a bg map thats on a big boat? yes
rework of all game physics for a pvp that would get boring very quick? no

TheFM wrote: »

OP, you will find that many on these forums have an aversion to creative new ideas. I would love to have something like this, I absolutely adored black flag, I know it couldnt be as in depth as that, but some naval decks for battlegrounds could be nice.

So many men, so many minds. It's fine. I was only surprised to read so many players have that aversion because of the game's current state, as if they know it will never change to the better for sure. They might be right as well as wrong - future is so uncertain. Thanks for a kind word, FM! Ok, I'll try to let those guys understand me better.. I wanted to play the mode I proposed generally, but of course, no sooner the devs fix the current troubles the majority of the players meet. That was so obvious to me I haven't even deemed it necessary to focus so thoroughly on it. And personally if I ever see the game is unplayable, I see no necessity to discuss it neither with the devs nor with the players even if those glitches, lags and crashes ever occur.

I'm just a customer who does not have to understand what it takes to make a product as well as my customers IRL need qualitative results only. I give an idea of what I want to pay for, the devs are to think about it, to decide if they are ready to make it, to test its stability and usability and tell me the price. If the product does not meet my requirements, becomes unstable, whatever unsuitable, I just stop investing in it and using it without any feedback. There is no socialism here and it's not freeware to participate in it's development in order to use the fruits of communal labor. No honey - no money. I just play the rules. What I do is only saying what taste of honey I want and it is irrelevant to me if the beekeeper has some troubles making it - there's a beekeeper to take that challenge. If he makes it - good. Otherwise I'll continue buying the honey he's been producing (if it suits me) without any additional investment he could receive. The quality of the basic honey itself is my own business with the beekeeper only, but I'd like to discuss it's possible tastes with other honey eaters. If the majority wants to eat classical honey, I'll be with them of course, because I pay for it too. The beekeeper also will not waste his time to make an unwanted product. Otherwise he'll see if he can take the challenge and earn extra money. It's simple. This is why I see no reason to discuss and quarrel here with any of the fellow players regarding the game stability. I gave an idea - you vote. Well, this is my personal approach I do not urge anyone to follow. I only thank you for voting and I appreciate your opinions. Have a great day.

I'd be all for it. If it meant that PvP broke off and become a separate game with no effect on raiding and other PVE activities.