Week 1 (ENDED): VOTE for the WORST 5th piece bonus on an item set! Winner gets 250k! (PC/NA)

Dr_Con
Dr_Con
✭✭✭✭✭
✭✭
Hello everyone!
edit: Week 1 has ended! To participate in week 2's voting please go here: https://forums.elderscrollsonline.com/en-gb/discussion/617186/vote-week-2-what-is-the-worst-5th-piece-item-bonus-winner-gets-250k-pc-na#latest
As mentioned in my previous topic here: https://forums.elderscrollsonline.com/en/discussion/616668/what-is-the-worst-5-piece-bonus-winning-suggestion-gets-250k-submissions-close-9-3-2022-at-3pm

We will now be voting for the WORST current set bonus as of the time of voting, the winner will get 250k. I will make a separate topic, probably in another section, to track the winning set (or losing set, depending on your point of view) voted each week by the community. You may vote for your own suggestion or you may vote for your friends, but in the spirit of the contest please vote for what you perceive to be the worst 5th piece bonus in the game as of this moment.

Voting will close tomorrow, Sunday at 11:59 PM, and the winner must provide me the @ account they want the prize money sent to.

(a big thanks to those who submitted in the format requested! it makes doing this much easier)
there is a 10 poll limit, this being the case I'll have to limit the options. Some were moved to honorable mentions for not providing a link to the set or any corresponding screenshot.

IMPORTANT! IF YOU BELIEVE AN HONORABLE MENTION SHOULD BE DECLARED WINNER: please indicate so in the comments and cast your vote there in a clear manner by saying "I vote for [set name] - do not post a list please. Most of the honorable mentions were moved there for not following the format I requested (which makes it easier to do these sorts of polls since they can be time intensive to set up).

remember, *you can encourage friends to vote* for your option, but I will remind everyone that you should vote for the worst current set as I will feature these in another community choice awards topic.
@Bigmatt2
qbxjf500lqxn.png

@RebornV3x
jhw59j5bnzy2.png

@FluffWit
q4gbzatgp8rd.png

@Faulgor
yhrcy404kawp.png

@Artim_X
79a9mstmufso.png

@notyuu
jl0mnzb9vcay.png

@RealLoveBVB
clij91nrgzyh.png

@mocap
mjo668s6141y.png

@N00BxV1
w3v0emfvcroz.png

@EF321
luhkfhcchdjl.png



honorable mentions (if you believe one of these should win, indicate so in the comments, if you cast a vote for another option via the poll that one will be counted instead):
@Redguards_Revenge
elux3tk8pufc.png

@Jaraal
v7tcusg3cvo9.png

@dmnqwk
nql7d6advo5t.png

@Kite42
5v13govmuh5l.png

@chessalavakia_ESO
fjjqlx39j3vz.png

@Jim_Pipp
pmjkadir7tke.png

@Xarc
fdye2gafrt2j.png

(edit was made to make it clear who submitted what)
edit was made to adept rider to reflect current stats
edits were made to show that this week has ended and direct people to week 2's voting
Edited by Dr_Con on 10 September 2022 02:27

Week 1 (ENDED): VOTE for the WORST 5th piece bonus on an item set! Winner gets 250k! (PC/NA) 101 votes

