The government is useless and incompetent 100% of the time everywhere in the planet.
Narvuntien wrote: »Both Jim Stirling and Yong Yea Videos point out that it isn't just about children, so its not "Bad Parenting" there are problem gamblers, there is the mentality impaired adults, people on the spectrum, and just straight depression that can all lead to compulsive spending
The government is useless and incompetent 100% of the time everywhere in the planet. They should most definately not interfer in the free market. The problem of loot boxes is that reeks of greed, a trait most of us learned to despise. Surely ZOS could earn tons of profits by fostering a good long term business model? Since I'm not part of the pathetic group of the species that needs a nanny to tell them what's right and what's wrong, I simply withdraw my money from ZOS' grasp. Very easily fixed if all humans learned to use their wallet power.
ShellaSunshine wrote: »The ban will most likely NOT affect ESO in any way.
The loot boxes they are referring to are the ones where it's necessary to buy them to progress further in the game. Free to play mobile games like Animation Throwdown has these types of loot boxes. Progressing through this game for free takes a really long time so the developers has a store where you can spend x amount of money or in-game currency to get a chance at a better card. You are not guaranteed this card and the majority of the time, the more boxes you buy, the higher the price increases.
That's what the article is talking about.
Crown crates in ESO are not required to progress further into the game. In fact, nothing you buy in the Crown Store gives any advantages to players in any way.
The law sounds like it will affect games where it's Pay to Win meaning in order to get ahead of other players, you need to spend money for a chance for better loot which ultimately increases in price to increase your chances of improving in the game.
That is, by all definitions, gambling. Well, at the very least the gambling mentality. People think the more money they spend or bet on will increase their chances of winning. The reality?
It doesn't.
starkerealm wrote: »nafensoriel wrote: »Nope.starkerealm wrote: »Further, and this is kinda important to understand, bans like this are absolutely enforceable. If you're selling products in a country, you're bound by the laws in that country. As a business, you can't argue, "I'm hiding behind seven proxies." You're doing business in their territorial boarders, you can run afoul of their laws. The consequences for blowing off a nation's laws can be quite dire.
Not how it works.
I'm going to stop you there. Last I checked, the UK does not have judicial review. So, most of what you're saying might carry some weight in an American court, but simply isn't how UK courts function, and you're assuming that the British judiciary has powers it lacks because that's how it works on Law & Order.
You are correct that UK Parliament is sovereign and as such the only body that can overturn a law passed by parliament is another parliament. However, it is very premature to think the UK will do an absolute ban on loot crates of all kinds for all ages.
ShellaSunshine wrote: »The ban will most likely NOT affect ESO in any way.
The loot boxes they are referring to are the ones where it's necessary to buy them to progress further in the game. Free to play mobile games like Animation Throwdown has these types of loot boxes. Progressing through this game for free takes a really long time so the developers has a store where you can spend x amount of money or in-game currency to get a chance at a better card. You are not guaranteed this card and the majority of the time, the more boxes you buy, the higher the price increases.
That's what the article is talking about.
Crown crates in ESO are not required to progress further into the game. In fact, nothing you buy in the Crown Store gives any advantages to players in any way.
The law sounds like it will affect games where it's Pay to Win meaning in order to get ahead of other players, you need to spend money for a chance for better loot which ultimately increases in price to increase your chances of improving in the game.
That is, by all definitions, gambling. Well, at the very least the gambling mentality. People think the more money they spend or bet on will increase their chances of winning. The reality?
It doesn't.
That’s not the case, this report has implications across the board and it’s not just limited to loot boxes either, you can read the full official report HERE.
The key points highlighted by Parliament are:
• Sale of loot boxes to children should be banned
• Government should regulate ‘loot boxes’ under the Gambling Act
• Games industry must face up to responsibilities to protect players from potential harms
• Industry levy to support independent research on long-term effects of gaming
• Serious concern at lack of effective system to keep children off age-restricted platforms and games
In bold above, notice there is no distinction between what loot boxes do and don’t contain, so crown crates in the UK will be regulated if this goes forward.
starkerealm wrote: »In case this part got away from you, EA sent a rep to parliament to lie for the publisher. People are not happy with them right now.
