I got the Reaper title on three characters so far and I'm swimming in motifs and have multiples of both masks.

Just hit 100 skulls and got the title yesterday.
Have multiples of all recipes and motifs (and this is with giving away spares to random strangers who were after the achievement.)
Found the Pumpkin Mask around my 5th/6th skull but still trying for an elusive Scarecrow Mask.

Have to say, the community on the whole have been great, some people even giving back what I had given them after they started getting doubles themselves.
Made a few new friends!

It still is civil....telling you that you missed somthing and should read properly on a forum is not exactly hostile

Well over 200 skulls across all my characters and not one mask yet... RNGeesus hates me.

Got all masks before 50 skulls. Got all motif chapters although some of that was through trading. I have all recipes, (haven't received the gold recipe yet but just decided to buy it in guild store)

Farming sets so have had literally 100s of them, had 4 bloody Mara recipes and 5 scarecrow masks, I destroy most of the loot now it takes up too much space.

I still haven't had a pumpkin drop but I did manage to swap a scarecrow for one.

I have been enjoying this event, it's pretty awesome and definitely love it! Gotten all the motifs and recipe's including the gold one...just the masks.. But in all honesty....I really, really, really wish they could raise the Drop rate for the masks...like really, lol .... it's almost exhausting having to go through all the fighting getting 100 plunder skull plus more, just getting repeats of the recipes and motifs....Doesn't feel like it's worth the fight anymore.. -_- I have gotten so many of them repeats, me and my crew are about the same on the drop rate for masks. Only two guild mates have gotten one scarecrow, and one pumpkin.. Haven't gotten one since that day (First day at the event..).

I've read in chat that certain people have gotten like 5 of each mask on just one of their Characters... Maybe ESO can raise the drop rate of them since it's towards the end of the event? It can be their Halloween extra treat to us! ^_^ Lol. I've seen other games that had this issue where they raised the drop rate of the special, special item so everyone could have a better chance. It would be a blessing!!.. (Not trying to be ungrateful..But would be fair to everyone!)

Keeps getting the same motifs over and over shoulders and axes still waiting for a helm got one gold recipe but no masks. Would have done close to 100 skulls now. That is the way the ESO cookie crumbles I suppose.

I opened about 100 with no mask (other nice things, though), then one day first three had both masks. But I'm not sure do I really need them. Is there any point of selling them? Prise must be pretty low.

I got a gold Hollowjack Motif yesterday from a plunder skull!