Weighted trait, increased weapon attack speed, doesn't seem to effect speed of staff heavy attacks..

Lonewolf628

There doesn't seem to be an increase in the speed of my flame staff heavy attack with the weighted trait. Can anyone confirm this and is this working as intended? If it isn't supposed to effect my staff heavy attacks then what is it supposed to do? My staff heavy attack is considered a weapon attack is it not? Or because it's a magic weapon it won't be effected?

Forestd16b14_ESO

I think the trait is broken but just no-body cares about it to ask ZOS to fix it

Lynx7386

Trait has been broken since launch, pretty much.

GreenGhostMan

If broken and no plans to fix it to do what it was intended to do, then why not change it to something that players will use?

Lynx7386

Because, like everything else going wrong with this game, ZOS hasnt come up with a way to market it for crowns yet. Nothing gets fixed unless it directly results in revenue.

danno8

Lynx7386 wrote: »

Because, like everything else going wrong with this game, ZOS hasnt come up with a way to market it for crowns yet. Nothing gets fixed unless it directly results in revenue.

More like ZoS knows that no one uses light or heavy attacks back to back, but instead animation cancels them, making the trait completely useless even if it worked perfectly.

So this is very low down on the priority list.

Lynx7386

So it should be changed. Weighted could just as easily reduce stamina and magicka costs instead

Lonewolf628

I'm was going to use it on my staff for faster heavy attacks to replenish majicka faster. Oh well

Silver_Strider

At one point, I really wanted to use Weighted so that I could proc Merciless Resolve quicker.
Real shame it doesn't work though but honestly if it doesn't work, the least they could do is change it to the Stamina equivalent of Nirnhoned and give Physical Pen and Resist

danno8

Silver_Strider wrote: »

At one point, I really wanted to use Weighted so that I could proc Merciless Resolve quicker.
Real shame it doesn't work though but honestly if it doesn't work, the least they could do is change it to the Stamina equivalent of Nirnhoned and give Physical Pen and Resist

But instead of reducing the animation by some small %, you can clip the whole animation by using animation cancelling. Waiting on the full animation to finish, even with the (working) trait would most definitely end up being a DPS loss in any scenario.

So yes, they need to rework this.

Forestd16b14_ESO

danno8 wrote: »

Silver_Strider wrote: »

At one point, I really wanted to use Weighted so that I could proc Merciless Resolve quicker.
Real shame it doesn't work though but honestly if it doesn't work, the least they could do is change it to the Stamina equivalent of Nirnhoned and give Physical Pen and Resist

But instead of reducing the animation by some small %, you can clip the whole animation by using animation cancelling. Waiting on the full animation to finish, even with the (working) trait would most definitely end up being a DPS loss in any scenario.

So yes, they need to rework this.

Well how you are putting it only way I can see weighted being any good is if ZOS got rid of animation cancellation completely which me personally am not apposed too.

Like weighted does kinda prove that ZOS never intended animation cancellation but after all the post and this and that about it and probably not knowing how to remove it or to lazy too then decided that it be easier and "make them look better" when they said "oh we put it in on purpose and don't plan on removing it".

Like why even have weighted if they "intended" players just to scrap the animation of attacks going even faster than the weighted trait gives.

Lynx7386

Animation cancelling was a bug at first, and ZOS decided it was going to be too difficult to 'fix' so they just made it an 'intended feature'.

Like I keep saying, they need to completely change the weighted trait, it doesnt work with this system. Having weighted reduce ability stamina/magicka costs would be a good solution.

Forestd16b14_ESO

Lynx7386 wrote: »

Animation cancelling was a bug at first, and ZOS decided it was going to be too difficult to 'fix' so they just made it an 'intended feature'.

Like I keep saying, they need to completely change the weighted trait, it doesnt work with this system. Having weighted reduce ability stamina/magicka costs would be a good solution.

uuuuuuuuhhhhhhhhhhhh sorry that's just a little to over powered.

Lynx7386

How so? I gave no hard numbers. You can already get cost reduction via jewelry enchants, champion points, and armor passives.

just as a possibility:
Common weighted trait: 1% stamina/magicka cost reduction
Uncommon: 2%
Rare: 3%
Epic: 4%
Legendary: 5%

Whatever it is, if anyone is going to use the trait it has to be made competitive with other options. You have to look at a trait and go "hey, that might actually be worth giving up 3% crit chance, or 5% damage reduction.

Didaco

Ok, from an animation canceling perspective, Weighted is useless.
What about the chance to restore resources though? A medium attack doesn't give me anything.
It has its uses.

Btw I didn't know it was broken. And from launch.
The heck is wrong with this SH?

olsborg

This is eso, stuff thats broken stay in the game for atleast a year or two, and when they fix it they break 2 more things...the circle of eso..

jbcrocks

Omg it's bugged?!

r.jan_emailb16_ESO

I've read somewhere that it reduces the time you have to wait between actual skills, but I never tested it.

Emma_Overload

r.jan_emailb16_ESO wrote: »

I've read somewhere that it reduces the time you have to wait between actual skills, but I never tested it.

It doesn't do that, unfortunately. The only thing Weighted trait does that is useful is that it allows you to make a series of back-to-back light attacks a little quicker. This could be useful for someone using the Shield Breaker set with a bow, for example. In my tests, Weighted trait does NOTHING to make heavy attacks or abilities fire quicker.

Waffennacht

Actually i don't believe you can animation cancel resto heavy (i think the animation goes away but you're still locked until the duration is over)

However, I remember someone pointing out that weighted works, just it removes something like .2 seconds from the heavy attack time. Which I doubt would be noticed. I could be wrong, im not one PC so I can only guess at some times.

PainfulFAFA

I too have noticed something off with Weighted.
It works well with regular light att spamming
BUT it does not work whe your tryna wind up a heavy att. It doesnt get the speed increased at all.

failkiwib16_ESO

It's a filler trait, utter useless like charged and powered x_x

r.jan_emailb16_ESO

failkiwib16_ESO wrote: »

It's a filler trait, utter useless like charged and powered x_x

Haha yeah, sadly it is.

Silver_Strider

ZOS really needs to think about redesigning all the useless traits to be actually useful for something.
I mean, Charged, Powered and Weighted are completely useless, just like Well-Fitted and Sturdy are for Armor

Charged should restore some of the enchantment charge on your weapon when you kill something, with a cooldown effect of course so that you can't just have infinite charge on your weapon enchantment
Powered should be the Stamina version of Nirncrux
Weighted should increase damage of light/heavy attacks

Well-Fitted should offer a speed boost or reduce the cost of sneaking as well as sprinting.
Sturdy should increase the effectiveness of healing effects on you.

Just my thoughts.

kojou

Weighted seems to me like it should increase the damage of light and heavy attacks by a % not make them faster...

Either way I had a weapon with it once and it did not seem to have any effect on my weaving so I never used it again.