Maintenance for the week of February 23:
· [COMPLETE] NA megaservers for maintenance – February 23, 4:00AM EST (9:00 UTC) - 12:00PM EST (17:00 UTC)
· [COMPLETE] EU megaservers for maintenance – February 23, 9:00 UTC (4:00AM EST) - 17:00 UTC (12:00PM EST)
· [COMPLETE] ESO Store and Account System for maintenance – February 23, 4:00AM EST (9:00 UTC) - 12:00PM EST (17:00 UTC)

ZOS NEEDS to allow character/account transfers when next gen consoles release.

  • nafensoriel
    nafensoriel
    ✭✭✭✭✭
    Will ESO be compatible with PS5 at all ?

    All PS4 games are going to be PS5 Compatible according to Sony.
  • huntgod_ESO
    huntgod_ESO
    ✭✭✭✭✭
    If you are playing on PS4 your account should transfer, along with your characters, etc. to the new PS5, though ultimately that is up to Sony not Zenimax. If you are playing on XBone and move to the new X console, the same should apply.

    They will never offer a transfer from PS4 to next X console, or Xbone to PS5, again though that is on Sony and Microsoft not Zenimax.
    --- HuntGod ---
    Officer of the Unrepentant
    www.unrepentantgaming.com
  • DaveMoeDee
    DaveMoeDee
    ✭✭✭✭✭
    ✭✭✭
    apri wrote: »
    Well let me throw in a few questions here (assuming ESO will be ported to the next gen consoles):
    • Why are in the crown store bought costumes not unlocked in our account but on a per-server-basis?
    • Why are bought mounts not unlocked account-wide?
    • Why are bought houses not unlocked account-wide?
    • Why are bought pets not unlocked... you got the picture ;)
    I think the answer is written on the wall.

    What you suggest can be done. It has been done when ESO launched on consoles and PC players were allowed to have their accounts be copied to PS4 or Xbox One for a one-time-fee. The PTS shows that ZOS can still copy accounts in 2019 for PC players. So technically ZOS has proven it is doable on multiple occasions. But maybe it is not the most profitable thing in the world so we gonna have to wait and see if this is still... possible.

    No, ZOS has NOT proven it is doable. You are confusing pre-populating with transferring to live systems. ZOS has loaded up fresh servers with already existing accounts from other servers. They have not added accounts from one live system to another live system.
  • idk
    idk
    ✭✭✭✭✭
    ✭✭✭✭✭
    apri wrote: »
    Well let me throw in a few questions here (assuming ESO will be ported to the next gen consoles):
    • Why are in the crown store bought costumes not unlocked in our account but on a per-server-basis?
    • Why are bought mounts not unlocked account-wide?
    • Why are bought houses not unlocked account-wide?
    • Why are bought pets not unlocked... you got the picture ;)
    I think the answer is written on the wall.

    What you suggest can be done. It has been done when ESO launched on consoles and PC players were allowed to have their accounts be copied to PS4 or Xbox One for a one-time-fee. The PTS shows that ZOS can still copy accounts in 2019 for PC players. So technically ZOS has proven it is doable on multiple occasions. But maybe it is not the most profitable thing in the world so we gonna have to wait and see if this is still... possible.

    To your list. Anything bought in game is only on that account as the NA and EU servers are not tied together. Anything obtained outside of the game is on both servers. With some games items are bound to character and cannot be accessed by other characters unless an additional fee is paid (real world money fee).

    You are correct that Zos has copied characters over to other servers but in each case they were not live environments and Zos clearly made that distinction when they setup to copy PC accounts to consoles before their launch and those who were a day late opting in never got copied.

    Further, Zos has also demonstrated how that can get messed up as account copy to the PTS did not go well on at least on occasion. This was last year iirc and it both delayed the PTS coming back online and they could not complete the transfer.

    Why Zos does not offer it is probably more simplistic than money as they could design a system and once it is built it would last for years. While it is a guess, I expect Sony and Microsoft have tied their hands with permitting players to transfer as both have a vested interest in keeping players on their platform. It is the most logical reason.
  • Kiralyn2000
    Kiralyn2000
    ✭✭✭✭✭
    ✭✭✭✭✭
    If you are playing on PS4 your account should transfer, along with your characters, etc. to the new PS5, though ultimately that is up to Sony not Zenimax. If you are playing on XBone and move to the new X console, the same should apply.

