Let me start with this: I'm on console and can't PTS so all I could really know so far is what I've read and heard. I'm also mostly speaking of the DPS role with being most familiar with sorcs. I do play magblade, magwarden, and magplar though as well. I rarely play stam and am unfamiliar with the impacts to that playstyle though I'd love to hear how it may be effected.
From what I've come across so far it's sounding like monster sets, vMA/vDSA weapons, and trials gear are really going to lose a lot of their worth in PvE with Horns of the Reach. Some of the highest DPS testing is coming from 2 5-piece sets with a monster shoulder and crafted staves (MS+Julianos is a big one). I've seen many other ideas all involving a similar set up. If that's the way we're headed for the next update then these high end items that many have spent hundreds of hours trying to get really aren't all that important anymore.
Most monster sets are being nerfed, some heavily. This is pretty well understood to be a move to appease primary PvP players. Not a big deal, balance requires sacrifice. The impact to PvE seems pretty minimal there. The only problem being now it seems you can get very similar damage parses with or without the sets. Where is the incentive to hunt for these sets if in fact that's true? Where does that put the new monster sets that are at the heart of the DLC that brings these changes?
Similar to the monster sets, I'm hearing of damage parses that pull similar or even better numbers with crafted staves over vMA/vDSA staves. These seem more situational but overall it's starting to sound like non vMA/vDSA staves are going to get more use. Again, where is the incentive to get these? vDSA especially has been rough gear-wise for awhile now.
As far as trials gear goes, I haven't heard a ton of speculation on this. I only wonder because I see more builds using the jewelry only or jewelry+staff and not as often the full 5 piece. I'm sure there will still be many that go MD/IA + 5 piece + Monster set but I'd be willing to bet that if things play out the way they seem to be headed there wont be as many for sure if 5+5+1 becomes the meta.
Does this create better diversity or make it worse? Is a large portion of this game about to be no longer relevant anymore? Have we spent all this time fighting through some of the toughest material the game has to offer for it to just not matter now? Or is it just nothing to worry about?
Thought? Comments? Trolling and disdain?