Maintenance for the week of April 6:
• PC/Mac: No maintenance – April 6

7-0-0 or 5-1-1 for Tank?

MrBrownstone
MrBrownstone
✭✭✭✭✭
So I just started tanking and it's really fun . Btw I refuse to use a staff, I play with pugs anyway so that 1.5% dps loss from the lack of full crusher is no big deal.

Anyway, I just realized that equipping 1 medium and 1 light piece increases only stamina and magicka because heavy armor already gives health. And I think that the bonus stats from the undaunted passive are not worth giving up on full 7 heavy pieces because This way I can't reach the resistance cap and forced to wear Lord Warden. I want to be able to use sets like Stonekeeper while having full resistances so I think wearing 7 heavy pieces is a better idea. My hp is the same anyway and wearing 5-1-1 only gives like 600-700 magicka/stamina while all heavy gives me around 2k more resistances, just enough to reach the cap.

What do you suggest?
Edited by MrBrownstone on March 16, 2019 5:02PM
  • Mojmir
    Mojmir
    ✭✭✭✭✭
    ✭✭✭✭✭
    5-1-1 is what i use, warden btw isnt just for the tank, it also helps the group inside the range.
  • IzzyStardust
    IzzyStardust
    ✭✭✭✭✭
    It really does depend for me; both on content and what I have. I prefer 5-1-1. Undaunted One gives more resources (health, stam, mag) generally, the other (all heavy) gives more resist. You can ez go over resist cap though - so it depends on your sets, spec, content. Also: what you have, until you get what you want.
    Edited by IzzyStardust on March 16, 2019 5:01PM
  • MartiniDaniels
    MartiniDaniels
    ✭✭✭✭✭
    ✭✭✭✭✭
    Do what you like, 95% of game encounters can be tanked in medium armor (if you are cp600+). Tanking is more about experience then raw stats.
  • Ghettokid
    Ghettokid
    ✭✭✭✭✭
    In Orc's life there's been heartache and pain
    I don't know if I can face Orc again
    Can't stop now, Orc has traveled so far
    To change this lonely Orc

    I wanna know what Orc is
    I want Orc to show me
    I wanna feel what Orc is
    I know Orc can show me
    Oh, oh, oorc
  • MrBrownstone
    MrBrownstone
    ✭✭✭✭✭
    I don't think reaching the resist cap is that easy without a monster set that gives resists. I have fully golded Ebon + Alkosh and I'm a Nord. I can't reach the cap without Lord Warden or full Heavy armor. Since I want to use Stonekeeper, 7-0-0 seems like my only option.
  • BattleAxe
    BattleAxe
    ✭✭✭✭✭
    First yes resistance is important but I learned after my first time tanking vet Hel ra resistance is only a small portion of tanking ur resources are actually very important and I always use 5-1-1. A ice staff back bar I use it to help with range taunting and maintaining my magicka so I can make effective use of my tanking tools.
  • IzzyStardust
    IzzyStardust
    ✭✭✭✭✭
    You wanna (as DK anyway; cannot speak for warden or others) shoot for min 32k health *in Ebon & Alkosh* (it will be much more in other sets), and just a touch more stam than mana - so that synergies return stam, and I use the atronach stone for mana regen - as I tank more DLC/4 person than trials; thus I need to chain and talon more, also range taunt etc.

    Learn to use balance sensibly. So that even with no healer, you can use balance.

    I suggest being a vampire for regen bonus +10%

    Perhaps if I tanked trials more, I’d change to health stone and more stam/mana with attribute points. I only ever tanked VAA, VAA HM & VHRC on vet, so I’m not equipped to speak from a trial tank or o/t perspective.

    Go and check out Woeler’s site (google woeler tank eso) as he has a lot of good tanking info.

    I’m not the best tank ever; but I’ve completed all DLC + HMs and more often than not, with no healer.
    Edited by IzzyStardust on March 16, 2019 5:11PM
  • MrBrownstone
    MrBrownstone
    ✭✭✭✭✭
    You wanna (as DK anyway; cannot speak for warden or others) shoot for min 32k health in Ebon Alkosh (it will be much more in other sets), and just a touch more stam than mana - and I use the atronach stone for mana regen - as I tank more DLC/4 person than trials; thus I need to chain and talon more, also range taunt etc. Perhaps if I tanked trials more, I’d change to health stone and more stam/mana with attribute points.

