When you say Skooma Cat is considered an aspect of Sheogorath, what does that mean? Who considers it so? I was under the impression that Daedric Princes could assume whatever form they wished, so Sheogorath could be a cat if he wanted. If Skooma Cat is just an aspect of him, that wasn't clear to me when I did that quest.
Unless he is summoned - though who would summon him - rereads the Cold Harbour Pact
https://en.uesp.net/wiki/Lore:Coldharbour_Compact
and Azura manifested herself through another I believe as well through a quest in ESO - or maybe she was summoned - I forget..
Unless he is summoned - though who would summon him - rereads the Cold Harbour Pact
https://en.uesp.net/wiki/Lore:Coldharbour_Compact
and Azura manifested herself through another I believe as well through a quest in ESO - or maybe she was summoned - I forget..
When you say Skooma Cat is considered an aspect of Sheogorath, what does that mean? Who considers it so? I was under the impression that Daedric Princes could assume whatever form they wished, so Sheogorath could be a cat if he wanted. If Skooma Cat is just an aspect of him, that wasn't clear to me when I did that quest.
It's a manifestation of a part of a deity in the mortal world, but not a full embodiment - limited power, possibly even limited knowledge/sentience. There's also a clear real-world inspiration, I think, but then I'll get a slap on my hand, as you know. I do think the Skooma Cat was refered to as an aspect somewhere in dialogue?
In any way, if the Coldharbor Compact is broken, I'd like to see the consequences. If it's not broken, I want to learn which means Sheogorath used, to do whatever he'd doing in the new story, so he doesn't break it.
I just want to see any lore explanation and possible consequences, and hope it won't just become one of these "deity tries to live amongs mortals but fails" comedy stories (there's dozens of movies about that, after all), with no deeper rooting in lore.
Unless he is summoned - though who would summon him - rereads the Cold Harbour Pact
https://en.uesp.net/wiki/Lore:Coldharbour_Compact
and Azura manifested herself through another I believe as well through a quest in ESO - or maybe she was summoned - I forget..
When you say Skooma Cat is considered an aspect of Sheogorath, what does that mean? Who considers it so? I was under the impression that Daedric Princes could assume whatever form they wished, so Sheogorath could be a cat if he wanted. If Skooma Cat is just an aspect of him, that wasn't clear to me when I did that quest.
It's a manifestation of a part of a deity in the mortal world, but not a full embodiment - limited power, possibly even limited knowledge/sentience. There's also a clear real-world inspiration, I think, but then I'll get a slap on my hand, as you know. I do think the Skooma Cat was refered to as an aspect somewhere in dialogue?

That doesn't answer the question though if that's supposed to be "full Sheo" appearing on Nirn, or an aspect of him that has manifested - basically like he sent part of his power to appear as some kind of embodiment on Nirn. An avatar basically. I think there was dialogue that called Skooma cat an aspect of Sheogorath, but I don't have time to search for that quote now, unfortunately.
allochthons wrote: »I can't walk past Sheogorath in Cyrodiil without thinking of the Calvin and Hobbes where Calvin says "Who was the guy who first looked at a cow and said, 'I think I'll drink whatever comes out of these things when I squeeze 'em?' "
Sheogorath was the one who saw a cow and went "I bet I can curdle that!"
I'm not looking forward to the Sheo quest line either. I was neutral until I saw the cheese location in Vvardenfell. I tired of the bit a long time ago. But maybe I'll be pleasantly surprised?
I don’t have any solid lore evidence (like “it said in x lorebook”) but I’m of the opinion that all the Princes we see are just manifestations. My belief is that the true form of a god is a sphere, thus the Princes are really their realms, though their manifestations still hold power (it’d be interesting to see how that holds up with Jyggalag if we ever see him again, since he is realmless (although follow-up to that, if he’s realmless because his realm is now the Shivering Isles… where did his Daedra come from when they invaded the Shivering Isles?)). Reason being is that, well, Masser and Secunda are spheres and that’s the corpse of Lorkhan. The “sun” is a circle, so Magnus leaving must’ve been him, as a sphere, floating away. Mannimarco’s ascension made the Necromancer Moon.
So… Sheogorath is the Shivering Isles and Skooma Cat is the form he chooses for when he sends part of himself to Elsweyr.
allochthons wrote: »I can't walk past Sheogorath in Cyrodiil without thinking of the Calvin and Hobbes where Calvin says "Who was the guy who first looked at a cow and said, 'I think I'll drink whatever comes out of these things when I squeeze 'em?' "
Sheogorath was the one who saw a cow and went "I bet I can curdle that!"
I'm not looking forward to the Sheo quest line either. I was neutral until I saw the cheese location in Vvardenfell. I tired of the bit a long time ago. But maybe I'll be pleasantly surprised?
If sending an aspect of oneself is a way to get around the Coldharbour Compact, why hasn't Molag Bal or Mehrunes Dagon done that? Or Meridia?
Calvin and Hobbes was a whimsical American newspaper comic strip from 1985-1995 about a curious six-year old who saw the world a bit differently, and his tiger.allochthons wrote: »I can't walk past Sheogorath in Cyrodiil without thinking of the Calvin and Hobbes where Calvin says "Who was the guy who first looked at a cow and said, 'I think I'll drink whatever comes out of these things when I squeeze 'em?' "
Sheogorath was the one who saw a cow and went "I bet I can curdle that!"
I'm not looking forward to the Sheo quest line either. I was neutral until I saw the cheese location in Vvardenfell. I tired of the bit a long time ago. But maybe I'll be pleasantly surprised?