Oh I am well aware of that. And frankly speaking, people have not been happy with EA for a good long time now.
Ydrisselle wrote: »ShellaSunshine wrote: »The ban will most likely NOT affect ESO in any way.
The loot boxes they are referring to are the ones where it's necessary to buy them to progress further in the game. Free to play mobile games like Animation Throwdown has these types of loot boxes. Progressing through this game for free takes a really long time so the developers has a store where you can spend x amount of money or in-game currency to get a chance at a better card. You are not guaranteed this card and the majority of the time, the more boxes you buy, the higher the price increases.
That's what the article is talking about.
Crown crates in ESO are not required to progress further into the game. In fact, nothing you buy in the Crown Store gives any advantages to players in any way.
The law sounds like it will affect games where it's Pay to Win meaning in order to get ahead of other players, you need to spend money for a chance for better loot which ultimately increases in price to increase your chances of improving in the game.
That is, by all definitions, gambling. Well, at the very least the gambling mentality. People think the more money they spend or bet on will increase their chances of winning. The reality?
It doesn't.
That’s not the case, this report has implications across the board and it’s not just limited to loot boxes either, you can read the full official report HERE.
The key points highlighted by Parliament are:
• Sale of loot boxes to children should be banned
• Government should regulate ‘loot boxes’ under the Gambling Act
• Games industry must face up to responsibilities to protect players from potential harms
• Industry levy to support independent research on long-term effects of gaming
• Serious concern at lack of effective system to keep children off age-restricted platforms and games
In bold above, notice there is no distinction between what loot boxes do and don’t contain, so crown crates in the UK will be regulated if this goes forward.
How will it affect TCGs like Magic the Gathering? You buy card packs and just could hope that it will contain cards you will be able to use
But the MPs found the industry was reluctant to accept responsibility for intervening when a player was over-spending or even to put a figure on how much was too much.
And some had been "wilfully obtuse" in answering questions about game-play, which MPs needed to know in order to better understand how players engaged with games.
starkerealm wrote: »Ydrisselle wrote: »ShellaSunshine wrote: »The ban will most likely NOT affect ESO in any way.
The loot boxes they are referring to are the ones where it's necessary to buy them to progress further in the game. Free to play mobile games like Animation Throwdown has these types of loot boxes. Progressing through this game for free takes a really long time so the developers has a store where you can spend x amount of money or in-game currency to get a chance at a better card. You are not guaranteed this card and the majority of the time, the more boxes you buy, the higher the price increases.
That's what the article is talking about.
Crown crates in ESO are not required to progress further into the game. In fact, nothing you buy in the Crown Store gives any advantages to players in any way.
The law sounds like it will affect games where it's Pay to Win meaning in order to get ahead of other players, you need to spend money for a chance for better loot which ultimately increases in price to increase your chances of improving in the game.
That is, by all definitions, gambling. Well, at the very least the gambling mentality. People think the more money they spend or bet on will increase their chances of winning. The reality?
It doesn't.
That’s not the case, this report has implications across the board and it’s not just limited to loot boxes either, you can read the full official report HERE.
The key points highlighted by Parliament are:
• Sale of loot boxes to children should be banned
• Government should regulate ‘loot boxes’ under the Gambling Act
• Games industry must face up to responsibilities to protect players from potential harms
• Industry levy to support independent research on long-term effects of gaming
• Serious concern at lack of effective system to keep children off age-restricted platforms and games
In bold above, notice there is no distinction between what loot boxes do and don’t contain, so crown crates in the UK will be regulated if this goes forward.
How will it affect TCGs like Magic the Gathering? You buy card packs and just could hope that it will contain cards you will be able to use
Physical TCGs will be fine. Not sure about the British precedents, but in the States trading card packs are considered akin to a physical "grab bag." You're always getting a physical product, so you are getting something at least as valuable as the asking price. However, if you're asking about digital TCGs like Magic: The Gathering: Arena, or The Elder Scrolls: Legends, I'm not sure. They certainly fit all of the prerequisites.