Assassin's Guile
7%
vailjohn_ESOAvalonRangerTheImperfectRoztlin45ZabagadStyxiusElendir2amMidniteOwl1913 8 votes
Vastarie's Tutelage
24%
daryl.rasmusenb14_ESOdmnqwkAH93stevenyaub16_ESOdanno8Ragged_ClawAnkael07morrowjenKlauthWarthogWoodenHeartBigmatt2spartaxoxobmnobleWiseSkythe1andonlyskwexNomadic_AtmoranPeacefulAnarchyKaelthorn_NightbloomMesiteNemezijus 25 votes
Spelunker Set
13%
GlassHalfFullTannus15Oberon45VoodooPlatypusDojohodaJim_PippSeminolegirl1992MellirusYandereGirlfriendlooshoraIriidiusAmeriseslonnmlPrincessOfThieves 14 votes
Druid's Braid
6%
GalenTyharRaammzzaaElvenOverlordixthUAZiggyTStardustveznan5 7 votes
Vampire Lord
22%
CloudtraderKarminathevampToRelaxVevvevTevalaurKandrecarmeekmikoArgonianAustinTyrobagArtim_XVeeskFinedaibleNord_RaseriJman100582Spectral_ForceBalDing710edward_frigidhandsK9002kevkjendgamesmug 23 votes
Redistributor
4%
ReverbFischblutDrathlyLikiLokijoergino 5 votes
Toothrow
0%
Zodiarkslayer 1 vote
Nikulas's Heavy Armor
4%
sPark101AshrynSuna_Ye_SunnabeZama666ezmaye 5 votes
Ranger's Gait
5%
N00BxV1ChiaroscuroWildRaptorXIndigogoaurelius_fxLykeion 6 votes
Jailer's Tenacity
6%
AliyavanaJacen_Veronnejcn001tomofhyruleAscarlEF321MafiaCat115 7 votes
  • Jaraal
    Jaraal
    ✭✭✭✭✭
    ✭✭✭✭✭
    v7tcusg3cvo9.png
  • sPark101
    sPark101
    ✭✭✭✭
    Nikulas's Heavy Armor
    Permission Problem.
  • Dr_Con
    Dr_Con
    ✭✭✭✭✭
    ✭✭
    sPark101 wrote: »
    Permission Problem.

    If anyone is running into this issue as well feel free to state your vote or try again
  • N00BxV1
    N00BxV1
    ✭✭✭✭✭
    Ranger's Gait
    remember, *you can encourage friends to vote* for your option
    I voted for my own submission since I don't have any friends that use the forums... :cookie:
  • Dr_Con
    Dr_Con
    ✭✭✭✭✭
    ✭✭
    N00BxV1 wrote: »
    remember, *you can encourage friends to vote* for your option
    I voted for my own submission since I don't have any friends that use the forums... :cookie:

    That's totally fair and allowed! I'm sure if this was posted to an external website or tallied in a discord we'd see different results.
  • EF321
    EF321
    ✭✭✭✭✭
    ✭✭
    Jailer's Tenacity
    N00BxV1 wrote: »
    remember, *you can encourage friends to vote* for your option
    I voted for my own submission since I don't have any friends that use the forums... :cookie:

    I voted for my own submission since I don't have any friends that use the forums.
  • blktauna
    blktauna
    ✭✭✭✭✭
    ✭✭
    I use toothrow all the time, especially for its 5th piece...
    PCNA
    PCEU
  • Dr_Con
    Dr_Con
    ✭✭✭✭✭
    ✭✭
    blktauna wrote: »
    I use toothrow all the time, especially for its 5th piece...

    the argument that the submitter made when they posted that is here:
    https://forums.elderscrollsonline.com/en/discussion/comment/7707030/#Comment_7707030
    Definitely this: https://eso-sets.com/set/toothrow

    You are always better off with slotting camo hunter/inner light or just have potions with the crit.

    for reference:
    35dqlzrpo9ql.png
    kp6gt6mvpvsx.png



    edit: please note the Adept Rider submission was changed to reflect current stats, and I confirmed it by checking in-game.

    fdye2gafrt2j.png

    bsjzljnqjyal.png

    I don't anticipate this making a huge difference on the results.
    Edited by Dr_Con on 3 September 2022 22:25
  • K9002
    K9002
    ✭✭✭✭✭
    Vampire Lord
    Vampire Lord is probably the only set in game that adds more penalties than bonuses. As useless as other candidates might be, at least they don't actively harm their wearers.
  • Vevvev
    Vevvev
    ✭✭✭✭✭
    ✭✭✭✭✭
    Vampire Lord
    The old form of vampire lord is ten times better than the current one. They massacred that set and made it worthless to everyone.

    It used to have a niche on the Greymoor PTS when the debuffs were so high, and the buffs so great, that the ultimate was like candy and you could keep it up. They adjusted it so that's no longer the case even when wearing this set.

    Vampire Lord + Shape shifter's chain doesn't even produce the desired effect, and you sacrifice way too much to get it.
    Edited by Vevvev on 3 September 2022 22:37
    PC NA - Ceyanna Ashton - Breton Vampire MagDK
  • danno8
    danno8
    ✭✭✭✭✭
    ✭✭✭✭✭
    Vastarie's Tutelage
    A fifth bonus that is worse the better you play is pretty bad. And if you do die the bonus is a paltry 258 damage stat and 10% reduced costs for only 10 seconds, at a time when you have practically no resources to draw from.
  • Freelancer_ESO
    Freelancer_ESO
    ✭✭✭✭✭
    Vevvev wrote: »
    The old form of vampire lord is ten times better than the current one. They massacred that set and made it worthless to everyone.