    Well, it likely won't "transfer" at all - it'll just be the same server (Playstation), but with people playing the game on PS4, on PS5 (the PS4 version of the game, backward compatible), or an improved version of the game native to PS5 (who knows if they'll bother doing this).
  • Tigerseye
    Tigerseye
    ✭✭✭✭✭
    ✭✭✭
    Acrolas wrote: »
    Tigerseye wrote: »
    Not really the point, is it?

    The OP just wants to be able to transfer the stuff, he has paid to access, over to another platform, if necessary.

    He's not asking for a refund, or anything.


    This thread demands a feature that was never part of the agreed-upon terms. By not having ownership of the account, we waive all claim to negotiation and accept all Services as-is.

    The time to take issue with the agreement is before you agree to it, not at any point afterward. Changes in functionality and technology, or features in other products have no bearing on the terms of service for this product.

    OK, another irrelevant point. :confused:

    The OP is merely asking that ZoS allow people to move their account from one console to another.

    Otherwise, if the next gen of their current console is worse than the next gen of another manufacturer's console, they will either have to buy an inferior console, or lose all their items and progress.

    Of course, ZoS don't have to allow this, but it would be pretty anti-consumer to not do it.

    I'm not sure what people don't understand here?

    Hard to imagine you're all trolling, given that some of the answers are extremely detailed, if totally off course.
  • Tigerseye
    Tigerseye
    ✭✭✭✭✭
    ✭✭✭
    idk wrote: »
    While it is a guess, I expect Sony and Microsoft have tied their hands with permitting players to transfer as both have a vested interest in keeping players on their platform. It is the most logical reason.

    Maybe.

    However, if it was the case that ZoS are willing and able to do it, but aren't allowed to when it comes to consoles, wouldn't they have already done it when it comes to transferring an account from PC EU to PC US, or vice versa?

    Although, I can't imagine many people would want to do the latter currently, given the state of the EU server.

    They haven't, which leads me to believe they simply don't want to, or perhaps can't (less likely, I would have thought), whatever the console manufacturers' position is on the subject.

    If they think there is no money in doing it, I can assure them that there is no way I would start again, from scratch, on a new platform.

    ...and if my current platform is unplayable, for whatever reason, I will just stop playing and paying and I doubt I'm alone.

    Edited by Tigerseye on November 11, 2019 11:23AM
  • FierceSam
    FierceSam
    ✭✭✭✭✭
    ✭✭✭✭
    It is totally in ZOS’s interest to enable players on next gen consoles to play on the existing servers with their existing accounts.

    It is totally down to the console developers to ensure this is possible.
  • zaria
    zaria
    ✭✭✭✭✭
    ✭✭✭✭✭
    apri wrote: »
    Well let me throw in a few questions here (assuming ESO will be ported to the next gen consoles):
    • Why are in the crown store bought costumes not unlocked in our account but on a per-server-basis?
    • Why are bought mounts not unlocked account-wide?
    • Why are bought houses not unlocked account-wide?
    • Why are bought pets not unlocked... you got the picture ;)
    I think the answer is written on the wall.

    What you suggest can be done. It has been done when ESO launched on consoles and PC players were allowed to have their accounts be copied to PS4 or Xbox One for a one-time-fee. The PTS shows that ZOS can still copy accounts in 2019 for PC players. So technically ZOS has proven it is doable on multiple occasions. But maybe it is not the most profitable thing in the world so we gonna have to wait and see if this is still... possible.
    The console release was an one time event towards an empty database.
    They simply copied the database and deleted all users who was not in the transfer me list.

    To move an user they will need to make an program who copy out all the account data with all their characters, bank and houses. Obviously inventory, achievements and quest status too

    Its some work to make this program. guess an week or two for an developer.
    This is why they has not made it.
    Had ZoS assumed it had been enough demand they had made this program.