    Go and check out Woeler’s site (google woeler tank eso) as he has a lot of good tanking info.

    My stats are 20k/35k/22k

    I just noticed that Woeler wears an Alkosh Belt. Smart.
    Edited by MrBrownstone on March 16, 2019 5:15PM
  • IzzyStardust
    IzzyStardust
    ✭✭✭✭✭
    You wanna (as DK anyway; cannot speak for warden or others) shoot for min 32k health in Ebon Alkosh (it will be much more in other sets), and just a touch more stam than mana - and I use the atronach stone for mana regen - as I tank more DLC/4 person than trials; thus I need to chain and talon more, also range taunt etc. Perhaps if I tanked trials more, I’d change to health stone and more stam/mana with attribute points.

    Go and check out Woeler’s site (google woeler tank eso) as he has a lot of good tanking info.

    My stats are 20k/35k/22k

    I just noticed that Woeler wears an Alkosh Belt. Smart.

    ;-) woeler is pretty much Go To if you ask me! ♥️
  • r34lian
    r34lian
    ✭✭✭✭✭
    I go 7-0-0 on my nord dk tank with warden+ebon+ akaviri my resist caps with warden proc even with full sturdy gear don't even have to slot major ward resolve previously used bloodspawn^_^
    2000 CP • 18 Maxed Characters • 6 Altmers • 7 Redguards • Necromancer Orc • Warden Dunmer • DK Nord • DK Imperial • Templar Breton
  • IzzyStardust
    IzzyStardust
    ✭✭✭✭✭
    I don't think reaching the resist cap is that easy without a monster set that gives resists. I have fully golded Ebon + Alkosh and I'm a Nord. I can't reach the cap without Lord Warden or full Heavy armor. Since I want to use Stonekeeper, 7-0-0 seems like my only option.


    Yeah and also depends on sets - but yes - and when I mention resist I mean if you’re using spiked armor, or if it’s a situation where you think you need chudan; like if you need the spiked armor slot for something else, if you’re casting orbs, altar, offbalance, ele drain or whatever. Like when I’m resource/ele giving as tank, then I might wear chudan - but the rest of the time, spiked armor (I use hardened - just because that’s what I chose when I started; a lot of people also use volatile) should be up; so you can use whatever other monster set; such as the new one, etc.
  • Jeremy
    Jeremy
    ✭✭✭✭✭
    ✭✭✭✭✭
    So I just started tanking and it's really fun . Btw I refuse to use a staff, I play with pugs anyway so that 1.5% dps loss from the lack of full crusher is no big deal.

    Anyway, I just realized that equipping 1 medium and 1 light piece increases only stamina and magicka because heavy armor already gives health. And I think that the bonus stats from the undaunted passive are not worth giving up on full 7 heavy pieces because This way I can't reach the resistance cap and forced to wear Lord Warden. I want to be able to use sets like Stonekeeper while having full resistances so I think wearing 7 heavy pieces is a better idea. My hp is the same anyway and wearing 5-1-1 only gives like 600-700 magicka/stamina while all heavy gives me around 2k more resistances, just enough to reach the cap.

    What do you suggest?

    Might want to consider Fortified Brass. That might give you enough resistance to throw on Stonekeeper and wear what ever Monster set you want. There is always The Lady as well.

    But I also just like to wear all Heavy Armor on my tank. I"m not sure what causes it - but Heavy Armor seems to have some built in increase to defense that doesn't include resistance.
  • Billdor
    Billdor
    ✭✭✭✭
    Ghettokid wrote: »
    In Orc's life there's been heartache and pain
    I don't know if I can face Orc again
    Can't stop now, Orc has traveled so far
    To change this lonely Orc

    I wanna know what Orc is
    I want Orc to show me
    I wanna feel what Orc is
    I know Orc can show me
    Oh, oh, oorc

    What the ***..
  • IzzyStardust
    IzzyStardust
    ✭✭✭✭✭
    Question though: do you think the new set is worth the resource pools?

