Maintenance for the week of December 15:
· [COMPLETE] PC/Mac: NA and EU megaservers for maintenance – December 15, 4:00AM EST (9:00 UTC) - 12:00PM EST (17:00 UTC)
· [COMPLETE] Xbox: NA and EU megaservers for maintenance – December 15, 4:00AM EST (9:00 UTC) - 12:00PM EST (17:00 UTC)
· [COMPLETE] PlayStation®: NA and EU megaservers for maintenance – December 15, 4:00AM EST (9:00 UTC) - 12:00PM EST (17:00 UTC)

Scathing Mage Set (Question to ZOS)

dantator
dantator
✭✭✭
Hi guys,

So, if you read the description in the tool tip for the 5 set bonus it is a little unclear.

(5 items) Scathing Mage
10% chance when causing Critical Damage to increase your Spell Damage by 516 for 6 seconds.


After, testing the set and reading the forums it seems as if the 5 set bonus doesn't proc of DoTs and AOE crits. I was just wondering if it was intended to work like this or is it just a bug?

My first assumption was that Critical Damage is any critical damage. DoTs and AOE do crit so one can assume that it does proc of DoTs and AOE. Now when you think about it if it were to proc of DoTs and aoe it would be powerful but if you consider that you can't crit people when they have their shields up it is kinda balanced imo.

So, ZOS can you clarify to us if the set is working as intended and if it is working as intended I think the description should be clarified too.
+Divine Force+

+Divines+
  • kuscoe
    kuscoe
    ✭✭✭
    dantator wrote: »
    Hi guys,

    So, if you read the description in the tool tip for the 5 set bonus it is a little unclear.

    (5 items) Scathing Mage
    10% chance when causing Critical Damage to increase your Spell Damage by 516 for 6 seconds.


    After, testing the set and reading the forums it seems as if the 5 set bonus doesn't proc of DoTs and AOE crits. I was just wondering if it was intended to work like this or is it just a bug?

    My first assumption was that Critical Damage is any critical damage. DoTs and AOE do crit so one can assume that it does proc of DoTs and AOE. Now when you think about it if it were to proc of DoTs and aoe it would be powerful but if you consider that you can't crit people when they have their shields up it is kinda balanced imo.

    So, ZOS can you clarify to us if the set is working as intended and if it is working as intended I think the description should be clarified too.

    Seen some pretty weird stuff with this set, it seems to proc off Jabs which is considered a DoT

    Bump for Clarity

    @ZOS_GinaBruno @ZOS_RichLambert
  • dantator
    dantator
    ✭✭✭
    kuscoe wrote: »
    dantator wrote: »
    Hi guys,

    So, if you read the description in the tool tip for the 5 set bonus it is a little unclear.

    (5 items) Scathing Mage
    10% chance when causing Critical Damage to increase your Spell Damage by 516 for 6 seconds.


    After, testing the set and reading the forums it seems as if the 5 set bonus doesn't proc of DoTs and AOE crits. I was just wondering if it was intended to work like this or is it just a bug?

    My first assumption was that Critical Damage is any critical damage. DoTs and AOE do crit so one can assume that it does proc of DoTs and AOE. Now when you think about it if it were to proc of DoTs and aoe it would be powerful but if you consider that you can't crit people when they have their shields up it is kinda balanced imo.

    So, ZOS can you clarify to us if the set is working as intended and if it is working as intended I think the description should be clarified too.

    Seen some pretty weird stuff with this set, it seems to proc off Jabs which is considered a DoT

    Bump for Clarity

    @ZOS_GinaBruno @ZOS_RichLambert

    Oh wow, that is weird. I really do like this set because I've always wanted a crit build.
    +Divine Force+

    +Divines+
  • SahrotRein
    SahrotRein
    ✭✭✭✭
    There's more set bonuses that do not proc their passive on DoTs and critical hits on AoE spells. For example, some time ago Sorcerer's Surge was "patched" and it didn't heal the player anymore when causing critical hits on AoE (ex: Liquid Lightning), Valkyn doesn't proc its effect on DoTs too.
    Today we make our stand. Today we take back the Ruby Throne, which is ours by ancient right and the blessings of the Divines.

    - A Dominion of peace. The fair and just rule of Tamriel
  • Anhedonie
    Anhedonie
    ✭✭✭✭✭
    ✭✭
    dantator wrote: »
    Hi guys,

    So, if you read the description in the tool tip for the 5 set bonus it is a little unclear.

    (5 items) