lackluster rewards of the others. Instead of the reasonable, common sense solution of actually improving the others.

Tallowby wrote: »

Note: This only applies to Armor glyphs only. Weapon glyphs have different values...

It also applies to jewelry glyphs, unfortunately.

As for the glyph rewards from enchanting writs, my master enchanter, who just hit v7, gets a random level glyph, i.e. anything from v1-3 (is that Major?) to Splendid (v7-9). Have not seen a monumental glyph, though.