    It used to have a niche on the Greymoor PTS when the debuffs were so high, and the buffs so great, that the ultimate was like candy and you could keep it up. They adjusted it so that's no longer the case even when wearing this set.

    Vampire Lord + Shape shifter's chain doesn't even produce the desired effect, and you sacrifice way too much to get it.

    I used it for a few months on my Vampire. With the Dragonguard and Soul Harvest it had a pretty good uptime. I ended up axing it because I got sick of the vampiric visuals and the animation for going in/out of Perfect Scion grew to be annoying.
  • Troodon80
    Troodon80
    ✭✭✭✭✭
    danno8 wrote: »
    A fifth bonus that is worse the better you play is pretty bad. And if you do die the bonus is a paltry 258 damage stat and 10% reduced costs for only 10 seconds, at a time when you have practically no resources to draw from.
    To be fair, it's granted to both you and the ally you revive. It's not "if you die in combat and someone revives you, get a stat increase and reduced cost; if you don't die then you'll never get this bonus." It actually rewards the wearer, in a sense, for not dying (i.e. playing better) and then reviving someone who did die, rewarding both the wearer and the person who did die. Albeit the reward is still pretty abysmal, especially considering your own personal DPS loss and potential risk for stopping to revive someone who arguably played worse and perhaps shouldn't be rewarded for it, no argument there. Compared to some of the others, that set would probably be okay in PvP if your goal was to run around reviving people doing sieges.

    @Troodon80 PC | EU
    Guild: N&S
    Hand of Alkosh | Dawnbringer | Immortal Redeemer | Tick Tock Tormentor | Gryphon Heart
    Deep Dive into Dreadsail Reef Mechanics
  • danno8
    danno8
    ✭✭✭✭✭
    ✭✭✭✭✭
    Vastarie's Tutelage
    Troodon80 wrote: »
    danno8 wrote: »
    A fifth bonus that is worse the better you play is pretty bad. And if you do die the bonus is a paltry 258 damage stat and 10% reduced costs for only 10 seconds, at a time when you have practically no resources to draw from.
    To be fair, it's granted to both you and the ally you revive. It's not "if you die in combat and someone revives you, get a stat increase and reduced cost; if you don't die then you'll never get this bonus." It actually rewards the wearer, in a sense, for not dying (i.e. playing better) and then reviving someone who did die, rewarding both the wearer and the person who did die. Albeit the reward is still pretty abysmal, especially considering your own personal DPS loss and potential risk for stopping to revive someone who arguably played worse and perhaps shouldn't be rewarded for it, no argument there. Compared to some of the others, that set would probably be okay in PvP if your goal was to run around reviving people doing sieges.

    Considering Kagrenacs gives you permanent 223 WD and SD as a fifth peice and 25% faster rez speed and 1700 Magicka back when rezzing someone I can't ever see a reason for this other set. 😕
  • Xarc
    Xarc
    ✭✭✭✭✭
    ✭✭
    lol how can we vote for
    - steadfast hero
    - radiant bastion
    - beekeeper
    - sithis's touch
    - meridia's blessed armor
    - eyes of mara
    - adept rider

    ?

    will you make another poll?