I don't get that joke (I'm not from North America, so perhaps I'm missing context?). People observe their surroundings. They see how animals feed their offspring. They know how they feed their own offspring. The thought "This is nourishment; if it feeds their young, maybe it can feed ours, too." isn't too complicated (if it had been for humans, mankind would have died out long ago). (And there's a tribe that feeds abandoned deer with their own human milk, too.) I don't think what ever Sheogorath does has anything to do with imitating something he saw.
If sending an aspect of oneself is a way to get around the Coldharbour Compact, why hasn't Molag Bal or Mehrunes Dagon done that? Or Meridia?
I'm wondering how capable these manifestations of Sheogorath that we see in game even are. Maybe it's indeed just a projection with no real power (not much, or nothing at all)? I can't exactly remember the visuals of the quests in Southpoint and as Skooma Cat anymore. Do we actually see Sheogorath do anything more than revealing himself and talking? Does he utilize some dangerous power on screen? Otherwise all that happened could have as well been the work of a daedra worshipper who acted as Sheogorath's champion, while he was only there as an observer.
And if Sheogorath himself is really just a powerless manifestation there, basically barely more than a projection, that should be no breach of the Coldharbor Compact; as that agreement forbids the daedric princes to interfere directly in mortal life on Nirn. We know having a champion and letting that person do things in a daedric prince's name does not go against the agreement.
In any way, I hope the Compact is considered in the upcoming Sheogorath story. Maybe what we'll see of him will indeed just be a powerless manifestation and the trouble he causes will not be based on daedric power, but really on how he gets things wrong when interacting with mortals? We'll see.
However he finagled his way onto Nirn, and however much power he's directly using, he's definitely not there just as an observer. In Southpoint he brings the player character in with the idea that it will inspire Aulus to cause more chaos and insanity. In Two Moons, he's actively interfering with Moon-Bishop Sizenza throughout the quest. So it does seem to me he is breaking the Coldharbour Compact. I'm guessing the reason Sil didn't do anything about it was because he wasn't precisely himself while this was going on.
However he finagled his way onto Nirn, and however much power he's directly using, he's definitely not there just as an observer. In Southpoint he brings the player character in with the idea that it will inspire Aulus to cause more chaos and insanity. In Two Moons, he's actively interfering with Moon-Bishop Sizenza throughout the quest. So it does seem to me he is breaking the Coldharbour Compact. I'm guessing the reason Sil didn't do anything about it was because he wasn't precisely himself while this was going on.
Interesting. I like that Haduras at least mentioned that coming to Nirn would normally be impossible for Sheogorath. It's a pity though that we never actually see any reaction on him breaking the rules (if what Sheogorath did there is considered that, and it's not just about huge invasions like the one on Old Mournhold or the attack on Gil-var-delle back then). If, in the new story, again nothing happens (and I somehow don't think anything will happen - they probably want to keep the Coldharbor Compact somewhat of a mystery; or even if they'd decide to reveal some part of it, I don't think that something that meaningful could be put well into a six-quest story?), could it still be explained with Sil being in the state he is before the CWC story is completed? We've been told last year that time had progressed, but never how much.
So a lot of people keep mentioning the Skooma cat quest. It isn't explicitly said to be an aspect but it likely is. When he reveals himself to the player character as the Sheo it is in his plane. Also if princes could just manifest themselves on Nirn then the whole plane meld base game and Solstice plots would be pointless. We also see this with the TES IV oblivion crisis and with the Blackwoods/Deadlands quest lines. They are trying to destroy Nirn or merge Nirn with their own planes. So yes Sheo has been manifesting aspects of himself on Nirn and meddling a bit where he is able to but he tends to spirit people away to the Shivering Isles once he really wants to mess with them.
Also there are a number of quest lines, including the base game quest line where we see other daedric Princes get upset that another prince is doing stuff.
I'm curious, too, about how much time is meant to have progressed. If previously everything was happening in the same year, then it would seem to me that time has progressed for every previous zone/chapter/story. So Sil should be fully Sil this time. Of course, if Sheogorath is on Nirn as a mortal, without power, doing the equivalent of sight-seeing--that's probably not against the Compact. Any chaos that ensues might not be his doing directly. I have a feeling Sheogorath is always going to find some loophole in the Compact if he's ever actually pressed to account for his actions.
Side note: was it the Sheogorath quest line that is comprised of six quests? I thought Thieves Guild was six, and Sheogorath was eight. Either way, both of them are set to be fairly lengthy and involved, which I like.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=jVjE88kBxwkThe house isn't Kushalit Sanctuary. I'm not sure where it is, but when they showed it on the stream, it was a standard looking house from the outside, and Sheogorath house on the inside--much larger than the outside would lead you to believe. They also mentioned that there's a possibility the house might become player housing in the future.
As for the images--it's hard to know what the story thread is from a few disparate images in a trailer. In the ESO direct stream from the 31st of March, the story was explained as Sheogorath wants to see what it's like to be a mortal, so he divests himself of his power and comes to Tamriel. His power is then grabbed somehow by someone--or they attempt to grab it anyway--and chaos happens. So if Sheogorath is meant to be without power, I doubt he would be the one turning things into other things. He may just be enjoying the chaos. Or, if he doesn't like his power being used by someone else, he may be trying to figure out how to get his power back.
Maybe it was the Bosmer then that grabbed his power..
The house that is seen in this video - would it be the Kushalit Sanctuary

Did you summon Sheorgorath then