In fact, nothing you buy in the Crown Store gives any advantages to players in any way.
Ydrisselle wrote: »starkerealm wrote: »Ydrisselle wrote: »ShellaSunshine wrote: »The ban will most likely NOT affect ESO in any way.
The loot boxes they are referring to are the ones where it's necessary to buy them to progress further in the game. Free to play mobile games like Animation Throwdown has these types of loot boxes. Progressing through this game for free takes a really long time so the developers has a store where you can spend x amount of money or in-game currency to get a chance at a better card. You are not guaranteed this card and the majority of the time, the more boxes you buy, the higher the price increases.
That's what the article is talking about.
Crown crates in ESO are not required to progress further into the game. In fact, nothing you buy in the Crown Store gives any advantages to players in any way.
The law sounds like it will affect games where it's Pay to Win meaning in order to get ahead of other players, you need to spend money for a chance for better loot which ultimately increases in price to increase your chances of improving in the game.
That is, by all definitions, gambling. Well, at the very least the gambling mentality. People think the more money they spend or bet on will increase their chances of winning. The reality?
It doesn't.
That’s not the case, this report has implications across the board and it’s not just limited to loot boxes either, you can read the full official report HERE.
The key points highlighted by Parliament are:
• Sale of loot boxes to children should be banned
• Government should regulate ‘loot boxes’ under the Gambling Act
• Games industry must face up to responsibilities to protect players from potential harms
• Industry levy to support independent research on long-term effects of gaming
• Serious concern at lack of effective system to keep children off age-restricted platforms and games
In bold above, notice there is no distinction between what loot boxes do and don’t contain, so crown crates in the UK will be regulated if this goes forward.
How will it affect TCGs like Magic the Gathering? You buy card packs and just could hope that it will contain cards you will be able to use
Physical TCGs will be fine. Not sure about the British precedents, but in the States trading card packs are considered akin to a physical "grab bag." You're always getting a physical product, so you are getting something at least as valuable as the asking price. However, if you're asking about digital TCGs like Magic: The Gathering: Arena, or The Elder Scrolls: Legends, I'm not sure. They certainly fit all of the prerequisites.
Yep, my question is about the digital card games. Their packs aren't different from a digital loot box, they only have a different name - plus they are more or less required to effectively play the game, so can even be considered as a P2W mechanic.
starkerealm wrote: »nafensoriel wrote: »Nope.starkerealm wrote: »Further, and this is kinda important to understand, bans like this are absolutely enforceable. If you're selling products in a country, you're bound by the laws in that country. As a business, you can't argue, "I'm hiding behind seven proxies." You're doing business in their territorial boarders, you can run afoul of their laws. The consequences for blowing off a nation's laws can be quite dire.
Not how it works.
I'm going to stop you there. Last I checked, the UK does not have judicial review. So, most of what you're saying might carry some weight in an American court, but simply isn't how UK courts function, and you're assuming that the British judiciary has powers it lacks because that's how it works on Law & Order.
You are correct that UK Parliament is sovereign and as such the only body that can overturn a law passed by parliament is another parliament. However, it is very premature to think the UK will do an absolute ban on loot crates of all kinds for all ages.
starkerealm wrote: »Ydrisselle wrote: »starkerealm wrote: »Ydrisselle wrote: »ShellaSunshine wrote: »The ban will most likely NOT affect ESO in any way.
The loot boxes they are referring to are the ones where it's necessary to buy them to progress further in the game. Free to play mobile games like Animation Throwdown has these types of loot boxes. Progressing through this game for free takes a really long time so the developers has a store where you can spend x amount of money or in-game currency to get a chance at a better card. You are not guaranteed this card and the majority of the time, the more boxes you buy, the higher the price increases.
That's what the article is talking about.
Crown crates in ESO are not required to progress further into the game. In fact, nothing you buy in the Crown Store gives any advantages to players in any way.