    and btw I think there should be a podium with 1st place, 2nd and 3rd with like 150k for winner, 70k for 2nd and 30k for 3rd
    Edited by Xarc on 4 September 2022 08:24
    @xarcs FR-EU-PC -
    Please visit my house ingame !
    sorry for my english, it's not my native language, I'm french
    "Death is overrated", Xarc
    Xãrc -- breton necro - DC - AvA rank50
    Xarcus -- imperial DK - DC - AvA rank50 - [pve] pureclass
    Elnaa - breton NB - DC - AvA rank50
    Xärc -- breton NB - DC - AvA rank49 - [pve] pureclass
    Isilenil - Altmer NB - AD - AvA rank41
    Felisja - Bosmer NB - DC - AvA rank41
    Glàdys - redguard templar - DC - AvA rank40 - [pve & pvp] pureclass
    Xaljaa - breton NB - now EP - AvA rank39
    Bakenecro - khajiit necro - DC - AvA rank28
    Xalisja - bosmer necro - DC - AvA ?
    Shurgha - orc warden EP - AvA rank? [pve & pvp]pureclass
    Scarlętt - breton templar DC - AvA rank?
    - in game since April 2014
    - on the forum since December 2014
  • Dr_Con
    Dr_Con
    ✭✭✭✭✭
    ✭✭
    Xarc wrote: »
    lol how can we vote for
    - steadfast hero
    - radiant bastion
    - beekeeper
    - sithis's touch
    - meridia's blessed armor
    - eyes of mara
    - adept rider

    ?

    will you make another poll?

    and btw I think there should be a podium with 1st place, 2nd and 3rd with like 150k for winner, 70k for 2nd and 30k for 3rd

    as stated above, if someone wants to vote for an option that is in the honorable mentions they can indicate it in the comments, but if they vote via the poll then their poll vote will count instead. People are encouraged to vote for their own submissions and even get their friends involved
    Dr_Con wrote: »
    Hello everyone!
    IMPORTANT! IF YOU BELIEVE AN HONORABLE MENTION SHOULD BE DECLARED WINNER: please indicate so in the comments and cast your vote there in a clear manner by saying "I vote for [set name] - do not post a list please. Most of the honorable mentions were moved there for not following the format I requested (which makes it easier to do these sorts of polls since they can be time intensive to set up).

    remember, *you can encourage friends to vote* for your option, but I will remind everyone that you should vote for the worst current set as I will feature these in another community choice awards topic.


    The polls are limited to 10 options and unless forum staff up the amount people can create options for, users who wish to vote for those options will have to write in the option they think should win. Since people should be voting for the worst set and votes are transparent, there should be no issues with vote representation unless you want to argue that people are too lazy to write in the one they think is the worst.

    The first response by Jaraal was a radiant bastion screenshot and that will be his vote, people are able to write in their votes in this manner. Most of the ones in the honorable mentions were not submitted in the proper format (with the exception of the mara set, which was decided based on feedback the Vampire Lord set was more likely to win so it was placed in the poll instead). Making another poll would confuse the results and I won't do that. It would be nice for them to increase the amount of options people can make for polling options, but that is up to the managers of the forum.

    I will take the other feedback into consideration for next week, as this week I only had limited time to put this together. Ideally I would want to use an expert panel to exclude non-competing options, but we run into issues such as people feeling excluded.
    Edited by Dr_Con on 4 September 2022 09:09
  • Eliahnus
    Eliahnus
    ✭✭✭✭
    I use Adapt Rider on all my mules and on my characters in their early stages to have them move faster. Very usefull that set.
  • Tyrobag
    Tyrobag
    ✭✭✭✭✭
    ✭✭
    Vampire Lord
    Most of these are just really lackluster, but Vampire lord is the only one here that is actually an active debuff to wear
  • Bigmatt2
    Bigmatt2
    ✭✭✭
    Vastarie's Tutelage
    I didn't know about this set or probably would of posted it myself. The entire buff is a function of you dying first in hopes that someone will resurrect you.
  • AvalonRanger
    AvalonRanger
    ✭✭✭✭✭
    Assassin's Guile
    There're simple question here.
    Why ZOS made meaningless set equipment ? :/

    To gather good equipment in group dungeon is super hard work.
    Each time dropping set item include garbage gear, and those time wasting
    farming keep killing our time. :s
    My playing time Mon-Friday UTC13:00-16:00 [PC-NA] CP over2000 now.
    I have [1Tough tank] [1StamSorc-DD] [1Necro-DD] [1Real Healer]
    with [1Stam Blade].
    But, I'm Tank main player. Recently I'm doing Healer.

    2023/12/21
    By the way...Dungeon-Meshi(One of Famous Japanese fantasy story comic book) got finale...
    Good-bye "King of Monster Eater".

    2024/08/23
    Farewell Atsuko Tanaka...(-_-) I never forget epic acting for major Motoko Kusanagi.
  • Zama666
    Zama666
    ✭✭✭✭
    Nikulas's Heavy Armor
    I love Bee Keepers!
    Stacked with Bewitch Sugar Skulls and some shields & healz....I have lived up to 3 seconds longer in PvP!!!!

