I want to vote "Yes"... or perhaps "No"... if there are no racial perks, it's nothing more then a popularity contest... the same poll could be "What is your favorite Race?"
I want to vote "Yes"... or perhaps "No"... if there are no racial perks, it's nothing more then a popularity contest... the same poll could be "What is your favorite Race?"
Which is exactly what this is @Hamfast. Well, not exactly. I'm interested in seeing two things:
- Which races are most associated with which role, and
- if the racial passives were mostly chosen right, which is looking good at the moment.
I want to vote "Yes"... or perhaps "No"... if there are no racial perks, it's nothing more then a popularity contest... the same poll could be "What is your favorite Race?"
Which is exactly what this is @Hamfast. Well, not exactly. I'm interested in seeing two things:
- Which races are most associated with which role, and
- if the racial passives were mostly chosen right, which is looking good at the moment.
We all associate races with classes due to the racial passives, even with the racial passives removed we will still associate the races because mentally we include the passives. Hence the majority will be Altmer, Breton, Dunmer and Argonian... then there are the folks that feel like they want the challenge of playing a "Weaker" race for a class will choose others (a Tarutaru Warrior or a Galka Mage in Final Fantasy).
I figure I should ask that folks that post, if they would be so kind include reasons... in my case, I do not like Altmer - they are snooty as a race, Dunmer are worse because they are snooty and think they need slaves to get things done, Nords seem to be the "Jock" race (Stupid, Drunk, Mussel Heads). Bosmer and Khajiit are "Sneaky" (this is not a slight, it's an ability), Red Guard and Orcs are more stoic, making good fighters... that leaves Breton's and Argonians as Spell Slingers. Argonans have more of a "Hive" mentality, making them better as healers... leaving Bretons as the mages.
AlexDougherty wrote: »I want to vote "Yes"... or perhaps "No"... if there are no racial perks, it's nothing more then a popularity contest... the same poll could be "What is your favorite Race?"
Which is exactly what this is @Hamfast. Well, not exactly. I'm interested in seeing two things:
- Which races are most associated with which role, and
- if the racial passives were mostly chosen right, which is looking good at the moment.
We all associate races with classes due to the racial passives, even with the racial passives removed we will still associate the races because mentally we include the passives. Hence the majority will be Altmer, Breton, Dunmer and Argonian... then there are the folks that feel like they want the challenge of playing a "Weaker" race for a class will choose others (a Tarutaru Warrior or a Galka Mage in Final Fantasy).
I figure I should ask that folks that post, if they would be so kind include reasons... in my case, I do not like Altmer - they are snooty as a race, Dunmer are worse because they are snooty and think they need slaves to get things done, Nords seem to be the "Jock" race (Stupid, Drunk, Mussel Heads). Bosmer and Khajiit are "Sneaky" (this is not a slight, it's an ability), Red Guard and Orcs are more stoic, making good fighters... that leaves Breton's and Argonians as Spell Slingers. Argonans have more of a "Hive" mentality, making them better as healers... leaving Bretons as the mages.
Um, being snooty is not a class, so ALtmer and Dunmer have not been assigned roles in that speech. Nor have Nords, who you have mistakenly identified as jocks, they are Warriors, maybe drunk but still warriors.
AlexDougherty wrote: »I want to vote "Yes"... or perhaps "No"... if there are no racial perks, it's nothing more then a popularity contest... the same poll could be "What is your favorite Race?"
Which is exactly what this is @Hamfast. Well, not exactly. I'm interested in seeing two things:
- Which races are most associated with which role, and
- if the racial passives were mostly chosen right, which is looking good at the moment.
We all associate races with classes due to the racial passives, even with the racial passives removed we will still associate the races because mentally we include the passives. Hence the majority will be Altmer, Breton, Dunmer and Argonian... then there are the folks that feel like they want the challenge of playing a "Weaker" race for a class will choose others (a Tarutaru Warrior or a Galka Mage in Final Fantasy).
I figure I should ask that folks that post, if they would be so kind include reasons... in my case, I do not like Altmer - they are snooty as a race, Dunmer are worse because they are snooty and think they need slaves to get things done, Nords seem to be the "Jock" race (Stupid, Drunk, Mussel Heads). Bosmer and Khajiit are "Sneaky" (this is not a slight, it's an ability), Red Guard and Orcs are more stoic, making good fighters... that leaves Breton's and Argonians as Spell Slingers. Argonans have more of a "Hive" mentality, making them better as healers... leaving Bretons as the mages.
Um, being snooty is not a class, so ALtmer and Dunmer have not been assigned roles in that speech. Nor have Nords, who you have mistakenly identified as jocks, they are Warriors, maybe drunk but still warriors.
If you read both my posts you will find that I first called this no more then a popularity contest, the OP sort of agreed and listed his reasons for the poll. I responded with the first part of the second post to his reply by pointing out there is a subconscious desire to use the racial passives when we define the rolls and so on...
At this point I responded to his information request with the added information of why and listed my views on the races, which have nothing really to do with classes in the case of Altmer, Dunmer and Nords... I just don't like them. This is not saying Altmer and Dunmer would not make good mages or Nords would not be good fighters, just that I do not like them, so in the popularity contest, they lose my vote before anything else is taken into account.
It was only after my second post that I actually voted in the poll... as my reasoning was spelled out in the post, I chose Breton.
AlexDougherty wrote: »AlexDougherty wrote: »I want to vote "Yes"... or perhaps "No"... if there are no racial perks, it's nothing more then a popularity contest... the same poll could be "What is your favorite Race?"
Which is exactly what this is @Hamfast. Well, not exactly. I'm interested in seeing two things:
- Which races are most associated with which role, and
- if the racial passives were mostly chosen right, which is looking good at the moment.
We all associate races with classes due to the racial passives, even with the racial passives removed we will still associate the races because mentally we include the passives. Hence the majority will be Altmer, Breton, Dunmer and Argonian... then there are the folks that feel like they want the challenge of playing a "Weaker" race for a class will choose others (a Tarutaru Warrior or a Galka Mage in Final Fantasy).
I figure I should ask that folks that post, if they would be so kind include reasons... in my case, I do not like Altmer - they are snooty as a race, Dunmer are worse because they are snooty and think they need slaves to get things done, Nords seem to be the "Jock" race (Stupid, Drunk, Mussel Heads). Bosmer and Khajiit are "Sneaky" (this is not a slight, it's an ability), Red Guard and Orcs are more stoic, making good fighters... that leaves Breton's and Argonians as Spell Slingers. Argonans have more of a "Hive" mentality, making them better as healers... leaving Bretons as the mages.
Um, being snooty is not a class, so ALtmer and Dunmer have not been assigned roles in that speech. Nor have Nords, who you have mistakenly identified as jocks, they are Warriors, maybe drunk but still warriors.
If you read both my posts you will find that I first called this no more then a popularity contest, the OP sort of agreed and listed his reasons for the poll. I responded with the first part of the second post to his reply by pointing out there is a subconscious desire to use the racial passives when we define the rolls and so on...
At this point I responded to his information request with the added information of why and listed my views on the races, which have nothing really to do with classes in the case of Altmer, Dunmer and Nords... I just don't like them. This is not saying Altmer and Dunmer would not make good mages or Nords would not be good fighters, just that I do not like them, so in the popularity contest, they lose my vote before anything else is taken into account.
It was only after my second post that I actually voted in the poll... as my reasoning was spelled out in the post, I chose Breton.
Sorry, I have been reading the thread, but not remembering what people have said.
Again sorry.