BejaProphet wrote: »Not the point of the thread, but...
I truly believe that in the presence of a good group a tank chaining, stacking and keeping group still does way more for team DPS than a DD with a taunt will.
Not when a DD is channelling heavy lightning attacks, fire off 3 silver shards in a row, then a Jesus beam at 80% health, drop their ultimate 20 foot away from the boss and then stand in an aoe and die.
cynicalbutterfly wrote: »BejaProphet wrote: »Not the point of the thread, but...
I truly believe that in the presence of a good group a tank chaining, stacking and keeping group still does way more for team DPS than a DD with a taunt will.
Not when a DD is channelling heavy lightning attacks, fire off 3 silver shards in a row, then a Jesus beam at 80% health, drop their ultimate 20 foot away from the boss and then stand in an aoe and die.
My former healer is cringing at this. I can't tell you how many people I've seen do exactly this type of thing LOL
BejaProphet wrote: »Not the point of the thread, but...
I truly believe that in the presence of a good group a tank chaining, stacking and keeping group still does way more for team DPS than a DD with a taunt will.
Not when a DD is channelling heavy lightning attacks, fire off 3 silver shards in a row, then a Jesus beam at 80% health, drop their ultimate 20 foot away from the boss and then stand in an aoe and die.
I can give them all the warhorns in the world, but major force applied to a skill hitting for about 478 damage crit is not doing way more than I can do while doing DPS.
I had a group of CP 170 - 530 in NORMAL darkshade 2 the other day. They all died on the last boss from the poison. Including the healer. Not poking fun or anything, but then what do I do as a full on tank? Res them to die at next poison wave?
No thanks. I'll taunt the big stuff and keep my dps. Sorry I'm not stacking them together for people to just use single target skills on them anyway.
Sorry to the actual DPS that would benefit from those things, but I ain't taking the risk.
colossalvoids wrote: »This thread made me feel better lol. I was never queueing as a tank before the last update so kinda felt like cheating the queue but I guess no one really cares if I'm just pale order DD with inner rage and silver leash.
Mostly when someone says a fake tank it is someone who is DPS or PVPer who thinks that are too good to wait in queue for DPS and just want the massive XP and transmutes you get for daily random. The really bad ones not only don't have a taunt, they don't know the mechanics and treat every dungeon like an XP grind. But don't realize all the adds don't just pile up like regular grinds so you can nuke them all in a corner.
This isn't just fake tanks, fake DPS who are impatient do the same thing. After years of tanking, and being able to quickly go from one trash pack to the next, pulling everything into a pile and having the team drop literally 2 aoes each and kill the whole pile in one rotation. Now I got these ? saying the piles should be bigger and running past me thinking they can be more efficient and just scattering adds all over the place that the rest of the team has to chase and kill one by one.
I think there is a massive amount of impatient toxic people who got all their experience doing shortcuts like XP grinds, and don't care about mechanics or other people at all. They just want XP, gear, transmutes, so they can get back to cyro, BG or trial dummy and brag about how great their DPS is. But don't want to really have fun, experience the game, or interact with anyone in a positive way.
And actually it is so easy, for any stam DPS you have just put on leeching, azureblight, slot inner fire, pierce armor, silver leash, caltrops. And you can do all the taunting, pulling and even explode rooms of adds. Simple really, any boss who has conal aoe/heavy taunt then point away from team. Pull all ranged adds into pile. Ranged taunt melee adds to come to you (DPS let adds get piled up then drop aoes). DPS/Healer if monster aggros on you don't run around room, bring to tank pile so they can taunt and take off you. Following a few simple techniques can make all dungeon encounters pretty easy actually.
BTW anyone who is interested in learning how to tank and mechanics should check out Xynodegaming. He is the only streamer/youtuber I've seen who has the balls to constantly do Vet random dungeons and DLCs with pugs and teaches a lot about tanking and other things.
Or some of us have done Spindleclutch one 6843974 times and don't want to pull 4 adds at a time.
Why is it toxic because I want something done quickly? People overuse the word toxic waaaaay too much.
