Do we need a PvP Master Guild (Like a Dungeon Master) ?

Rune_Relic

At the moment we can have the whole population on each faction facing off in the same place.
We can have one faction sending 72 to a keep vs another sending 24.
We can have lots of keeps and resources and most of the map ignored with small scale non-existant.
We have zergs just steam rolling everything in their path.
Its nothing but a guild vs guild free for all really rather than faction vs faction

With the old dungeon games... we had a dungeon master to set the scene, the story and the combat rules of engagement.
Do we need something like that in Cyrodiil campaigns ?
Can any guilds be trusted to take on such a role without fixing the contests ?
Would everyone agree to abide by the PvP Masters strategies ?
Is such a thing even desired....are we happy with this free for all ?

EDIT: Is ESO to blame for the sorry state of PvP...or us ?

Mojmir

So you want a referee?

Rune_Relic

Mojmir wrote: »

So you want a referee?

Seems weird doesnt it. But yes kind of. Lmao.

ZOS has given us the tools to create all the content we need....other players.
Surely the Onus is on us to create/structure/organise the content, just as much as ZOS ?
We dont think twice about organising Dueling tournaments ?

ScooberSteve

Um i would settle for having 1 crappy guild at the moment because pvp is rubbish and no 1 wants to take part

Rune_Relic

ScooberSteve wrote: »

Um i would settle for having 1 crappy guild at the moment because pvp is rubbish and no 1 wants to take part

Cant argue with that
/shrugs

Just thought it would be nice for each faction to go to a keep and know they will be facing another 1x12 man team
Just thought it would be nice for each faction to go to a bridge and know they will be facing another 1x24 man team
Just thought it would be nice for each faction to go to a resource and know they will be facing another 1x4 man team

Maybe after a while decide if 4 self sustaining builds is actually better than 1 tank 1 healer 1 single target dd and 1 aoe dd as a unit.
That kind of thing is pointless when its 20v4.

People scream battelgrounds....and yet...they could do that right now.

Etaniel

Zos is to blame for the balance, and the players are to blame for the ridiculous circle jerk around the imperial city.

Like Fengrush said it's a train track, and people just follow the track to the next keep like idiots.
You barely ever see people running around the next keep to hit the enemy home keeps to create a diversion, you only ever see one Zerg for the faction, one 12-20 man guildgroup farming the other factions' zerg and a total of 5 idiots trying to small scale.

It's 90% up to the players to go hit the outer rim keeps and retake the towns to create action in various places of the map.
And 10% up to the devs to change up the map.

Rune_Relic

@Etaniel cant argue with you.
Thats exactly how I see it.
Its only us that can change the way we use the PvP system...gameplay
I see all the keeps, bridges, resources merely as props ZOS has provided us to help with that gameplay.
The Onus is on ZOS to fix the balance and the bugs.

Rune_Relic

@FENGRUSH
Some of what you write I agree with. Some of what you write I hate.
But many many people value your opinion.
I would appreciate your thoughts here too if you dont mind.
Good or Bad.

Any solution has to bring everyone on board.

Anazasi

I'm sorry but i just have not had enough coffee to care about this idea.