Ya that websites kind of terrible, it only has the obvious up on it, thanks for trying to help tho

ThePonzzz wrote: »

Guild traders sound like a nightmare without Master Merchant and AwesomeGuildStore.

A nightmare would actually be an improvement.

warrior9880 wrote: »

I'm on Xbox one and I was hoping there would be some kind of price estimators, I have some Stygian rings and sharp Stygian inferno and can't find any in guild traders. I'm not sure if they are worth much but can't find any to compare to. Anyone know anything?

I'm just curious on where you're looking, because I see these items in guild stores frequently, with each one at insanely ridiculous prices.

The problem with guild stores is the cost of the listing fee and house cut is directly added to the price of the item, which means the seller is getting less than what's listed. So consider this when you're trying to judge prices.

If it were me, I'd head to popular areas and enter chat and sell directly without the middleman of a guild. Set your price to a reasonable amount, and you can easily sell your item(s).

Reasonable should entail the following:
- did it take you 2 hours to run a vet dungeon where you obtained the item?
- Was this the only dungeon the item drops?
- how "rare" is it really?
- who is the target buyer? Mid level? High level?
- what would YOU deem as a fair price if you were the buyer?

Don't be afraid to undercut guild store prices. The transaction should make you feel comfortable, not what others think you should sell it for, and both should be pleased with the trade.

Yeah, it's horrible. I found 2 Kuta runes, and 'Google' told me they were worth anywhere between 12.000 each and 500 each. I asked one of my guilds and a dude told me 10.000 for the pair was reasonable so i put them in the Trader for that amount and sold them about a day later so I assume he was probably spot on. But there is no real good way to check.

Tomg999 wrote: »

Without an addon, the best way is to look at a busy guild or two and look up the item and check price vs how long it's been for sale. When there are many entires like with Kuta, you can kind of figure it out.
If a bunch have been for sale for 24-28 days at around 1 price, and a higher price has like 10 days, the price for the recently listed items is probably close. If the item has like 7 days left, the price may be too high (or the item more rarely needed).

Since I belong to several trader guilds, I go to the bank and can quickly check prices at several guilds.

Just ignore the super high prices for things. Some are newbies, some are fools, some are buying from gold sellers.

Yes, running with master merchant you can see lots of idiot prices.
It might also be an guild store thing, some fool sell something at 10x normal price so the others tries to sell it a bit cheaper.
And yes the posting date is important. something who has been out for weeks is overpriced.
The good location guild stores is nice places to check as they tend to have mostly good traders so they don't try to pull many overpriced items.