    I have it; but I’m just not sure yet.

    I mean; you’re essentially giving up pools you already have for regen based on proc; I’m not sure about that.

    I haven’t done the math yet though.
    Edited by IzzyStardust on March 16, 2019 5:56PM
  • IzzyStardust
    IzzyStardust
    ✭✭✭✭✭
    Also: re Alkosh: I don’t have to worry about that as much as a proper trial tank because often and esp with no healer; I’m not gonna get enough syn to keep the time up.
  • stimpy986b14_ESO
    stimpy986b14_ESO
    ✭✭✭✭
    If you have the undaunted passive, 5-1-1. Otherwise 7
  • firedrgn
    firedrgn
    ✭✭✭✭✭
    I am just getting into tanking so only advise i can give is keep a staff on hand so u can back bar staff for the ranged interrupt. Sometimes like in cos its a world of differance when pugging.
  • idk
    idk
    ✭✭✭✭✭
    ✭✭✭✭✭
    I don't think reaching the resist cap is that easy without a monster set that gives resists. I have fully golded Ebon + Alkosh and I'm a Nord. I can't reach the cap without Lord Warden or full Heavy armor. Since I want to use Stonekeeper, 7-0-0 seems like my only option.

    You do not need to reach the resist cap. Meta tank builds for the hardest content in the game have not been concerned with reaching the resist cap for over 2 years now. It is only with Torug that it happens for Spell Resist, but that is not why Torugs is worn.

    With that, 5/1/1 is helpful for max stats, especially health since that is often a tanks highest stat. Beyond that, wear what you want. You said you pug so you are not interested in running with a regular raid team where they will have a say in what you wear.
  • IzzyStardust
    IzzyStardust
    ✭✭✭✭✭
    firedrgn wrote: »
    I am just getting into tanking so only advise i can give is keep a staff on hand so u can back bar staff for the ranged interrupt. Sometimes like in cos its a world of differance when pugging.

    No; when I tank they can forget that. They can have altar, ele drain, orbs, and offbalance but I personally am not tanking, healing, buffing, ccing and doing ranged interrupt around the boss. I’ll bash where appropriate.

    Sorry but that’s not gonna happen - if people want me to do all the jobs, they’re welcome to get a different tank.
  • IzzyStardust
    IzzyStardust
    ✭✭✭✭✭
    idk wrote: »
    I don't think reaching the resist cap is that easy without a monster set that gives resists. I have fully golded Ebon + Alkosh and I'm a Nord. I can't reach the cap without Lord Warden or full Heavy armor. Since I want to use Stonekeeper, 7-0-0 seems like my only option.

    You do not need to reach the resist cap. Meta tank builds for the hardest content in the game have not been concerned with reaching the resist cap for over 2 years now. It is only with Torug that it happens for Spell Resist, but that is not why Torugs is worn.

    With that, 5/1/1 is helpful for max stats, especially health since that is often a tanks highest stat. Beyond that, wear what you want. You said you pug so you are not interested in running with a regular raid team where they will have a say in what you wear.

    Yeah I don’t think they were concerned about reaching cap; I myself was just saying that with skills+armour reaching cap is not hard and no need at all to go over.
    (Short reply as I’m on phone and doing dinnner)
  • frozzzen101
    frozzzen101
    ✭✭✭✭
    I tried 5/1/1 for longest time, but after switching to 7/0/0 I'm keeping it that way. As usually it's just rule of the thumb what you are and aren't comfortable as a tank, but reaching resist cap is really worth it in my opinion because every additional percentage of damage reduction is more and more cost efficient. And like you said, I want option to be able to use Earthgore, Thurvokun etc while being on resist cap with major ward/resolve. Protective jewelery is also really good if you aren't Nord. 7/0/0 also gives you more sustain than 5/1/1 via Constitution passive. After long time tanking I realized that resource sustain is #1 priority for me as rather than max stats pool as it allows me more active playstyle with skill being cast on every global cooldown - much more fun and involved. That's why I'm using Orzorga's Red Frothgar (5000 hp / 469 magregen) food instead of usual 3 stat food. I have 15k/15k resource pools but they are always healthy because of high investment in sustain.

