Just my opinion that it could be confusing....because of how these are achieved, it could cause confusion for those who have nameplates on.

If this happened I ask that group role icons appear on characters heads vs the arrows and crown

Idk really.
My dd chars have "dungeon healer" and "dungeon blocker" too and on an actual healer I got my "trials healer" achievement before even finishing its first trial.
The requirements for these are very low. Actually I think they havent changed them after softcap removal.

KoshkaMurka wrote: »

Idk really.
My dd chars have "dungeon healer" and "dungeon blocker" too and on an actual healer I got my "trials healer" achievement before even finishing its first trial.
The requirements for these are very low. Actually I think they havent changed them after softcap removal.

I think they were, but power creep has rendered their values pretty meaningless. I mean, I've got a NB DPS that hasn't run a dungeon in ages who's 30% of the way towards the 10m damage blocker achievement.

Reread my description for these achievements. The normal ones we already can get also count Delves as Dungeons, which makes them way too easy and practically worthless. These achievement titles however would only count your earnings inside group dungeons.

KoshkaMurka wrote: »

ArchMikem wrote: »

Reread my description for these achievements. The normal ones we already can get also count Delves as Dungeons, which makes them way too easy and practically worthless. These achievement titles however would only count your earnings inside group dungeons.

It doesnt matter. Still, they can be obtained very fast.
Highest tier of these achieves is 10 mil which isnt much considering how much hp the mobs have...

Then increase the ammount needed. I tried to make the descriptions as specific as possible so they wouldnt be earned as easily by people not playing the roles for them.

If I may offer a few ways to construct it so it weeds out the fakers and isn't that vulnerable to being gamed?

Couldn't be a flat X many points of damage dealt / healed / blocked. That's just another grind that proves nothing. It would have to be keyed according to the % damage you did of the group, % damage the group received that you healed, % damage the mobs gave that you blocked. Starts at zero in each dungeon. PC players can calculate this right now with their addons, their addon knows their own damage and knows the stats of the mobs on the screen, so no big change here. I think the way to make this work well would be to set high thresholds for getting credit for the achievement. Like, 50% of the damage comes from one person, 80% of the healing came from the healer, tank blocked 70% of the total damage. High thresholds so people have to work at it.

Couldn't be just a one-time hurdle to overcome. Just about anybody can heal normal fungal 1. It might need to require multiple dungeons to avoid just running fungal 1, and multiple times to demonstrate that it wasn't just a fluke. So, maybe require 2/3rds of the dungeons? And each has to be completed maybe 4 times?

And, add 'Champion' to the title for achieving the requirements with the stronger versions of the dungeons. So we can tell the difference between a person that has only done a role on normals and one who has gone the distance on the harder content.

Karius_Imalthar wrote: »

These titles are extremely easy to get and don't even require a group or even going into an actual group dungeon. You could sit in a public dungeon, find a group of mobs, stand there and heal yourself occasionally and get the defender and healer achievements.

Thats the opposite of what i said. Public Dungeons do not count as they are more on par wih Delves than legit Group Dungeons, which i have specified.

@Cryptical 's suggestion is a great additive requirement.

ForsakenSin wrote: »

@Tryxus

Tryxus wrote: »

"Blamed the healer"

That's the title I want

LOL as a Healer can i get title that says "Stop being Leeroy Jenkins Damm it!!!! "

If i can get that on my tank too Sure

Karius did point out a problem.

Vet white gold has been soloed. So has vet cradle. And vet fungal 2 with the boss that chains you down. Vet imperial prison is in process of being soloed.

So, just tap into the BoP loot code to make these things not count unless you are grouped and the group mates are present. Which would forestall being able to solo those titles.

Also, being able to solo means being able to get credit for all 3 roles with each run, even when grouped. Maybe add a time limit, so that a single person grouped with a tag along still can't farm them because it takes too long.