There's throwing pies & throwing pies to harass/stop others doing something (like using an outfit station, harvesting, looting or unlocking a chast etc..)
There's throwing pies & throwing pies to harass/stop others doing something (like using an outfit station, harvesting, looting or unlocking a chast etc..)
Exactly! I just read an earlier thread about this, and there were these same bad-faith arguments as in the message you quoted, and more. It is astounding how some people don't want to understand the difference. There's good fun and there's harassment and the line between isn't really that hard to see. Basically: Throwing an occasional pie/mudball at someone just standing around or passing by = OK in most cases; going around purposefully hindering other people's gameplay with the things = not OK.
But you can still use stations after you're mudballed? Last I heard you can't even mudball someone who is actively using an outfit or crafting station. I'd check now but I'm at work.
Personally I think calling getting mudballed in a video game "harassment" is a pretty bad faith argument. A crazy overexagerration or overreaction at best. It's literally pixels changing colors for a few seconds lol
Snowstrider wrote: »It depends.
If they go around questing and shopping, being thrown mud/pie is mostly irrelevant. I personnaly don't give a damn.
BUT
If they are roleplaying and you throw a pie? Then, you're the bad person, not them, since they don't go around wrecking your playstyle. Throwing pies in that case is griefing, and should be reported.
PSA : throw pies, but think before you do !
What if I also roleplay a character that loves to throw pies at people?
There's throwing pies & throwing pies to harass/stop others doing something (like using an outfit station, harvesting, looting or unlocking a chest etc..)
There's throwing pies & throwing pies to harass/stop others doing something (like using an outfit station, harvesting, looting or unlocking a chast etc..)
Exactly! I just read an earlier thread about this, and there were these same bad-faith arguments as in the message you quoted, and more. It is astounding how some people don't want to understand the difference. There's good fun and there's harassment and the line between isn't really that hard to see. Basically: Throwing an occasional pie/mudball at someone just standing around or passing by = OK in most cases; going around purposefully hindering other people's gameplay with the things = not OK.
But you can still use stations after you're mudballed? Last I heard you can't even mudball someone who is actively using an outfit or crafting station. I'd check now but I'm at work.
Personally I think calling getting mudballed in a video game "harassment" is a pretty bad faith argument. A crazy overexagerration or overreaction at best. It's literally pixels changing colors for a few seconds lol
But you can still use stations after you're mudballed? Last I heard you can't even mudball someone who is actively using an outfit or crafting station. I'd check now but I'm at work.
Personally I think calling getting mudballed in a video game "harassment" is a pretty bad faith argument. A crazy overexagerration or overreaction at best. It's literally pixels changing colors for a few seconds lol
It's about the intent and amount. Are you seriously suggesting that it's normal or acceptable to e.g. follow someone around for a long time and repeatedly mudball them, even if they say that they don't like it? Or do that to annoy people who are obviously RPing? In those cases there is a clear intent to annoy the person, so yes, it is harassment. Much like if you followed someone around in RL and shouted some word at them over and over. I also would find doing those kinds of things a bit unhinged, whether in RL or in Internet. The actual harm done is negligible, yes, but it prevents the other one enjoying what he is doing. Civil behaviour is civil behaviour both online and offline. Not hard to understand.
If you want to RP with no interruptions, the blatantly obvious answer is to not play a game where thousands of random players all around you. They aren't required to play by your standards and you aren't required to play by theirs.
Snowstrider wrote: »Snowstrider wrote: »It depends.
If they go around questing and shopping, being thrown mud/pie is mostly irrelevant. I personnaly don't give a damn.
BUT
If they are roleplaying and you throw a pie? Then, you're the bad person, not them, since they don't go around wrecking your playstyle. Throwing pies in that case is griefing, and should be reported.
PSA : throw pies, but think before you do !
What if I also roleplay a character that loves to throw pies at people?
There's throwing pies & throwing pies to harass/stop others doing something (like using an outfit station, harvesting, looting or unlocking a chest etc..)
Really? It stops people from doing stuff? Didnt know that.. now i know why people are bothered by it
If you want to RP with no interruptions, the blatantly obvious answer is to not play a game where thousands of random players all around you. They aren't required to play by your standards and you aren't required to play by theirs.
