There are some animation bugs when you go fishing whilst using the Scholar Personality. [Tested on the NA/PC Server]
1: As can be seen in the following video, after you catch a fish by pressing "E", during the "strike" animation the fishing rod is replaced by a book and quill in your hands.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=XLkQ0-28cSc
2: If my character claps after catching a fish, she has a book flat against one palm and a quill flat against the other whilst clapping.
3: During the idle animation for fishing, from the player's perspective you again have a book flat against one palm and a quill flat against the other (you are not holding them, they are just pressed flat against your hands). From another player's perspective, you look normal.