I have fished in each of the fishing holes in Artaeum (some more than once) but still not caught one rare fish. I have been using simple bait as it is near impossible to get worms or chub on Summerset atm. I find that my return is about 7-9 used bait for each 15 cast hole. I think this is really high and, of course, only happens with simple bait. I have fished nearly all the waters (in 2 of the 3 alliances) in the live game, and got quite a few of the achievements but never with simple bait, so cannot compare if this is as it should be. Is this only happening in Summerset, or is this how the live game works too? Have I no hope of catching rare fish with simple bait? If so, then the help/information should state this. I understand that it might still be necessary to buy simple bait if all you want is fish for provisioning, but I think it should say that this is not the ideal bait for rare fish (or something like that).