People keep using the excuse that "it's cosmetic so it's not p2w". However it is not just cosmetic. The Crown Store version removes the rank requirement of the rare motifs. Rather than having to almost max a crafting skill in order to use the motif, you can just buy it and completely sidestep all the work you used to have to do in order to use the skin. It would be functionally equivalent to putting Dark Seducer or Mannimarco costume in the Crown Store.
I don't have the numbers to calculate the amount of money, time, and material this is sidestepping, but it is significant. Even if this isn't considered pay to win by some, you have to at least admit it is a huge leap in that direction. It is very concerning. TBH with the amount of work and money this allows you to skip, I consider it way more p2w than the upcoming XP boost potions.
Others may or may not feel this way, but I've played since beta and never dropped my sub no matter what bugs, glitches, or lag. Even now with it b2p I still hold my sub because despite all the issues, they have shown a lot of effort towards making ESO a better gaming experience. This though is definitely strike one for me. Short of abolishing the motifs from the store, it is an irrevocable push towards the door.
Not just the level to use it but the level to find it. Daedric and AE don't even drop *at all* until you get into the V5+ zones and motifs like barbaric don't drop until the V1+ zones so now a level 1 person can just buy them immediately without even playing the game.
Not just the level to use it but the level to find it. Daedric and AE don't even drop *at all* until you get into the V5+ zones and motifs like barbaric don't drop until the V1+ zones so now a level 1 person can just buy them immediately without even playing the game.
Are you sure about that? I'm more than sure I found my barbaric and imperial in Vulkhael Guard AD of all places.
Not just the level to use it but the level to find it. Daedric and AE don't even drop *at all* until you get into the V5+ zones and motifs like barbaric don't drop until the V1+ zones so now a level 1 person can just buy them immediately without even playing the game.
Are you sure about that? I'm more than sure I found my barbaric and imperial in Vulkhael Guard AD of all places.
From Matt Firor:
“...“customization and convenience” items before. Simply put, this means that an item in the Crown Store serves one of two purposes: it either provides a visual upgrade or distinction for your character, or it provides a way to save time at the expense of spending crowns...”
Uhhh, there it is. Surprised? I don't see why. This opens up the door to pretty much EVERYTHING.
From Road Ahead - Feb
People keep using the excuse that "it's cosmetic so it's not p2w". However it is not just cosmetic. The Crown Store version removes the rank requirement of the rare motifs. Rather than having to almost max a crafting skill in order to use the motif, you can just buy it and completely sidestep all the work you used to have to do in order to use the skin. It would be functionally equivalent to putting Dark Seducer or Mannimarco costume in the Crown Store.
I don't have the numbers to calculate the amount of money, time, and material this is sidestepping, but it is significant. Even if this isn't considered pay to win by some, you have to at least admit it is a huge leap in that direction. It is very concerning. TBH with the amount of work and money this allows you to skip, I consider it way more p2w than the upcoming XP boost potions.
Others may or may not feel this way, but I've played since beta and never dropped my sub no matter what bugs, glitches, or lag. Even now with it b2p I still hold my sub because despite all the issues, they have shown a lot of effort towards making ESO a better gaming experience. This though is definitely strike one for me. Short of abolishing the motifs from the store, it is an irrevocable push towards the door.
Not just the level to use it but the level to find it. Daedric and AE don't even drop *at all* until you get into the V5+ zones and motifs like barbaric don't drop until the V1+ zones so now a level 1 person can just buy them immediately without even playing the game.
I have said this in other threads but we need to stop using P2W as the end all be all qualifier of what should/shouldn't be allowed in the store. The real qualifier should be whether the item is disruptive to the game somehow. It could be P2W items or items that disrupt the crafting system or economy or mounts/pets that don't fit with the theme/lore of the game. I think people would be just as pissed if they introduced motorcycles as mounts or sparkling rainbow ponies even if they weren't P2W. None of that crap should be in the store.
From Matt Firor:
“...“customization and convenience” items before. Simply put, this means that an item in the Crown Store serves one of two purposes: it either provides a visual upgrade or distinction for your character, or it provides a way to save time at the expense of spending crowns...”
Uhhh, there it is. Surprised? I don't see why. This opens up the door to pretty much EVERYTHING.
From Road Ahead - Feb
Back when they first made this particular announcement I posted a complaint to this effect. The term convenience is extremely vague and encompasses everything which falls under the p2w category. P2W by its very definition and implementation is a convenience. Paying gold farmers is a convenience are they going to allow them back too? The clarification Matt made in that statement did nothing to clarify the issue people were complaining about. Trying to pull a thing veil of words around a turd to try to trick people into being comforted more or less just confirmed this was the direction they were taking.People keep using the excuse that "it's cosmetic so it's not p2w". However it is not just cosmetic. The Crown Store version removes the rank requirement of the rare motifs. Rather than having to almost max a crafting skill in order to use the motif, you can just buy it and completely sidestep all the work you used to have to do in order to use the skin. It would be functionally equivalent to putting Dark Seducer or Mannimarco costume in the Crown Store.
