Nice guide, but it doesn't help when using a tool that has design issues. Meaning, four different players can queue for the same dungeon, each in her/his own role, and still not be put together.
onlinegamer1 wrote: »1985 called, it wants its group finder tool design back.
"Role based auto-matching/filling" is an ancient concept and has no place in modern Group Finder tools. Given that MMORPGs are social games, players don't want to use ESO's archaic and outdated Group Finder. We want a modern Group Finder tool design. You know, a tool that:
For a group leader:
- Let's someone start a group (they are the group leader)
- Lets them mark which Dungeon, and which mode (normal/Vet)
- Lets them indicate what roles they want (Tank, DPS, Healer)
- Lets them set level requirements (Min and Max acceptable) i.e. "Min: V11 Max: V14"
- Lets them post a comment, like "Experienced only" or "learning run, anyone welcome"
- Can alter the parameters at any time (min/max level, roles needed, even dungeon or mode)
Then, as someone who is LFG, we want:
- Bring up a list of all available Groups (all listings from the above Leaders) (unless the Leader has me on ignore, then I don't even see their listing!)
- Filter the list by: Dungeon, Mode, and "Meets Requirements" (the reason I might want to see groups I DON'T qualify for is if I have Alts which DO qualify, and if I'm willing to swap to that alt to join).
- Click on any Group(s) I am interested in, and click "Apply to Join" (can apply to multiple groups)
Then, as the Leader again:
- I see all "Join Requests"
- I see character name, class, level, role and a flag indicating if we are in the same guild(s) or not.
- I can click "Accept" or "Decline" to add them to my group or decline their request.
- Once the group is full, the listing automatically de-lists, and we are all teleported to the dungeon.
Simple.
Example from DDO (Dungeons & Dragons Online) (slightly modified for ESO)
Searching using the Finder for 4 hours during primetime and finding no group for the DAILY PLEDGE = broken.
I don't get why there are still people who believe the tool is 100% working.
Yes, sometimes it can find people to make a group with. That is if it doesn't group 3 DPS (and the 3 DPS only checked the DPS box), or if it doesn't group people who wanted different dungeons.
I always use the tool while I look for a group. And almost every time find people before the tool does.
And honestly as someone said in another topic :Searching using the Finder for 4 hours during primetime and finding no group for the DAILY PLEDGE = broken.
Can you really believe that when there are at least hundreds of people connected, there is not even 3 persons who want to do the daily dungeon quest?
So explaining how the tool work and telling people to use it more is really a nice idea and players can't do much more than. But on ZOS side it would be really nice to have something to improve (or at least fix) their tool.
jenwa72ab14_ESO wrote: »Being a new player and lower level, I would like to run the dungeons, but to be honest there is nothing in front of it to make me know if I'm a capable tank or a healer. Being a Templar I can heal, but I've done so little of it to this point I feel inadequate. As a tank, I can block, got a couple skills, but have no idea how good I can be or not. So I go DPS (never found a match) and to be honest I really don't know how good I am at that, however it is something I've been doing consistently from the start. The older mmo's, for some reason you just know what role you are and how to play it, by playing the game. ESO does a poor job in prepping for these specific roles.
NewBlacksmurf wrote: »jenwa72ab14_ESO wrote: »Being a new player and lower level, I would like to run the dungeons, but to be honest there is nothing in front of it to make me know if I'm a capable tank or a healer. Being a Templar I can heal, but I've done so little of it to this point I feel inadequate. As a tank, I can block, got a couple skills, but have no idea how good I can be or not. So I go DPS (never found a match) and to be honest I really don't know how good I am at that, however it is something I've been doing consistently from the start. The older mmo's, for some reason you just know what role you are and how to play it, by playing the game. ESO does a poor job in prepping for these specific roles.
It doesn't really work like any other MMO. Throw those ideas away but pay very close attention to how your party plays and communicate and enjoy. Have fun!
onlinegamer1 wrote: »1985 called, it wants its group finder tool design back.
"Role based auto-matching/filling" is an ancient concept and has no place in modern Group Finder tools. Given that MMORPGs are social games, players don't want to use ESO's archaic and outdated Group Finder. We want a modern Group Finder tool design. You know, a tool that:
For a group leader:
- Let's someone start a group (they are the group leader)
- Lets them mark which Dungeon, and which mode (normal/Vet)
- Lets them indicate what roles they want (Tank, DPS, Healer)
- Lets them set level requirements (Min and Max acceptable) i.e. "Min: V11 Max: V14"
- Lets them post a comment, like "Experienced only" or "learning run, anyone welcome"
- Can alter the parameters at any time (min/max level, roles needed, even dungeon or mode)
Then, as someone who is LFG, we want:
- Bring up a list of all available Groups (all listings from the above Leaders) (unless the Leader has me on ignore, then I don't even see their listing!)