    This poll is hilarious!

    Thankz!

    Z
  • mocap
    mocap
    ✭✭✭✭✭
    Vampire Lord set reduce vampire ultimate cost, so at least it can be used in role play if you want to "spam" Scion form.
    Edited by mocap on 4 September 2022 17:01
  • Dr_Con
    Dr_Con
    ✭✭✭✭✭
    ✭✭
    mocap wrote: »
    Vampire Lord set reduce vampire ultimate cost, so at least it can be used in role play if you want to "spam" Scion form.

    While true and a less than optimal but having potential as a backbar build for this reason, you also have the potentiate set that only takes up 1 jewelry piece and a backbar slot for a 15% reduction to ultis. Assuming stage 4 vampirism, which reduces the ult cost by 26% to begin with under the feed passive, and using perfect scion IV, that makes it into a 207-208 ulti cost for Potentiates, and around 194 ult cost for Vampire Lord. Once you use perfect scion, the 5 piece debuffs go away, but that's a 20 second window where you are doing extreme damage on your main bar with increased tankiness and healing for 15% of damage dealt, and all your health regen, ability cost, and flame damage debuffs disappear.

    Combine this with +10k stam, hp, and magicka and the ability to see thru walls, and you can dish out and tank some serious damage with the right buffs. Additionally, vampire lord will mean you have to either use up all your jewelry slots or wear light armor, whereas you need only wear 1 piece of jewelry with the potentiate set and use it for prebuffing on your back bar. A front bar set with this sort of setup could include a high damage dealing rotation while the backbar has the perfect scion ult to achieve stage 5 vampirism and some pre-buffs (forward momentum, channeled acceleration, etc).

    Since the highest damage dealing ability for vampires is in fact the eviscerate line of abilities and it's more of a blood for damage sort of thing with more damage as you go lower, the passive on vampire lord doesn't help you achieve optimal results- it actually reduces the costs which will result in reduction of DPS. The only thing it may help with are reduced costs for blood mist and blood frenzy, possibly also reduced costs on the the ranged drain spells (exhilarating drain can help you gain more ulti) which has a range of 22m that can be further extended to 29m with the help of propelling shield IV, however I don't really envision many people using this ability like that or needing reduced costs on their vampirism abilities if they are attacking from this range since they can just get it all back with a heavy attack. As for blood mist, desert rose or something that reduces the cost of channeled spells in conjunction with magicka cost reducing glyphs is a more viable option to help with troll tanking/capturing points, as you can run that as a back bar 5 piece set with shield that covers all your jewelry, with arena weapons on your front bar or something with a decent 2 piece bonus, and a full tanky/sustain set in your armor slots without sacrificing a monster helm. Finally, blood frenzy is manageable with a self-heal slotted such as eternal vigour and does not require the 20% reduction on health costs- and using it during perfect scion will have practically no cost so long as you are dishing out insane DPS like you are supposed to in those 20 seconds due to the 15% rebate (which is affected by healing and critical CP btw).

    TLDR: Potentiates backbar for the 15% reduction on the ulti cost- people acknowledge there are better options and they need a more compelling reason to run a 5 set item that requires you to be stage 4 to benefit from the 20% reduced vampire ability costs and an even further increase in non-vampire ability cost and increased fire damage when the main source of siege damage in PVP is fire.

    This commentary doesn't really focus on PVE, but I'm sure it's a lovely set to go around use in normal/casual content for people trying to learn how to use vampirism, but better options do exist and it's sad to see the state of this item currently as it seems they decided to buff vampire abilities and passives at the cost of nerfing this item, and further multiply the feed passive's debuffs with this item, which is an odd trade-off that sort of relies on you to use perfect scion to get any benefit out of this item (and even still, there's better options).

    Since werewolves have a mythic that decreases ulti and ability costs while increasing base stats. It would be nice to see one for vampires as well- at least one that gives passive health regen back so I don't always have to heal when changing zones (due to CP HP) I might even buy a new chapter just to try that out.

