I posted this
in this thread here, but want to create a new topic for this in the hopes that an admin actually pays attention to it because it contains what they need to know about permanently missable quests in Shadowfen, and why so many people are stuck at 60/62 or 61/62.
I take a LOT of screenshots as I play. I have screenshots to confirm I've done every quest in Shadowfen except for the following:
Bound to the Bog
Eyes of the Enemy (Not currently in the game)
Hushed Whispers
Lost to the Mire (I think I did this, but don't have screenshots)
Overrun
Unwelcome Guests (I did it, but don't get Complete due to mercenary bug)
What Happened at Murkwater
Now I may have done any of these, but just didn't have screenshots for them is all. However, even after doing the group dungeon quest I am stuck at 60/62.
I believe some of these quests were possible to skip, going to a quest stage after it, and then you can never get the quest. For example, "Bound to the Bog" says"
"...and find Gerent Saervild Steel-Wind"
but in "Saving The Relics" I killed him, so obviously can't do "Bound to the Bog" now, assuming it's one of the ones I'm missing.
Also, "Hushed Whispers" description is:
I've found a scroll bearing marks from the Aldmeri Dominion. It details a series of unsolved murders in Stormhold.
I should inform Vicecanon Hrondar that the Aldmeri Dominion is aware of the murders.
I've done the Stormhold murder quest, but I don't recall this step leading to it. Again, I think this is a quest that's possible to skip and then never get in your completed quests list.
The description for "Overrun" is:
The Aldmeri Dominion has set up a staging area south of Hissmir in a fishing village called Murkwater.
I should look for Silent-Moss near and see how I can help him. I was told the fishing village is just southeast of Hissmir.
Currently, Silent-Moss stands in the middle of Murkwater with friends around a campfire and responds to me as if I did a quest with him. But I don't recall doing this quest that took you to him. Again, I think this is a quest that can be skipped ahead of and then missed forever.
The description for "What Happened at Murkwater" is:
Pale-Heart wants me to take word of our accomplishments to Hissmir.
I should go to Hissmir, northwest of Murkwater. I need to find Azinar.
I've gone to Hissmir and done the quests there, so once again this might be a quest to take you there that's possible to skip and then not be able to get after.
!!! ADMINS LISTEN UP !!! - I have screenshots that I've done ALL OTHER QUESTS NOT LISTED HERE! I am stuck at 60/62 even after doing the group dungeon quest. Therefore two or more (more likely more) quests of the 4 quests I've detailed are possible to skip and then become permanently missable. And "Unwelcome Guests" also needs resolving.
PLEASE pay attention to what I've written and use this information to fix things so we can finish Shadowfen and get our Achievement.
The best solution is to fix the quest "Unwelcome Guests", and to also lower the achievement from 62 needed quests down to 60, since there's no way to go back and do missable quests. ie: You can't do a quest involving an NPC you already killed in a later quest!
And for those people who got 62/62 and say it's possible, remember, the problem is with quests that are possible to skip ahead of, and then you're never able to do the earlier steps and get your quest counts for them. So if you did the earlier steps whereas somebody else didn't, those are quests you got that the other person will NEVER be able get.
P.S. The group dungeon quest for "Arx Corinium" called "Force of Nature" counts toward the Shadowfen achievement count even though it's not listed as one the 64 Shadowfen quests, so it's kind of bonus count, and not enough help for many people anyway.