    Grinding just make you go in circles.
    Asking ZoS for nerfs is as stupid as asking for close air support from the death star.
  • zaria
    zaria
    ✭✭✭✭✭
    ✭✭✭✭✭
    Will ESO be compatible with PS5 at all ?
    Both consoles simply upgrades cpu and gpu, add more memory and SSD so they will be fully backward comparable.
    More less demanding games can simply be released as an PS4 / 5 version


    Grinding just make you go in circles.
    Asking ZoS for nerfs is as stupid as asking for close air support from the death star.
  • Tigerseye
    Tigerseye
    ✭✭✭✭✭
    ✭✭✭
    FierceSam wrote: »
    It is totally in ZOS’s interest to enable players on next gen consoles to play on the existing servers with their existing accounts.

    It is totally down to the console developers to ensure this is possible.

    Yes and to ensure no one is tied-in to buying a certain manufacturer's next gen of console, whether they like it or not, to be able to do so.

    It's incredibly anti-consumer to force people to have to buy a specific piece of hardware, they wouldn't otherwise choose to buy, simply to be able to continue to play their current game account.

    Assuming they are ready and able to upgrade, obviously.
    Edited by Tigerseye on November 11, 2019 11:43AM
  • DaveMoeDee
    DaveMoeDee
    ✭✭✭✭✭
    ✭✭✭
    FierceSam wrote: »
    It is totally in ZOS’s interest to enable players on next gen consoles to play on the existing servers with their existing accounts.

    It is totally down to the console developers to ensure this is possible.

    Definitely. It really is very straightforward. Either both consoles can access the same server infrastructure or they can't. I would be shocked if they couldn't both access the same ESO backend as that would be a disaster for the initial period where games are released on both the new and old platforms. And it would be pretty bad if PS5 players couldn't play coop games with their PS4 PSN friends because their versions ran on different infrastructure.
    Edited by DaveMoeDee on November 11, 2019 1:35PM
  • essi2
    essi2
    ✭✭✭✭✭
    ✭✭
    What makes you think the next consoles will get new servers separate from the current gen servers?
    "The Heritance are racists yes? Idiots. But dangerous, destabilizing racist idiots." - Razum-dar

    "Wood Elves aren't made of wood, Sea Elves aren't made of water. M'aiq still wonders about High Elves" - M'aiq the Liar

    ** Leyawiin Layabouts (PC-EU) - Leyawiin Layabouts (PC-NA) **

    *** https://www.youtube.com/@essi2 - https://www.twitch.tv/essi2 ***
  • Dogzey
    Dogzey
    ✭✭✭
    Didn't rich or somebody mention on stream this year that cross platform was something they were looking into? Might have been before elsweyr. They said something along the line of "We heard peoples outcry for cross platform and it is something we are looking into down the road". Could be something they will do here.
    PS4 EU [810CP] - (Clairvoyance)

    PvE High Elf Mag DK - Irelia Dragneel (Voice of Reason) (Dro-m'Athra Destroyer)
    PvE Orc Stam DK - Minato Uzamaki
    PvE Breton Templar - Ashura Namikaze (Voice of Reason)
    PvE Altmer Magcro - Zeref Dragneel
    PvE Orc Stamcro - Saphira Dragonsbane (Dro-m'Athra Destroyer)
    PvE Orc Stam Sorc - Laxus Dreyar
    PvE Imperial DK Tank- Tartarus the Abyss
    PvE Dumner Magblade - Apex the Destroyer (Flawless Conqueror)
    PvE/PVP Orc Stamblade - IIzuna Uchiha
    PvE Altmer Warden Healer - Lady Netch

    PVP Dumner Mag DK - Lady Embers

    Clears
    vAS HM
    vMoL HM
    vHoF HM
    vCR +1
    vSS
    Craglorns HM
  • twev
    twev
    ✭✭✭✭✭
    ✭✭
    I don't have any console play or ownership in my past or present, so I have no actual dog in this fight.

    That said - I strongly believe in the name of fairness and all that is good and holy that console players deserve the opportunity to be able to port their accounts to any new generation of console that comes out.

    The ONLY restriction that MIGHT need discussion is that they be required to stay on the BRAND of console they are tied to, but that is a point that is within the console community to argue for.
    The problem with society these days is that no one drinks from the skulls of their enemies anymore.
  • itscompton
    itscompton
    ✭✭✭✭✭
    Jeez, we're still a year away from the new consoles. That's too far out to be this worried.
  • FierceSam
    FierceSam
    ✭✭✭✭✭
    ✭✭✭✭
    zaria wrote: »
    apri wrote: »
    Well let me throw in a few questions here (assuming ESO will be ported to the next gen consoles):
    • Why are in the crown store bought costumes not unlocked in our account but on a per-server-basis?
    • Why are bought mounts not unlocked account-wide?
    • Why are bought houses not unlocked account-wide?
    • Why are bought pets not unlocked... you got the picture ;)
    I think the answer is written on the wall.

