sotha sil choice. what should I choose?

Danteanz

power or Luciana

what will sotha sil give if I choose power or Luciana

Woeler

I got a 2 hour 150% xp scroll when I chose power

Danteanz

Woeler wrote: »

I got a 2 hour 150% xp scroll when I chose power

oh thx!

quake89

I chose to save the damsel in distress and received a 100% XP scroll for 2 hours. just encase any one was wondering what the other option gave

Danteanz

quake89 wrote: »

I chose to save the damsel in distress and received a 100% XP scroll for 2 hours. just encase any one was wondering what the other option gave

I chose that one too. lol

DPShiro

So the rewards are identical no matter what you choose?

zaria

DPShiro wrote: »

So the rewards are identical no matter what you choose?

150% or 100% xp scroll if you save the lady.

DPShiro

zaria wrote: »

DPShiro wrote: »

So the rewards are identical no matter what you choose?

150% or 100% xp scroll if you save the lady.

So useless either way =/

SecretAtoz

Thank God. I thought I missed a skill point if I didn't choose power.

TheRimOfTheSky

Luciana has been alive for over 800 years now. Her son, Marius, died a long time ago, which is the reason behind her stern behavior. If you choose not to save her she says she's cool with it and that she can finally go to heaven and be with her son.

zaria

DPShiro wrote: »

zaria wrote: »

DPShiro wrote: »

So the rewards are identical no matter what you choose?

150% or 100% xp scroll if you save the lady.

So useless either way =/

Not useless, but not not something you just need to have. You can buy it for gold, however going for long term buff over high short term will pay off a lot,

Aliyavana

DPShiro wrote: »

zaria wrote: »

DPShiro wrote: »

So the rewards are identical no matter what you choose?

150% or 100% xp scroll if you save the lady.

So useless either way =/

the good choice you save a person and get a scroll whose buff you can craft, or sacrifice her for a better scroll you can craft... if you rp a good person its better to take the good choice

bottleofsyrup

You also can't bank the scroll, so if you did the storyline on your main like I did, the extra 50% is especially useless.

Arantesovelha

bottleofsyrup wrote: »

You also can't bank the scroll, so if you did the storyline on your main like I did, the extra 50% is especially useless.

Why zenimax, why???

I wil be sooooo better just pass that to my low lvl char

BigBadVolk

you get the same thing

TheShadowScout

The rewards are so close, that the extra XP is not really worth anything. Thus each can choose how their character might like... "good" characters can choose to rescue the damsel in distress (well... more like, have sotha sil resurrect her once again, likely with even more clockwork bits), not quite so good characters can grasp for power and get... slightly dissapointed.

Not like it gives you skill points like feeding Valaste to Shoegorath, but I guess that's the difference between a reward from a deadric prince and a mere imposter god... but look at the bright side, at least you did not merely get a flashlight from the trinket shop like back when you helped Almalexia with her temple...

krullskull

Saving her from being re-united with her son in heaven when she’s already 800 years old and will die yet again anyway, doesn't seem to be a very sympathetic (good) act, in fact it’s more selfish to bring her back from the dead just because you want her around.
Where as, on the other hand, the extra 50% xp for choosing power can help you get CPs quicker, making it a bit easier to defeat the bad and revenge, protect and unite the good of Tamriel.

Apache_Kid

bottleofsyrup wrote: »

You also can't bank the scroll, so if you did the storyline on your main like I did, the extra 50% is especially useless.

.....................

You can't bank it????

Why does that make any sense whatsoever

Yarlenzey

Apache_Kid wrote: »

bottleofsyrup wrote: »

You also can't bank the scroll, so if you did the storyline on your main like I did, the extra 50% is especially useless.

.....................

You can't bank it????

Why does that make any sense whatsoever

It makes sense to someone. Otherwise they wouldn't have done it.

Apache_Kid

Yarlenzey wrote: »

Apache_Kid wrote: »

bottleofsyrup wrote: »

You also can't bank the scroll, so if you did the storyline on your main like I did, the extra 50% is especially useless.

.....................

You can't bank it????

Why does that make any sense whatsoever

It makes sense to someone. Otherwise they wouldn't have done it.

That someone didn't think about the scenario of the many players who complete the quest-line at full-CP.

It's a small thing to be sure, but I picked the power option and receive no benefit from it now. Not being able to bank it is one of the more moronic things I've heard this week.

Sweetpea704

The reward sucks either way if you are on your achievement toon, who doesn't really have ANY use for a scroll that can't even be put in the bank to use for an alt. Skill points would have been better.

Everstorm

aliyavana wrote: »

DPShiro wrote: »

zaria wrote: »

DPShiro wrote: »

So the rewards are identical no matter what you choose?

150% or 100% xp scroll if you save the lady.

So useless either way =/

the good choice you save a person and get a scroll whose buff you can craft, or sacrifice her for a better scroll you can craft... if you rp a good person its better to take the good choice

She seemed very content with finally being allowed to die. Not sure if keeping her alive would be the "good" choice.

LadyDestiny

I got the xp scroll, gloves and 1 skill point for choosing power.

Charoshy

It would have been nice if I could ask him to fix the artificial light on the farm. That quest left me with a bad taste in my mouth.

TheShadowScout

Charoshy wrote: »

It would have been nice if I could ask him to fix the artificial light on the farm. That quest left me with a bad taste in my mouth.

Indeed, it makes eating clockwork city produce a bit... ehhh. Makes me wonder why noone there thought of the obvious alternatives yet... I mean, there -are- criminals even in clockwork city, right? So...

karekiz

.Dates

ADarklore

I have yet to do this quest... but seems to me, as others have said, that denying her death so she can join her son is NOT the 'good choice' but the selfish choice- especially since it's just prolonging her suffering and anguish. Imagine if you, yourself was in the same situation... and someone had the choice of letting you die to be with your children or remain alive and continue to be miserable without them. What choice would you make for YOURSELF?

majulook

Character bound rewards are not good. When its my 900cp Nightblade ever gonna use this?

Nightfall12

man i just want the Knight of Marrow back...

DoctorESO

Danteanz wrote: »

power or Luciana

what will sotha sil give if I choose power or Luciana

Save Luciana. If you don't, it will haunt you for the rest of your life.

Absolut_Turkey

ADarklore wrote: »

I have yet to do this quest... but seems to me, as others have said, that denying her death so she can join her son is NOT the 'good choice' but the selfish choice- especially since it's just prolonging her suffering and anguish. Imagine if you, yourself was in the same situation... and someone had the choice of letting you die to be with your children or remain alive and continue to be miserable without them. What choice would you make for YOURSELF?

No...saving Luciana IS the good choice. Sotha Sil says that she will put this “gift” to great use, and Luciana is grateful for what you’ve done for her and vows to continue to serve in her duties faithfully. There is NO HINT WHATSOEVER that Luciana would have preferred to die.