Xbox Live™ is currently experiencing a service interruption. Please check here for status updates:
Maintenance for the week of January 20:
• PC/Mac: NA and EU for maintenance – January 20, 6:00AM EST (11:00 UTC) - 9:00AM EST (14:00 UTC)
• Xbox One: NA and EU megaservers for maintenance – January 20, 6:00AM EST (11:00 UTC) - 9:00AM EST (14:00 UTC)
• PlayStation®4: NA and EU megaservers for maintenance – January 20, 6:00AM EST (11:00 UTC) - 9:00AM EST (14:00 UTC)

A Guide to Socio-Economic Formations of Tamriel.

  • Helgi_Skotina
    Author doesn't know what socialism is and which horrors it means.
  • Ratzkifal
    Author doesn't know what socialism is and which horrors it means.

    Are you sure? Clockwork City is quite the horrible place. It's a very fitting description.
    This Bosmer was tortured to death. There is nothing left to be done.
  • Cygemai_Hlervu
    Ratzkifal wrote: »
    Great analysis. I have a few points I would want to make about it though.
    First of all I think there needs to be a distinction made between the First Aldmeri Dominion and the Second and Third.
    From what we are seeing, I am not convinced the First Aldmeri Dominion is a fascist society rather than an monarchical society with the opposing classes of the nobility and the sapiarchs/priests and the Queen. (The bourgousie in Altmer society can usually trace back their ancestory to nobility as well, as these records are a fundamental part of their society. If you aren't a noble Altmer, you are most likely serving a noble or are one of the outcasts with no rights)

    What is missing from the First Aldmeri Dominion compared to the Third that I think is necessary for the society to be called fascist would be the single-party mentality that everyone needs to support the same political faction, for example the Thalmor, and no tolerance for open opposition. "Naemon should have been King" is a sentence we hear a lot ingame and we meet nobles who openly oppose Ayrenn. The ideal fascist dogma is "if it's not explicitly allowed, it's illegal" while Ayrenn seems to be far more lenient more akin of "if it's not explicitly forbidden, it's allowed".

    At best we have an absolute monarchy with regional nobles - at worst it is a fascist society without a fascist ruler with Queen Ayrenn's very hands-off approach at ruling.
    However the Third Aldmeri Dominion is most likely a very typical fascist society with the Thalmor and Divine Prosecution policing and ruling over everything.
    A definition of fascism on your part would have been good though, especially to distinguish it further from capitalism, seeing as fascism is usually opposed to the free market as well.

    Secondly, as a bit of a nitpick, the Bosmer and Orsimer didn't leave due to religious scisms.
    The Bosmer were most likely Aldmer (not to be confused with Altmer) colonists who made a pact with Y'ffre in order to survive in Valenwood. The Orsimer were on the same side as the main stream Altmer, even going as far as to try to stop the Chimer from leaving Summerset. Only due to Trinimac's defeat and defilement at the hands of Boethia were they changed and cast out.

    Thirdly, I think it's worth examining the Argonians again under a different paradigm with the Hist being their absolute rulers and all Argonians being slaves or serfs to them.

    Fourth, another nitpick, Bosmer don't need imported wood to build their own houses, they grow them from live trees. :P

    Great work though overall!

    Yes, very good critics there, @Ratzkifal, thank you! I haven't thought of the Hist as a ruling entity there. Hmm, I'll think over it. Thanks much!
    Author doesn't know what socialism is and which horrors it means.

    You are very wrong here, Helgi :D. I'm very well aware of what socialism, feudalism and capitalism mean, moreover I have personal reasons to dislike exactly socialism among those three formations. But I am not the one who judges those formations from his personal emotional point of view. Because I'm also aware not only of horrors those three formations mean, but also of all the good they've done. To me and, moreover, to you ;) including. My experience showed me multiple times: a very bad, evil deeds sometimes become the reasons of some very good consequences. It's just the matter of time - sometimes decades are needed to pass to see it. And you have to decide what to choose - to accuse someone for doing wrong decades ago or to thank him for doing it because today you have something that couldn't have existed without that evil. It's not a talk of some "what if" concept or any parallel universes. It's reality - pick at least one reason from the link and the result changes dramatically. We just don't know the future until it comes, we can only calculate some miserable expectations only. So don't be so quick to judge, sometimes we need much time to see what some actions lead to. Though of course we have to resist the current evil, but only the history itself shows who's right or wrong.

    Socialism has never won it's struggle in the countries where everybody were happy. Just like capitalism could come to power only because feudalism could not solve the exact troubles of the exact society at a certain period of time. The personal attitude to those formations depends much on the historical period of those formations' development, the country (e.g. capitalism is very different in the US and, say, Bangladesh) and the personal social position of the speaker. It is very hard to like an absolutist state when you are a serf with the only right to work harder for your lord almost for free. But it is also very hard to dislike it when you are that very lord.

    This is why I'm not intended to speak of pros and cons neither of socialism nor feudalism or capitalism here. The guide is only the description based strictly on a scientific theory of one of the well known scientists and it is not intended to convince someone to like something. Sometimes I might choose some other theory to describe the same thing - we'll see. I ask you guys to stay within the thread in-game topic, please.

    P.S. @Ratzkifal's right - Clockwork City is indeed a horrible place. "Plastic" food, factories, artificial nature.. It's a nightmare.
    Edited by Cygemai_Hlervu on December 29, 2019 12:23PM
Sign In or Register to comment.