BejaProphet wrote: »So my daughter wants to do ESO dungeons with me. I’m thrilled. I’m doing a dungeon with her. Period. I want her to have the best experience possible because I want her to love it.
After thinking about all that can go wrong in dungeon finder, and the best way to head it all off, I actually decide to do something I’ve always been against. I queued as a fake tank.
If I went in my serious tank set up it could expose how little she contributed. I didn’t want the group to be mean to her because she couldn’t DPS on her level 10 sorc, and I didn’t want a tank who would let her die due to being a fake tank who would not protect her. So I took my DD set up (which is pretty tanky because it is my tank in all damage gear, food, mundus, and skills), and I just threw inner fire on my bar.
It went wonderfully. I was the highest damage dealer both runs, so we had a great pace. I taunted bosses and anything that I knew I didn’t want pounding on my kid. Nothing could kill me cuz I’m still tanky and using vigor and brawler. But the grouping was trash and I mostly just did damage.
But then I ask myself? Was I a fake tank, or a real one? I did take the dangerous targets after all.
So what makes a tank fake? Was what I did bad when it was motivated by giving others the best run possible?
Fake tank for most is someone who doesn't hold aggro.
Taunt boss and big adds that hit hard and don't die. Nobody cares beyond that.
I have a few characters setup as essentially DPS but with chunky health and a taunt. Nobody has ever said anything.
This one is the clincher for me. If you can't even hold aggro you're not a tank, end of. Beyond that we can discuss if they're fake, bad or simply ignorant.
Or some of us have done Spindleclutch one 6843974 times and don't want to pull 4 adds at a time.
Why is it toxic because I want something done quickly? People overuse the word toxic waaaaay too much.
BejaProphet wrote: »INe_Saninus wrote: »On a normal dungeon?
Not having a taunt to hold the boss in place and not having enough health/resist to keep it in place.
That's really it.
Like, seriously. I don't care what else you're doing. What class you are. Hell, bring those deeps! Let's get through this quickly and efficiently.
On vet?
That's a whole other story. You'd better be the real deal.
...but I don't play vet with randoms.
Why would you?!
...and if I do (again, why would I do this?) I have zero expectations and am usually still let down.
I'll wait for a buddy to get on. 2 of us can usually pull 2 randoms through.
...and one of us usually tanks! Lol
Vet DLC dungeons are too challenging for a random group.
I enjoy pug tanking vet DLCs
Elendir2am wrote: »
Or some of us have done Spindleclutch one 6843974 times and don't want to pull 4 adds at a time.
Why is it toxic because I want something done quickly? People overuse the word toxic waaaaay too much.
Such comment I don’t understand at all. I am not such badass like you. I did all dungeons only hundred times, but a can clear mobs from room in normal easy dungeons during 2 second and difficult 5 second (with my DPSs). Elite mobs are exception, the take one or two shoot more.
So, if you are soooooo good, you should be able do it during run, shouldn’t you?
INe_Saninus wrote: »BejaProphet wrote: »INe_Saninus wrote: »On a normal dungeon?
Not having a taunt to hold the boss in place and not having enough health/resist to keep it in place.
That's really it.
Like, seriously. I don't care what else you're doing. What class you are. Hell, bring those deeps! Let's get through this quickly and efficiently.
On vet?
That's a whole other story. You'd better be the real deal.
...but I don't play vet with randoms.
Why would you?!
...and if I do (again, why would I do this?) I have zero expectations and am usually still let down.
I'll wait for a buddy to get on. 2 of us can usually pull 2 randoms through.
...and one of us usually tanks! Lol
Vet DLC dungeons are too challenging for a random group.
I enjoy pug tanking vet DLCs
Well, bless you, sir.
That life ain't for me.
My buddy and I actually started the game as a tank and healer.
After realizing that most randoms have about 8k dps, we switched over to dps.
It's easier to get through a vet with amazing DPS and mediocre tank/healer than it is with an amazing tank/healer and mediocre dps in my experience.
BejaProphet wrote: »So my daughter wants to do ESO dungeons with me. I’m thrilled. I’m doing a dungeon with her. Period. I want her to have the best experience possible because I want her to love it.