    P.S. I also acknowledge that Vastarie's Tutelage is a weird set as it rewards you and the dead person when you rez someone. Sets that reward people for dying when you shouldn't die I will say have little intrinsic value, however there is a dual stam and magicka regen to make up for this proc-when-rez set, so someone who focuses in sustain but sees a lot of death may see value in it.
    Edited by Dr_Con on 4 September 2022 19:19
  • Nomadic_Atmoran
    Nomadic_Atmoran
    ✭✭✭✭✭
    Vastarie's Tutelage
    By the time your teammate gets back into the fight after being raised from the dead and rebuffs themselves. Yeah thatll get maybe a few seconds off of that weapon/spell buff. And god knows how much dps was lost just to proc that 5th piece set.
    Edited by Nomadic_Atmoran on 4 September 2022 18:53
    Penniless Sellsword Company
    Captain Paramount Jorrhaq Vhent
    Korith Eaglecry - Laerinel Rhaev - Enrerion - Caius Berilius - Seylina Ithvala - Signa Squallrider - H'Vak the Grimjawl
    Yynril Rothvani - Tenarei Rhaev - Bathes-In-Coin - Dazsh Ro Khar - Aredyhel - Reads-To-Frogs - Azjani Ma'Les
    Kheshna gra-Gharbuk - Gallisten Bondurant - Aban Shahid Bakr - Etain Maquier - Atsu Kalame - Faulpia Severinus
  • ArgonianAustin
    ArgonianAustin
    ✭✭✭✭
    Vampire Lord
    Whatever the 2 worst 5 peice sets are, im going to wear them both and go straight to pvp.
    Just a Lizard Man that plays ESO with my twin brother khajiit_kyle
  • Jman100582
    Jman100582
    ✭✭✭✭
    Vampire Lord
    Sad that nobody mentioned nights silence
  • WiseSky
    WiseSky
    ✭✭✭✭✭
    ✭✭
    Vastarie's Tutelage
    I don't know what any of the sets do.

    So I Went with the lamest Name
  • Tevalaur
    Tevalaur
    ✭✭✭✭✭
    Vampire Lord
    WiseSky wrote: »
    I don't know what any of the sets do.

    So I Went with the lamest Name

    If you couldn't be bothered to look through the screenshots atop the poll then I hardly think your vote should actually count... Literacy is in a sad state these days...
    Is Uncle John's band calling you? Do you daydream about Sugar Magnolias? Is your favorite sunflower a China Cat? Tired of Truckin' alone to Terrapin Station? If so, share some Space with other hippies & deadheads in the guild Sunshine Daydream! Send a message in game (PC-NA) to Kaibeth for your invitation.
  • spartaxoxo
    spartaxoxo
    ✭✭✭✭✭
    ✭✭✭✭✭
    Vastarie's Tutelage
    K9002 wrote: »
    Vampire Lord is probably the only set in game that adds more penalties than bonuses. As useless as other candidates might be, at least they don't actively harm their wearers.

    I voted for Vastarie because at least there's a real use case for Vampire Lord. If you're planning on being a stage 4 vampire only using vampire abilities at all times, the regular ability cost of that set is negated. Meanwhile, Vastarie actively works against the goals of the person who wears it, since it's a set that presumably a healer would "want" to wear. And they would not want their allies to die. In addition, not only does the set only work when things are actively going against the gameplay you likely intend, but when the set does come in handy, what you get out of it is barely worth mentioning. It effectively costs you a 5-piece bonus for the vast majority of the time, but then it gives you hardly anything for that sacrifice. This is presumably so people don't die on purpose for the buff, but that just reinforces why it's a terrible idea.
    Edited by spartaxoxo on 4 September 2022 23:10
  • Finedaible
    Finedaible
    ✭✭✭✭✭
    ✭✭
    Vampire Lord
    Like 96% of the sets in the entire game are useless fodder crap but Vampire Lord is among the most useless. The only reason I could think of using this set would be for overland vampire roleplay but anyone can steamroll overland regardless of gear.

    My honorable mention would be Armor of the Veiled Heritance: "When you interrupt an enemy, you gain 516 Weapon and Spell Damage for 15 seconds. Your Bash attacks deal 516 more damage." For one, it is a heavy armor set, AND two it has an incredibly niche proc condition with such a short buff duration that most users will never get any use out of it at all.

    edit: typo
    Edited by Finedaible on 4 September 2022 23:21
Sign In or Register to comment.