    What you suggest can be done. It has been done when ESO launched on consoles and PC players were allowed to have their accounts be copied to PS4 or Xbox One for a one-time-fee. The PTS shows that ZOS can still copy accounts in 2019 for PC players. So technically ZOS has proven it is doable on multiple occasions. But maybe it is not the most profitable thing in the world so we gonna have to wait and see if this is still... possible.
    The console release was an one time event towards an empty database.
    They simply copied the database and deleted all users who was not in the transfer me list.

    To move an user they will need to make an program who copy out all the account data with all their characters, bank and houses. Obviously inventory, achievements and quest status too

    Its some work to make this program. guess an week or two for an developer.
    This is why they has not made it.
    Had ZoS assumed it had been enough demand they had made this program.

    I would assume it’s also the same process used to import your characters into the PTS server. And even then that process is server specific.

    Easy to move anything to a new, blank database. Potentially catastrophic if it goes wrong for an existing database.

    I would guess that ZOS’s planning would currently include options for both situations for console users... best case/worst case planning. So many of the factors are not in ZOS’s control. Will console developer X even allow newproduct to communicate with oldproduct?

    Right now, it’s a way away and ZOS have bigger fish/issues to fry and around a year’s worth of new content to produce before this becomes a serious thing.
  • Kiralyn2000
    Kiralyn2000
    ✭✭✭✭✭
    ✭✭✭✭✭
    [Quoted post has been removed.

    There's a difference between "having values" and "understanding the situation".

    No matter what you feel about it, the fact of the matter is that all these "digital" things we buy in online games are ephemeral piles of bits, that only exist until the company or server goes poof. Legally, they are literally worth nothing.

    (Check out the fine print on any of those "win all the mounts/houses/whatever" contests - the prize listing defines the value of the prize as $0.)
    Edited by ZOS_GregoryV on November 11, 2019 8:26PM
  • apri
    apri
    ✭✭✭✭
    Will ESO be compatible with PS5 at all ?

    All PS4 games are going to be PS5 Compatible according to Sony.
    We better wait and see if and what will be true about that. PS3 was sold with PS2 backward compatibility at first, too, but that was not quite a story of success in the end. In the marketing days before PS4's release there were quite a lot of rumors around how we could keep on playing our PS3 games, yet in the end it was not quite as straight-forward as us naive gamers hoped it to be. In the case of ESO, not only the game but also the netcode and the whole server architecture need to be compatible, as well. Only time can tell if or how we play ESO on PS5. If for whatever reason new servers are required, I'm skeptical we can keep our progress (both in terms of character development and in-game purchases). But we'll see.
  • mb10
    mb10
    ✭✭✭✭✭
    ✭✭✭
    I’d be happy just taking the stats, crown store stuff and achievements over.

    Items would be great but can understand why it would be trickier
  • Acrolas
    Acrolas
    ✭✭✭✭✭
    ✭✭✭✭✭
    apri wrote: »
    The PTS shows that ZOS can still copy accounts in 2019 for PC players.

    As some console players have probably never touched PTS, they may not realize what it is. It's not a case where PC players have a persistent test account that gets periodically updated from Live. PTS is regularly wiped of all player data. So when ZOS copies NA or EU accounts over, there's no existing data to conflict with it.

    You can think of two megaservers a lot like two fish tanks. When you remove a fish from one tank and place it in another, you can't guarantee that the transferred fish will be all right, nor can you guarantee that the existing fish will be all right. Without absolute certainty, any unexpected consequences are going to be the fault of whomever took the risk. For all the accusations ZOS gets about crown crates, you would think player data is the one thing we can all agree should never be gambled with.
    signing off
  • nafensoriel
    nafensoriel
    ✭✭✭✭✭
    apri wrote: »
    Will ESO be compatible with PS5 at all ?