- Filter the list by: Dungeon, Mode, and "Meets Requirements" (the reason I might want to see groups I DON'T qualify for is if I have Alts which DO qualify, and if I'm willing to swap to that alt to join).
- Click on any Group(s) I am interested in, and click "Apply to Join" (can apply to multiple groups)
Then, as the Leader again:
- I see all "Join Requests"
- I see character name, class, level, role and a flag indicating if we are in the same guild(s) or not.
- I can click "Accept" or "Decline" to add them to my group or decline their request.
- Once the group is full, the listing automatically de-lists, and we are all teleported to the dungeon.
Simple.
Example from DDO (Dungeons & Dragons Online) (slightly modified for ESO)
onlinegamer1 wrote: »1985 called, it wants its group finder tool design back.
"Role based auto-matching/filling" is an ancient concept and has no place in modern Group Finder tools. Given that MMORPGs are social games, players don't want to use ESO's archaic and outdated Group Finder. We want a modern Group Finder tool design. You know, a tool that:
For a group leader:
- Let's someone start a group (they are the group leader)
- Lets them mark which Dungeon, and which mode (normal/Vet)
- Lets them indicate what roles they want (Tank, DPS, Healer)
- Lets them set level requirements (Min and Max acceptable) i.e. "Min: V11 Max: V14"
- Lets them post a comment, like "Experienced only" or "learning run, anyone welcome"
- Can alter the parameters at any time (min/max level, roles needed, even dungeon or mode)
Then, as someone who is LFG, we want:
- Bring up a list of all available Groups (all listings from the above Leaders) (unless the Leader has me on ignore, then I don't even see their listing!)
- Filter the list by: Dungeon, Mode, and "Meets Requirements" (the reason I might want to see groups I DON'T qualify for is if I have Alts which DO qualify, and if I'm willing to swap to that alt to join).
- Click on any Group(s) I am interested in, and click "Apply to Join" (can apply to multiple groups)
Then, as the Leader again:
- I see all "Join Requests"
- I see character name, class, level, role and a flag indicating if we are in the same guild(s) or not.
- I can click "Accept" or "Decline" to add them to my group or decline their request.
- Once the group is full, the listing automatically de-lists, and we are all teleported to the dungeon.
Simple.
Example from DDO (Dungeons & Dragons Online) (slightly modified for ESO)
Sallington wrote: »Anything useful that players are wanting added into the game all fall under the category of "Yer ruinin my 'mersion!"
NewBlacksmurf wrote: »I don't get why there are still people who believe the tool is 100% working.
Yes, sometimes it can find people to make a group with. That is if it doesn't group 3 DPS (and the 3 DPS only checked the DPS box), or if it doesn't group people who wanted different dungeons.
I always use the tool while I look for a group. And almost every time find people before the tool does.
And honestly as someone said in another topic :Searching using the Finder for 4 hours during primetime and finding no group for the DAILY PLEDGE = broken.
Can you really believe that when there are at least hundreds of people connected, there is not even 3 persons who want to do the daily dungeon quest?
So explaining how the tool work and telling people to use it more is really a nice idea and players can't do much more than. But on ZOS side it would be really nice to have something to improve (or at least fix) their tool.
Because it works 100% of the time for us.
Have you tried it with all addons disabled?
jenwa72ab14_ESO wrote: »NewBlacksmurf wrote: »jenwa72ab14_ESO wrote: »Being a new player and lower level, I would like to run the dungeons, but to be honest there is nothing in front of it to make me know if I'm a capable tank or a healer. Being a Templar I can heal, but I've done so little of it to this point I feel inadequate. As a tank, I can block, got a couple skills, but have no idea how good I can be or not. So I go DPS (never found a match) and to be honest I really don't know how good I am at that, however it is something I've been doing consistently from the start. The older mmo's, for some reason you just know what role you are and how to play it, by playing the game. ESO does a poor job in prepping for these specific roles.
It doesn't really work like any other MMO. Throw those ideas away but pay very close attention to how your party plays and communicate and enjoy. Have fun!
