Another ESO event without curated drops

LonePirate · March 25

I opened my gold Jesters Festival reward box on PC EU today and inside it was a gold Cadwell’s style page that was first given out several years ago. For some reason unbeknownst to players, it did not contain one of the new gold style pages being offered this year.

@ZOS, if you want a quality of life fix which players will appreciate, it’s fixing stuff like this. At no point should a gold level item from several years ago - especially one already earned/learned by the player - be the primary reward in a gold level event box. There should not be a single one of these Cadwell pages in these gold event boxes this year or any subsequent year. Instead, the only gold items should be new ones from this year’s collection. These items should also be curated so that I don’t receive the same one every day while having not received some of the others. What amount of asking and begging do players need to do to make this happen?

twisttop138 · March 25

Hard agree.

redlink1979 · March 25

Stuff from previous years should be availabe in a separate bag to be sold at the empresario.
I've asked for this change several times, in all anual events, without any success so far.
Why ZOS keep doing it? Beats me.

joe_schmo · March 25

This is my 5th year doing Jester's Festival, every year for every day of the event I've done all daily quests, and I'm still sitting at 2/7 Sovereign Sow fragments. Seriously???

SeaGtGruff · March 25

Um, I don't think the old Cadwell's style pages prevent the new ones from dropping-- that is, it doesn't seem to be a "one page or the other" scenario where getting a Cadwell's page means you're prevented from getting a new page. I say this because of four things: (1) I received both a new "One Bad Knight" page plus an old Cadwell's page in my first (golden) event coffer on PC EU today; (2) the old Cadwell's pages have a chance to drop from purple event coffers; (3) the new "One Bad Knight" pages drop exclusively from the once-a-day golden event coffer but only have a chance to drop rather than a guaranteed drop; and (4) the daily golden event coffer can contain anything else that the purple event coffers can.

So you got an old Cadwell's page because it's a potential drop from the purple event coffers, and the fact that you did not get a new "One Bad Knight" page in your daily golden event coffer had nothing to do with whether you happened to receive an old Cadwell's page or any other old rewards from a previous year's Jester event.

By letting the old rewards drop from the purple event coffers instead of having to be bought with Trade Bars in "grabbags," ZOS is giving players a chance to obtain those older items without having to "buy" them. Those older items are not polluting or diluting the RNG loot pool for the golden event coffers, because they have no impact on whether or not you can get one of the new pages in your golden event coffer.

scrappy1342 · March 25

SeaGtGruff wrote: »

Um, I don't think the old Cadwell's style pages prevent the new ones from dropping-- that is, it doesn't seem to be a "one page or the other" scenario where getting a Cadwell's page means you're prevented from getting a new page.

bump. and that cadwell page is probably worth a lot more than those new ones will be at the end of the week. you got lucky

Necrotech_Master · 12:05AM

redlink1979 wrote: »

Stuff from previous years should be availabe in a separate bag to be sold at the empresario.
I've asked for this change several times, in all anual events, without any success so far.
Why ZOS keep doing it? Beats me.

they do already have that, its called the grab bags (other long running events for sure already have this such as the witches festival)

now how fast they move stuff into said grab bags can be an issue, i could see them keeping an event item around for current and maybe the following year event, but it should just go into the grab bag after 2 years

Vaqual · 12:25AM

SeaGtGruff wrote: »

Um, I don't think the old Cadwell's style pages prevent the new ones from dropping-- that is, it doesn't seem to be a "one page or the other" scenario where getting a Cadwell's page means you're prevented from getting a new page. I say this because of four things: (1) I received both a new "One Bad Knight" page plus an old Cadwell's page in my first (golden) event coffer on PC EU today; (2) the old Cadwell's pages have a chance to drop from purple event coffers; (3) the new "One Bad Knight" pages drop exclusively from the once-a-day golden event coffer but only have a chance to drop rather than a guaranteed drop; and (4) the daily golden event coffer can contain anything else that the purple event coffers can.

So you got an old Cadwell's page because it's a potential drop from the purple event coffers, and the fact that you did not get a new "One Bad Knight" page in your daily golden event coffer had nothing to do with whether you happened to receive an old Cadwell's page or any other old rewards from a previous year's Jester event.

By letting the old rewards drop from the purple event coffers instead of having to be bought with Trade Bars in "grabbags," ZOS is giving players a chance to obtain those older items without having to "buy" them. Those older items are not polluting or diluting the RNG loot pool for the golden event coffers, because they have no impact on whether or not you can get one of the new pages in your golden event coffer.

Yes, I can confirm that, the same happened for me.

SeaGtGruff · 12:49AM

Necrotech_Master wrote: »

redlink1979 wrote: »

Stuff from previous years should be availabe in a separate bag to be sold at the empresario.
I've asked for this change several times, in all anual events, without any success so far.
Why ZOS keep doing it? Beats me.

they do already have that, its called the grab bags (other long running events for sure already have this such as the witches festival)

now how fast they move stuff into said grab bags can be an issue, i could see them keeping an event item around for current and maybe the following year event, but it should just go into the grab bag after 2 years

I'm conflicted about having old items drop from purple coffers versus having them available in a grab bag.

It's good to be able to get them from purple coffers without having to buy them.

But on the other hand, having them in a grab bag makes it easy to see if you're missing something from past years' events-- because if the grab bag isn't grayed out then there's still at least one item you don't have yet.