    All PS4 games are going to be PS5 Compatible according to Sony.
    We better wait and see if and what will be true about that. PS3 was sold with PS2 backward compatibility at first, too, but that was not quite a story of success in the end. In the marketing days before PS4's release there were quite a lot of rumors around how we could keep on playing our PS3 games, yet in the end it was not quite as straight-forward as us naive gamers hoped it to be. In the case of ESO, not only the game but also the netcode and the whole server architecture need to be compatible, as well. Only time can tell if or how we play ESO on PS5. If for whatever reason new servers are required, I'm skeptical we can keep our progress (both in terms of character development and in-game purchases). But we'll see.

    Unlike the PS3->PS4 transition the PS4->PS5 transition has been relatively confirmed to NOT include major redesigns of its architecture. While the parts themselves are being upgraded and it is safe to assume they have enhanced and built upon the software and OS side of things they have not completely ripped out the guts and replaced them.
    Sony developers have point-blank stated it will be backward compatible multiple times.

    I can, personally, feel safe saying that 99.9% of PS4 games will work on the PS5 due to the fundamental shift both hardware design and software design have gone through in the last 20 years. What we started to do then was modularize code. Sony took longer but the PS4 elements can be pulled, polished, and replaced just like most elements of windows or modern game engines.

    TLDR: Long gone are the days we coded so *** poorly that every new version required a complete restart. The PS5 is just more hardware and some extra features(like hybrid ray-tracing) bolted onto the software.
  • apri
    apri
    ✭✭✭✭
    Acrolas wrote: »
    As some console players have probably never touched PTS, they may not realize what it is.
    That's so true actually. I wish there was some kind of PTS for consoles, too. Thanks for the helpful explanation!

    I'm still not 100% sold on the PS4 to PS5 transfer. I'd be happy if it goes that smoothly as it was pointed out in this thread not just for the sake of ESO but the many other great games I'd like to keep playing but there's more to it than just hardware. There is also a huge business behind re-releases of games on as many platforms as possible and Bethesda is one of the most famous players when it comes to bringing Skyrim to each and every possible device (for another fee obviously).

    So even if technically there's no barrier in place, it's not safe to say it's really gonna happen unless reality proves so. We have been deceived so many times, I rather believe in what I see now. And if there's just a chance to re-sell a game, well Bethesda has a track record to like such a thing.

    In this context, should they add a fresh client and a new megaserver for PS5 (and next Xbox), chances are everything will be rebooted. They can sell once more what they sold before (the base game and everything in the crown store). They can also offer a one-time character transfer because in @Acrolas metaphor there will be a fresh fish bowl in place. They have done such a thing in the past with PC to console migration and at least that should be possible once again. If that's not needed because PS4 to PS5 goes smoother than assumed by me, the better. Pardon my skeptical mindset in these money-hungry times. :)
  • nafensoriel
    nafensoriel
    ✭✭✭✭✭
    apri wrote: »
    /snipsnip
    I just wanted to comment on Bethesda reselling things.. this is both kinda true and mostly not.

    Bethesda is just weird in that they sell their tech demos and build their tech demos into their games.

    IE they'll upgrade their engine to 64 bit and add some elements to their engine and then sell "Skyrim special edition" to basically pay for the modifications they've made.

    Is this ethical etc etc? Not my place to say.. but it seems to be their odd quirk company wise.

  • kaisernick
    kaisernick
    ✭✭✭✭✭
    Prehaps hell i wouldnt even complain if was for console only.....

    IF ONLY that means we get a increase in furnishing limit.
  • ReverseVenom
    ReverseVenom
    ✭✭✭
    Tigerseye wrote: »
    Acrolas wrote: »
    Tigerseye wrote: »
    Not really the point, is it?

    The OP just wants to be able to transfer the stuff, he has paid to access, over to another platform, if necessary.

    He's not asking for a refund, or anything.


    This thread demands a feature that was never part of the agreed-upon terms. By not having ownership of the account, we waive all claim to negotiation and accept all Services as-is.

    The time to take issue with the agreement is before you agree to it, not at any point afterward. Changes in functionality and technology, or features in other products have no bearing on the terms of service for this product.

    OK, another irrelevant point. :confused:

    The OP is merely asking that ZoS allow people to move their account from one console to another.

    Otherwise, if the next gen of their current console is worse than the next gen of another manufacturer's console, they will either have to buy an inferior console, or lose all their items and progress.