Then perhaps they should drop the Tank, Heal, DPS delegation. What party? I'm looking for a PUG, I assume that is why the tool exists.
NewBlacksmurf wrote: »I don't get why there are still people who believe the tool is 100% working.
Yes, sometimes it can find people to make a group with. That is if it doesn't group 3 DPS (and the 3 DPS only checked the DPS box), or if it doesn't group people who wanted different dungeons.
I always use the tool while I look for a group. And almost every time find people before the tool does.
And honestly as someone said in another topic :Searching using the Finder for 4 hours during primetime and finding no group for the DAILY PLEDGE = broken.
Can you really believe that when there are at least hundreds of people connected, there is not even 3 persons who want to do the daily dungeon quest?
So explaining how the tool work and telling people to use it more is really a nice idea and players can't do much more than. But on ZOS side it would be really nice to have something to improve (or at least fix) their tool.
Because it works 100% of the time for us.
Have you tried it with all addons disabled?
Addons or not, the tool should work for nearly anyone of any level range looking to run group content. And it does not.
NewBlacksmurf wrote: »NewBlacksmurf wrote: »I don't get why there are still people who believe the tool is 100% working.
Yes, sometimes it can find people to make a group with. That is if it doesn't group 3 DPS (and the 3 DPS only checked the DPS box), or if it doesn't group people who wanted different dungeons.
I always use the tool while I look for a group. And almost every time find people before the tool does.
And honestly as someone said in another topic :Searching using the Finder for 4 hours during primetime and finding no group for the DAILY PLEDGE = broken.
Can you really believe that when there are at least hundreds of people connected, there is not even 3 persons who want to do the daily dungeon quest?
So explaining how the tool work and telling people to use it more is really a nice idea and players can't do much more than. But on ZOS side it would be really nice to have something to improve (or at least fix) their tool.
Because it works 100% of the time for us.
Have you tried it with all addons disabled?
Addons or not, the tool should work for nearly anyone of any level range looking to run group content. And it does not.
I respect your opinion, I'm only offering solutions. Whether or not it should work with an add-on is based on the add-on and since ZOS doesn't make the add-on, when an add-on causes a conflict with the game you shouldn't blame the game developer but rather the add-on developers.
NewBlacksmurf wrote: »NewBlacksmurf wrote: »I don't get why there are still people who believe the tool is 100% working.
Yes, sometimes it can find people to make a group with. That is if it doesn't group 3 DPS (and the 3 DPS only checked the DPS box), or if it doesn't group people who wanted different dungeons.
I always use the tool while I look for a group. And almost every time find people before the tool does.
And honestly as someone said in another topic :Searching using the Finder for 4 hours during primetime and finding no group for the DAILY PLEDGE = broken.
Can you really believe that when there are at least hundreds of people connected, there is not even 3 persons who want to do the daily dungeon quest?
So explaining how the tool work and telling people to use it more is really a nice idea and players can't do much more than. But on ZOS side it would be really nice to have something to improve (or at least fix) their tool.
Because it works 100% of the time for us.
Have you tried it with all addons disabled?
Addons or not, the tool should work for nearly anyone of any level range looking to run group content. And it does not.
I respect your opinion, I'm only offering solutions. Whether or not it should work with an add-on is based on the add-on and since ZOS doesn't make the add-on, when an add-on causes a conflict with the game you shouldn't blame the game developer but rather the add-on developers.
Except there isn't any conflict with addons I've ever been aware of. And I've been following/experiencing this issue since it popped up. And I can confirm with multiple accounts that the tool does not work the majority of the time in my experiences. Unlike your posts however, I don't bash those who are finding the tool to work for them occasionally. You are the only poster I've read that claims it works consistently 100% of the time.
My advice to you is to point out that your opinion is not absolute. Neither are your experiences playing with your friends. Your solution is not a solution at all. It is merely you forcing your opinion upon others in such a way that invalidates the experiences of others. That is not respect, nor is it constructive.
Thanks.
MyNegation wrote: »DDO the best grouping tool currently available in one of the best and the most underrated games.
So the best way to get a group with the group finder is to queue up then way shrine through all the popular spots?acording to my experiences the main problem of that crapy group finder we have is its inability to cope with the game beeing instanced. it only scans through your current instance to find matches wich is completly garbage as it forces you to hop around the world to find group members or a slot in a group.
Shadesofkin wrote: »To verify the tool I'd like to see a thread started that had people willing to say "I will be on at this time to queue for this dungeon in the grouping tool"