The law sounds like it will affect games where it's Pay to Win meaning in order to get ahead of other players, you need to spend money for a chance for better loot which ultimately increases in price to increase your chances of improving in the game.
That is, by all definitions, gambling. Well, at the very least the gambling mentality. People think the more money they spend or bet on will increase their chances of winning. The reality?
It doesn't.
That’s not the case, this report has implications across the board and it’s not just limited to loot boxes either, you can read the full official report HERE.
The key points highlighted by Parliament are:
• Sale of loot boxes to children should be banned
• Government should regulate ‘loot boxes’ under the Gambling Act
• Games industry must face up to responsibilities to protect players from potential harms
• Industry levy to support independent research on long-term effects of gaming
• Serious concern at lack of effective system to keep children off age-restricted platforms and games
In bold above, notice there is no distinction between what loot boxes do and don’t contain, so crown crates in the UK will be regulated if this goes forward.
How will it affect TCGs like Magic the Gathering? You buy card packs and just could hope that it will contain cards you will be able to use
Physical TCGs will be fine. Not sure about the British precedents, but in the States trading card packs are considered akin to a physical "grab bag." You're always getting a physical product, so you are getting something at least as valuable as the asking price. However, if you're asking about digital TCGs like Magic: The Gathering: Arena, or The Elder Scrolls: Legends, I'm not sure. They certainly fit all of the prerequisites.
Yep, my question is about the digital card games. Their packs aren't different from a digital loot box, they only have a different name - plus they are more or less required to effectively play the game, so can even be considered as a P2W mechanic.
Yeah, electronic card packs fit the description given, so it wouldn't surprise me if they're collateral damage in all of this.
Now, honestly? I'm okay with that. It won't kill the genre, because there is the LCG model in the real world, which a number of publishers have started transitioning to. If electronic CCGs transition over to that format, I'm happy. I still remember the endorphin rushes from cracking packs when I was younger, but, to be honest, the non-random buy format is way more consumer friendly across the board, and puts the focus on your ability to play instead of your luck on getting the card you wanted from a booster.
(Fantasy Flight Games trademarked LCGs, or Living Card Games, to refer to a CCG distribution system where cards are sold in fixed bundles, so keeping up with the release schedule costs a fixed amount, rather than throwing money at randomized packs. Doesn't hurt that there have been some really good LCGs, including Warhammer 40k Conquest, and a Star Wars LCG, though both of those have since been retired.)
The government is useless and incompetent 100% of the time everywhere in the planet. They should most definately not interfer in the free market. The problem of loot boxes is that reeks of greed, a trait most of us learned to despise. Surely ZOS could earn tons of profits by fostering a good long term business model? Since I'm not part of the pathetic group of the species that needs a nanny to tell them what's right and what's wrong, I simply withdraw my money from ZOS' grasp. Very easily fixed if all humans learned to use their wallet power.
The teachers that tought you to read, the road that brings you to work, the building you live in without killing you - that's all due to the government. The fact that somebody cannot walk over to your house and beat you to a bloody pulp for posting bs about politics on the internet - government interference!
Please, dear comrades on the "abolish government because they want to take away my loot boxes which I'm totally not addicted to" trip, take a step back and look at the greater picture. Change hurts, but without change, there's no progress.
Agree with the part about regulation. I’m not sure about the viability of taxation, given that these companies are mostly non uk
Based- but it’s a good and logical point - I’m convinced air would be taxed if they could figure out how
Personally what I think we will see is loot boxes but with a stated odds or “guaranteed drop” list OR we will see everything go into the crown store - which not only gets round the issue but generates more revenue
Realistically, this is not about banning anything. This is about regulation.
Agree with the part about regulation. I’m not sure about the viability of taxation, given that these companies are mostly non uk
Based- but it’s a good and logical point - I’m convinced air would be taxed if they could figure out how
None of the things you mentioned requires a government. Those are merely the parasites that latches on the progress created by the business people. Enjoy being a pet of your betters and rely on their mercy. Bow to the king and lick his boots.
Oh they've tried. Why do you think they push climate change so hard?