    Of course, ZoS don't have to allow this, but it would be pretty anti-consumer to not do it.

    I'm not sure what people don't understand here?

    Hard to imagine you're all trolling, given that some of the answers are extremely detailed, if totally off course.

    That's essentially all I'm saying, surprised at the backlash tbh
    Nerf mudcrabs
  • Vlad9425
    Vlad9425
    ✭✭✭✭✭
    ✭✭
    I highly doubt this game will be even remotely popular once the next Gen consoles arrive unless they specifically release this game as a new download / disk that's been upgraded for the new consoles.
  • exeeter702
    exeeter702
    ✭✭✭✭✭
    ✭✭
    apri wrote: »
    Acrolas wrote: »
    As some console players have probably never touched PTS, they may not realize what it is.
    That's so true actually. I wish there was some kind of PTS for consoles, too. Thanks for the helpful explanation!

    I'm still not 100% sold on the PS4 to PS5 transfer. I'd be happy if it goes that smoothly as it was pointed out in this thread not just for the sake of ESO but the many other great games I'd like to keep playing but there's more to it than just hardware. There is also a huge business behind re-releases of games on as many platforms as possible and Bethesda is one of the most famous players when it comes to bringing Skyrim to each and every possible device (for another fee obviously).

    So even if technically there's no barrier in place, it's not safe to say it's really gonna happen unless reality proves so. We have been deceived so many times, I rather believe in what I see now. And if there's just a chance to re-sell a game, well Bethesda has a track record to like such a thing.

    In this context, should they add a fresh client and a new megaserver for PS5 (and next Xbox), chances are everything will be rebooted. They can sell once more what they sold before (the base game and everything in the crown store). They can also offer a one-time character transfer because in @Acrolas metaphor there will be a fresh fish bowl in place. They have done such a thing in the past with PC to console migration and at least that should be possible once again. If that's not needed because PS4 to PS5 goes smoother than assumed by me, the better. Pardon my skeptical mindset in these money-hungry times. :)

    Again this mindset regarding transfers and new platfroms is entirely unfounded. The ps4 to ps5 transition is in no way comparable here. Everything about the backwards compatibility situation with ps3 and ps2 games was directly a result of how foreign the ps3s architecture was vs the ps2s, likewise the ps4s more practical pc hardware architecture compared to ps3s uniquely proprietary chipset and fabrication. Backwards compatibility was bound by either elaborate emulation, with is taxing and innacurate or hardware powered which introduces additional costs in manufacturing the hardware.

    The ps4 to ps5 is absolutely positively no different than playing the game on a gtx 1060 w/ a ryzen zen vs a gtx 1660 and a zen 2 cpu. These pc specs are not literal ofc, just to point out the only barrier in place with backwards compatibility moving forward in the console industry is a factor of pc specs and how said specs can run a game at a certain graphical fidelity.

    Eso on ps4 vs ps5 is exclusively a matter of running the game on a higher end pc. There are no new servers, there are no new points of transfer or new platforms to shift players to. Eso on ps5 is a mater of fact, not a mater of speculation, unless zenimax deems the game no longer profitable and and sooner shuts the game down rather than putting it on a new console, not putting it on ps5 is simply money lost. The only interfacing that Zos has engage in is learning the new consoles ui systems and integrate them to eso accordingly, which is entirely a code issue only, and a simple one at that.
    Edited by exeeter702 on November 13, 2019 6:57PM
  • apri
    apri
    ✭✭✭✭
    exeeter702 wrote: »
    Again this mindset regarding transfers and new platfroms is entirely unfounded. The ps4 to ps5 transition is in no way comparable here.
    Is it? I admire your prophetic qualities but what I tried to point out differs. Compatibility is not only about what is technically possible but also what is wanted from a business point of view. Re-publishing of games is a business. For this very reason it is rather naive to think everything will be a given. If it is, I'll take it. But don't be too surprised if it won't be quite as consumer-friendly, even if it is technically a non-issue. It's not PCs, it's consoles. And it is a business after all.
  • DjMuscleboy02
    DjMuscleboy02
    ✭✭✭✭✭
    Database integrity must be a really hard concept for mouth breathers to grasp, huh.
    Brodor - PC NA - ESO's only pure bodybuilding guild
    Hodor, but stronger
Sign In or Register to comment.