I don't have the numbers to calculate the amount of money, time, and material this is sidestepping, but it is significant. Even if this isn't considered pay to win by some, you have to at least admit it is a huge leap in that direction. It is very concerning. TBH with the amount of work and money this allows you to skip, I consider it way more p2w than the upcoming XP boost potions.
Others may or may not feel this way, but I've played since beta and never dropped my sub no matter what bugs, glitches, or lag. Even now with it b2p I still hold my sub because despite all the issues, they have shown a lot of effort towards making ESO a better gaming experience. This though is definitely strike one for me. Short of abolishing the motifs from the store, it is an irrevocable push towards the door.
Not just the level to use it but the level to find it. Daedric and AE don't even drop *at all* until you get into the V5+ zones and motifs like barbaric don't drop until the V1+ zones so now a level 1 person can just buy them immediately without even playing the game.
I have said this in other threads but we need to stop using P2W as the end all be all qualifier of what should/shouldn't be allowed in the store. The real qualifier should be whether the item is disruptive to the game somehow. It could be P2W items or items that disrupt the crafting system or economy or mounts/pets that don't fit with the theme/lore of the game. I think people would be just as pissed if they introduced motorcycles as mounts or sparkling rainbow ponies even if they weren't P2W. None of that crap should be in the store.
I agree with you that P2W shouldn't be the ultimate qualifier, I used it because it is simply the easiest term to describe items of inequality. Disruptive items in general should not be in there. I just wanted to focus on the one aspect because I knew my complaint was already going to be lengthy.
From Matt Firor:
“...“customization and convenience” items before. Simply put, this means that an item in the Crown Store serves one of two purposes: it either provides a visual upgrade or distinction for your character, or it provides a way to save time at the expense of spending crowns...”
Uhhh, there it is. Surprised? I don't see why. This opens up the door to pretty much EVERYTHING.
From Road Ahead - Feb
Back when they first made this particular announcement I posted a complaint to this effect. The term convenience is extremely vague and encompasses everything which falls under the p2w category. P2W by its very definition and implementation is a convenience. Paying gold farmers is a convenience are they going to allow them back too? The clarification Matt made in that statement did nothing to clarify the issue people were complaining about. Trying to pull a thing veil of words around a turd to try to trick people into being comforted more or less just confirmed this was the direction they were taking.People keep using the excuse that "it's cosmetic so it's not p2w". However it is not just cosmetic. The Crown Store version removes the rank requirement of the rare motifs. Rather than having to almost max a crafting skill in order to use the motif, you can just buy it and completely sidestep all the work you used to have to do in order to use the skin. It would be functionally equivalent to putting Dark Seducer or Mannimarco costume in the Crown Store.
I don't have the numbers to calculate the amount of money, time, and material this is sidestepping, but it is significant. Even if this isn't considered pay to win by some, you have to at least admit it is a huge leap in that direction. It is very concerning. TBH with the amount of work and money this allows you to skip, I consider it way more p2w than the upcoming XP boost potions.
Others may or may not feel this way, but I've played since beta and never dropped my sub no matter what bugs, glitches, or lag. Even now with it b2p I still hold my sub because despite all the issues, they have shown a lot of effort towards making ESO a better gaming experience. This though is definitely strike one for me. Short of abolishing the motifs from the store, it is an irrevocable push towards the door.
Not just the level to use it but the level to find it. Daedric and AE don't even drop *at all* until you get into the V5+ zones and motifs like barbaric don't drop until the V1+ zones so now a level 1 person can just buy them immediately without even playing the game.
I have said this in other threads but we need to stop using P2W as the end all be all qualifier of what should/shouldn't be allowed in the store. The real qualifier should be whether the item is disruptive to the game somehow. It could be P2W items or items that disrupt the crafting system or economy or mounts/pets that don't fit with the theme/lore of the game. I think people would be just as pissed if they introduced motorcycles as mounts or sparkling rainbow ponies even if they weren't P2W. None of that crap should be in the store.
I agree with you that P2W shouldn't be the ultimate qualifier, I used it because it is simply the easiest term to describe items of inequality. Disruptive items in general should not be in there. I just wanted to focus on the one aspect because I knew my complaint was already going to be lengthy.
Yeah, I wasn't even directing my comment to you per se. I just keep seeing that term being used and then the discussion devolves into an argument about what is or isn't P2W but I think that is missing the bigger problems brought on by the cash shop.
Dukegaming wrote: »utzpretzels wrote: »This sucks.
Rare items belong in the game and you should have to play the game to get them.
There is now absolutely nothing special about motifs. I remember at launch what a huge deal it was to find one. Putting things like this on the store seems innocent at the start but ultimately detract from the overall fun of the game.
People said the drop rate of finding these were nerfed. I didn't beleieve them. Low and behold it makes sense why they were nerfed back then.
The drop rate of hirelings were nerfed recently. Makes me wonder if legendary materials are what's coming next.