If you would have read my earlier posts, you would have seen that I'm okay with occasional mudballs/pies/whatever. It's actually the obsession some people exhibit about their "right" to annoy other people without reason and the assumption that the other person should just suck it up or leave that makes me angry. If it wasn't mudballs, it would be something else. And no, online environment doesn't make a difference. But, it is useless to argue with people to whom basic manners are incomprehensible so I'll stop this here.
Oh, BTW: I'm not an RPer really, I used it just as an example.
TequilaFire wrote: »I thought this was a game, my bad. lol
I think you are confusing someone disagreeing with you and pointing out holes in an argument as being bad mannered. Again, I think people need to stop taking every interaction as a personal attack. I attacked your argument, not you.
I was offering legitimate advice btw. People aren't going to get a perfect RP experience in an MMO. It just flat out isn't going to happen. I'm not going to get my perfect experience either. There seems to be a lot of people that get legitimately furious that everything isn't catered to their personal whim. I suggest for people who can't handle the tradeoffs to try a single player game. You can remain in TES universe with modded Skyrim. The modding community is still going strong after all these years and you can customize a world to one's exact preferences.
SilverBride wrote: »
KalyanLazair wrote: »TequilaFire wrote: »I thought this was a game, my bad. lol
So is soccer or Monopoli, but that doesn't justify forgetting basic social norms.
And note that I'm stating we shouldn't go to either extreme. Tormenting a player and ruining their experience is as bad, if not worse, than being annoyed by someone playing a lute. Actually, it is worse because the person playing the lute is likely doing it because they like the emote (I do). The person pelting another user for minutes on end with mudballs is aware that they're going to annoy that player, and yet they decide to engage in such activity only to cause someone else distress, annoyance or to ruin their gaming experience when they were just minding their own business.
I don't have an issue with a random ball, I will likely even laugh at it. I will not react to harassers pelting me with balls, but not because it is acceptable but because it will give them what they want and I will not give them that pleasure.
SilverBride wrote: »It's amazing to me how many players try to justify being a bully by saying "It's just a game".
SilverBride wrote: »It's amazing to me how many players try to justify being a bully by saying "It's just a game".
It's not bullying lol. I could write a long list of things that really annoy me and none of it would be considered bullying. None of which dictates how other have to play either. It's literally using a feature as intended to change the color of some pixels temporarily. You're just calling it that to make it sound way worse than it really is and to pretend that this is a moral issue which it isn't lol. It's pixels changing color on a screen. Essentially over exaggerating for affect.
spartaxoxo wrote: »People are gonna mudball random people because it's fun and part of the game, and it's not rude.
SilverBride wrote: »Fun for who? I am not a fan of pranks in real life, and would never be friends with anyone who is a prankster. And yes, it is extremely rude. But in game I'm more lenient.
SilverBride wrote: »I just brush it off if I get hit by a random mudball when I'm running through town. But I've also been harassed by repeated mudballs from someone trying to disrupt me from opening a lockbox. And I had a friend who constantly threw things at me every time we got together in game, despite me asking them to stop.
spartaxoxo wrote: »"Random strangers" is nearly the entirery of the in-game world. You cannot expect them to know your opinion nor share it.
VaranisArano wrote: »ZOS was pretty clear that if someone asks you to stop spamming emotes at them, you should stop.
I'm more inclined to throw back in good spirits, and if that means stopping for a minute of mudflinging before I go on my merry way, so be it.
SilverBride wrote: »spartaxoxo wrote: »"Random strangers" is nearly the entirery of the in-game world. You cannot expect them to know your opinion nor share it.
That is why you don't just come up to a random stranger and do something invasive to their character. Because by your own words, "You cannot expect them to know your opinion nor share it."
It's always the best thing to err on the side of caution. If you don't know whether or not someone will be offended by something you do to their character... don't do it.
spartaxoxo wrote: »It's only rude if they ignore you don't like it, it's not rude to try and engage you in the first place.
Emoting with strangers has been an accepted social norm of MMOs for decades.
SilverBride wrote: »spartaxoxo wrote: »It's only rude if they ignore you don't like it, it's not rude to try and engage you in the first place.
Emoting with strangers has been an accepted social norm of MMOs for decades.
I don't like it, so to me it's rude.
Also, emoting is very different from interacting with someone else's character.