Likes:
- it's something different; the fishing itself is kinda fun
- it's always kinda fun to catch a gunnysack
dislikes:
- it really has a very low return of anything useful (only the gunnysacks really)
- the rare fish don't show up in your inventory; you catch something that potentially has monetary value and the takeaway from it is actually less then catching a 3 gold normal fish
- you can't do anything BUT fishing; no chatting, no inventory checking, just fishing
what needs to be done to improve it?
- add provisioning recipes requiring fish
- add alchemical properties to certain fish
- possibly make some fish into edible boost providing items on their own
- at the very least put caught fish in the inventory
pretty sure it needs more but that's of the top of my head