    Also, do yourself a favor and try out ice staff for tanking. Not only because of crusher, you can use generic absorb stamina glyph to keep yourself healthy, but because skill line is full of amazing stuff. On 3 dd runs, being able to run ele drain is really good as it helps yourself and your group, plus it's free skill to use not wasting any of your resources and using global cooldowns more efficiently. Blockade is amazing as trash pull initiator as it will hit multiple enemies and keep them in with its 60% slow as you are chaining them and grouping them. Also crusher if you want. Both Impulse and shock clench do have some uses in more advanced strategies of some DLC dungeons, and crushing for ranged interupt can be very nice on stuff like Fang Lair Hardmode and some others. I can see why you wouldn't want to use staff, but it really makes tanking a more fun experience so feel free to try it out at least.

    Like everything in tanking it's personal preference and you can do without minmax setups or resist cap, but that's my two cents.
  • usmcjdking
    usmcjdking
    ✭✭✭✭✭
    ✭✭✭
    It really does depend for me; both on content and what I have. I prefer 5-1-1. Undaunted One gives more resources (health, stam, mag) generally, the other (all heavy) gives more resist. You can ez go over resist cap though - so it depends on your sets, spec, content. Also: what you have, until you get what you want.

    5/1/1 and 7 Heavy give the exact same amount of health.
    0331
    0602
  • idk
    idk
    ✭✭✭✭✭
    ✭✭✭✭✭
    usmcjdking wrote: »
    It really does depend for me; both on content and what I have. I prefer 5-1-1. Undaunted One gives more resources (health, stam, mag) generally, the other (all heavy) gives more resist. You can ez go over resist cap though - so it depends on your sets, spec, content. Also: what you have, until you get what you want.

    5/1/1 and 7 Heavy give the exact same amount of health.

    Yes and no. Since 5/1/1 provides more max stat it does allow more to be put into health.

    Maybe splitting hairs but it works well this way.
    Edited by idk on March 16, 2019 6:46PM
  • D0PAMINE
    D0PAMINE
    ✭✭✭✭✭
    ✭✭
    I go 5-1-1. Along with Vampire and Atronach Mundas it makes it easier imo to self sustain. I don't always have the luxury of having a healer, and Woelers builds deffinatly take that into consideration.
    Edited by D0PAMINE on March 16, 2019 8:31PM
  • MrBrownstone
    MrBrownstone
    ✭✭✭✭✭
    I tried 5/1/1 for longest time, but after switching to 7/0/0 I'm keeping it that way. As usually it's just rule of the thumb what you are and aren't comfortable as a tank, but reaching resist cap is really worth it in my opinion because every additional percentage of damage reduction is more and more cost efficient. And like you said, I want option to be able to use Earthgore, Thurvokun etc while being on resist cap with major ward/resolve. Protective jewelery is also really good if you aren't Nord. 7/0/0 also gives you more sustain than 5/1/1 via Constitution passive. After long time tanking I realized that resource sustain is #1 priority for me as rather than max stats pool as it allows me more active playstyle with skill being cast on every global cooldown - much more fun and involved. That's why I'm using Orzorga's Red Frothgar (5000 hp / 469 magregen) food instead of usual 3 stat food. I have 15k/15k resource pools but they are always healthy because of high investment in sustain.

    Also, do yourself a favor and try out ice staff for tanking. Not only because of crusher, you can use generic absorb stamina glyph to keep yourself healthy, but because skill line is full of amazing stuff. On 3 dd runs, being able to run ele drain is really good as it helps yourself and your group, plus it's free skill to use not wasting any of your resources and using global cooldowns more efficiently. Blockade is amazing as trash pull initiator as it will hit multiple enemies and keep them in with its 60% slow as you are chaining them and grouping them. Also crusher if you want. Both Impulse and shock clench do have some uses in more advanced strategies of some DLC dungeons, and crushing for ranged interupt can be very nice on stuff like Fang Lair Hardmode and some others. I can see why you wouldn't want to use staff, but it really makes tanking a more fun experience so feel free to try it out at least.