The bad thing about motifs being available in the cash shop is that it will snowball into more and more in game items along with the high possibility of certain items drop rate being reduced to the point that people will just give in and go to the shop for what ever they want. This isn't my first,second,third,fourth merry~go~round with RPGs. I'm just basing my opinion from past experiences with cash shops in game.
Legendary mats in cash shops in 6 months to a year, watch.
No wonder, I thought something changed about hirelings. Its been about a month now since I've gotten a legendary mat. It does sound like a coincidence, nerf the drops so the demand ramps up, then introduce improvement materials into the Crownshop. I do hope this doesn't happen though.
In EVE Online you can buy 30day subscription for ingame money.
And noone cryes it's W2P.
Or you can buy ingame money for an item, that cost's a little bit more than 30day subscription.
And noone cryes it's P2W.
But of course, it's another game with another rules etc.
Dunno. Playing since 2009 and don't see it's...hm, P2W.If you google "Eve Online Pay to Win" There are pages upon pages of people discussing this, obviously someone is complaining about it. One particular forum post they were arguing about P2W back in 2013.
Does anyone know if you have to have your crafting to lvled to use the daedric motif bought from the crown shop?
In game you have to LVL crafting pretty high in order to use it, so I was just wondering if the crown store motifs are the same or no.
People keep using the excuse that "it's cosmetic so it's not p2w". However it is not just cosmetic. The Crown Store version removes the rank requirement of the rare motifs. Rather than having to almost max a crafting skill in order to use the motif, you can just buy it and completely sidestep all the work you used to have to do in order to use the skin. It would be functionally equivalent to putting Dark Seducer or Mannimarco costume in the Crown Store.
I don't have the numbers to calculate the amount of money, time, and material this is sidestepping, but it is significant. Even if this isn't considered pay to win by some, you have to at least admit it is a huge leap in that direction. It is very concerning. TBH with the amount of work and money this allows you to skip, I consider it way more p2w than the upcoming XP boost potions.
Others may or may not feel this way, but I've played since beta and never dropped my sub no matter what bugs, glitches, or lag. Even now with it b2p I still hold my sub because despite all the issues, they have shown a lot of effort towards making ESO a better gaming experience. This though is definitely strike one for me. Short of abolishing the motifs from the store, it is an irrevocable push towards the door.
Dunno. Playing since 2009 and don't see it's...hm, P2W.If you google "Eve Online Pay to Win" There are pages upon pages of people discussing this, obviously someone is complaining about it. One particular forum post they were arguing about P2W back in 2013.
You can buy stuff, gear, etc.. But you never will buy Character's Skills.
You can buy whole character with good skills for ingame money and do a transfer to your account with a PLEX(this P2W thing).
But.
It works as intended
Because all in EVE is, hm.... lootable and killable. And there is full loot system. When you lose - you lose all except character.
Ragged_Claw wrote: »People keep using the excuse that "it's cosmetic so it's not p2w". However it is not just cosmetic. The Crown Store version removes the rank requirement of the rare motifs. Rather than having to almost max a crafting skill in order to use the motif, you can just buy it and completely sidestep all the work you used to have to do in order to use the skin. It would be functionally equivalent to putting Dark Seducer or Mannimarco costume in the Crown Store.
I don't have the numbers to calculate the amount of money, time, and material this is sidestepping, but it is significant. Even if this isn't considered pay to win by some, you have to at least admit it is a huge leap in that direction. It is very concerning. TBH with the amount of work and money this allows you to skip, I consider it way more p2w than the upcoming XP boost potions.
Others may or may not feel this way, but I've played since beta and never dropped my sub no matter what bugs, glitches, or lag. Even now with it b2p I still hold my sub because despite all the issues, they have shown a lot of effort towards making ESO a better gaming experience. This though is definitely strike one for me. Short of abolishing the motifs from the store, it is an irrevocable push towards the door.
Couldn't agree more. Also why should some 'Johnny come lately' be able to wear my beautiful Daedric robe that it took me literally months to get, after levelling my crafting, getting to vet levels and hunting everywhere for the motif and materials. I know a lot of people think it's not a big deal, that it's nothing special, but it was to meI'm also considering whether to keep subbing or not, given that I play on both servers and now have to pay twice for anything I want from the crown shop anyway.
jamesharv2005ub17_ESO wrote: »Thing is the big crowd doesnt matter. The small percentage of people who will spend $1000s a year in cash shops are the ones they want to cater to. The big crowd just plays the game for free.
jamesharv2005ub17_ESO wrote: »Again its only pay to win if the stuff you pay for is better and not available any other way besides the store.
jamesharv2005ub17_ESO wrote: »Again its only pay to win if the stuff you pay for is better and not available any other way besides the store.
That's the problem. The crown rare motifs are better because you can learn them straight out of tutorial rather than having to almost max out your crafting to learn it. They are still available in the game, but take a significant amount of time to get. It also means you can buy the achievement and dye without putting in the effort to actually achieve it. Granted the dye is a brown iirc and not that significant. It would be like buying alliance ranks.