After thinking about all that can go wrong in dungeon finder, and the best way to head it all off, I actually decide to do something I’ve always been against. I queued as a fake tank.
If I went in my serious tank set up it could expose how little she contributed. I didn’t want the group to be mean to her because she couldn’t DPS on her level 10 sorc, and I didn’t want a tank who would let her die due to being a fake tank who would not protect her. So I took my DD set up (which is pretty tanky because it is my tank in all damage gear, food, mundus, and skills), and I just threw inner fire on my bar.
It went wonderfully. I was the highest damage dealer both runs, so we had a great pace. I taunted bosses and anything that I knew I didn’t want pounding on my kid. Nothing could kill me cuz I’m still tanky and using vigor and brawler. But the grouping was trash and I mostly just did damage.
But then I ask myself? Was I a fake tank, or a real one? I did take the dangerous targets after all.
So what makes a tank fake? Was what I did bad when it was motivated by giving others the best run possible?
BejaProphet wrote: »INe_Saninus wrote: »BejaProphet wrote: »INe_Saninus wrote: »On a normal dungeon?
Not having a taunt to hold the boss in place and not having enough health/resist to keep it in place.
That's really it.
Like, seriously. I don't care what else you're doing. What class you are. Hell, bring those deeps! Let's get through this quickly and efficiently.
On vet?
That's a whole other story. You'd better be the real deal.
...but I don't play vet with randoms.
Why would you?!
...and if I do (again, why would I do this?) I have zero expectations and am usually still let down.
I'll wait for a buddy to get on. 2 of us can usually pull 2 randoms through.
...and one of us usually tanks! Lol
Vet DLC dungeons are too challenging for a random group.
I enjoy pug tanking vet DLCs
Well, bless you, sir.
That life ain't for me.
My buddy and I actually started the game as a tank and healer.
After realizing that most randoms have about 8k dps, we switched over to dps.
It's easier to get through a vet with amazing DPS and mediocre tank/healer than it is with an amazing tank/healer and mediocre dps in my experience.
You are right about how crippling bad DD’s can be. But I fi d vet DLCs usually scare those off.
I just wanted to point out that "needs to hold still" demand. While most bosses can be held still there are many that can't. I've been called out by pugs who dont know mechs. When I first started tanking I received hate from several groups in Darkshade 1 last boss, when he does his spinning and chases random player. Also Frostvault 1st boss, he jumps on people and punches them in air, also Scalecaller last boss just to name few. Just last week some inexperienced pug raged on me in vHRC last boss when he kept jumping on people because they stayed too far lol.
People who demand real tanks or judge them, make sure you know the fight before you criticize. Or make your own tank and serve salty pugs.
Zodiarkslayer wrote: »A fake tank is a monkey.
Jumping, Screeching and flinging his own metabolism end product at people, who call them out.
Zodiarkslayer wrote: »A fake tank is a monkey.
Jumping, Screeching and flinging his own metabolism end product at people, who call them out.
BejaProphet wrote: »So my daughter wants to do ESO dungeons with me. I’m thrilled. I’m doing a dungeon with her. Period. I want her to have the best experience possible because I want her to love it.
After thinking about all that can go wrong in dungeon finder, and the best way to head it all off, I actually decide to do something I’ve always been against. I queued as a fake tank.
If I went in my serious tank set up it could expose how little she contributed. I didn’t want the group to be mean to her because she couldn’t DPS on her level 10 sorc, and I didn’t want a tank who would let her die due to being a fake tank who would not protect her. So I took my DD set up (which is pretty tanky because it is my tank in all damage gear, food, mundus, and skills), and I just threw inner fire on my bar.
It went wonderfully. I was the highest damage dealer both runs, so we had a great pace. I taunted bosses and anything that I knew I didn’t want pounding on my kid. Nothing could kill me cuz I’m still tanky and using vigor and brawler. But the grouping was trash and I mostly just did damage.
But then I ask myself? Was I a fake tank, or a real one? I did take the dangerous targets after all.
So what makes a tank fake? Was what I did bad when it was motivated by giving others the best run possible?