    Like everything in tanking it's personal preference and you can do without minmax setups or resist cap, but that's my two cents.

    I don't understand why people are so obsessed with max stats as a tank. After 5 seconds into the fight, your pools are no longer full and the only thing matters beyond that point is sustain. DDs benefit from max stats but as a tank I don't think +700 stamina is more useful than 2-3k more resist. I think I might switch to that food, it makes a lot of sense. I already use the Atronach but never thought of using regen food too.
  • MrBrownstone
    MrBrownstone
    ✭✭✭✭✭
    I don't think reaching the resist cap is that easy without a monster set that gives resists. I have fully golded Ebon + Alkosh and I'm a Nord. I can't reach the cap without Lord Warden or full Heavy armor. Since I want to use Stonekeeper, 7-0-0 seems like my only option.


    Yeah and also depends on sets - but yes - and when I mention resist I mean if you’re using spiked armor, or if it’s a situation where you think you need chudan; like if you need the spiked armor slot for something else, if you’re casting orbs, altar, offbalance, ele drain or whatever. Like when I’m resource/ele giving as tank, then I might wear chudan - but the rest of the time, spiked armor (I use hardened - just because that’s what I chose when I started; a lot of people also use volatile) should be up; so you can use whatever other monster set; such as the new one, etc.

    I use Balance already and can't hit 33k with 5-1-1 and Stonekeeper. Gonna switch to 7-0-0. Same hp, just 600-700 magicka/stamina loss. But nearly 5% more mitigation and like mentioned above, the resource return from passives are more important. I don't think higher stats matter for a tank, sustain is more important.
  • MrBrownstone
    MrBrownstone
    ✭✭✭✭✭
    D0PAMINE wrote: »
    I go 5-1-1. Along with Vampire and Artonach Mundas it makes it easier imo to self sustain. I don't always have the luxury of having a healer, and Woelers builds deffinatly take that into consideration.

    But more max stats =/= sustain.

    7-0-0 actually gives better sustain. You lose around 600-700 Magicka/Stamina, but the Constitution passive becomes more effective.
  • Rex-Umbra
    Rex-Umbra
    ✭✭✭✭✭
    ✭✭
    I tank in 5 light 🤗
    Xbox GT: Rex Umbrah
    GM of IMPERIUM since 2015.
  • Jeremy
    Jeremy
    ✭✭✭✭✭
    ✭✭✭✭✭
    I don't think reaching the resist cap is that easy without a monster set that gives resists. I have fully golded Ebon + Alkosh and I'm a Nord. I can't reach the cap without Lord Warden or full Heavy armor. Since I want to use Stonekeeper, 7-0-0 seems like my only option.


    Yeah and also depends on sets - but yes - and when I mention resist I mean if you’re using spiked armor, or if it’s a situation where you think you need chudan; like if you need the spiked armor slot for something else, if you’re casting orbs, altar, offbalance, ele drain or whatever. Like when I’m resource/ele giving as tank, then I might wear chudan - but the rest of the time, spiked armor (I use hardened - just because that’s what I chose when I started; a lot of people also use volatile) should be up; so you can use whatever other monster set; such as the new one, etc.

    I use Balance already and can't hit 33k with 5-1-1 and Stonekeeper. Gonna switch to 7-0-0. Same hp, just 600-700 magicka/stamina loss. But nearly 5% more mitigation and like mentioned above, the resource return from passives are more important. I don't think higher stats matter for a tank, sustain is more important.

    With the exception of health, I'd agree with you about higher stats don't matter as much for a tank. I"d rather have higher magicka regen for example than higher magicka. A higher health pool though can be pretty useful to a tank.
  • Liofa
    Liofa
    ✭✭✭✭✭
    ✭✭
    7 Heavy gives little more Resistances while 5/1/1 gives little more off stats and little more sustain. Really not much difference, I prefer 7 Heavy though. If you are Nord, definitely go with 5/1/1.
Sign In or Register to comment.