I have a confession to make. I'm not having fun. This is hard for me to say. I played the beta, played the final product since 5 days early access, love MMOs and love the Elder Scrolls universe. I WANT to be having fun. I've explored extensively, crafted, PvPd, gone into dungeons, etc. I've tried to experience the game as fully as I can but overall I honestly can say I'm not particularly enjoying myself.
I've played UO, WOW, EQ and found these to be much more engrossing and engaging. And I also enjoyed Morrowind, Oblivion and Skyrim immensely. I have played all of these games for many hours, losing track of time and getting completely and joyfully absorbed in the game. I haven't had the same experience with ESO. Basically I had a lot more fun in these games than I have in ESO.
Maybe I'm just getting older and the lustre of MMO gaming is beginning to fade for me. Maybe I ramped up my anticipation levels too high, and in my experience that almost invariably leads to disappointment.
But maybe ESO really doesn't stack up (in my personal gaming experience of course - others experience may vary).
The issue seems to be this: Ostensibly Zenimax have tried to make a game that caters to both MMO fans and single player Elder Scrolls fans. It's a wonderful idea, but at the same time it feels that this approach has detracted from both elements - it has resulted in a game that is quite a bit less engaging, less fun than a 'pure' MMO or single player Elder Scrolls game.
Do many others feel this way? Is my opinion an outlier? A minority view? Or is there a large enough playerbase that have similar feelings that it may impact the future viability of ESO? If so, can it be fixed?
I know many will jump to the defense of the game and that's fine. I was defensive about criticism of the game during beta. But if your opinion differs from mine I will happily listen and accommodate it, if stated thoughtfully and civilly (i.e. I do realise there will be a backlash due to these views, but keep it cool please).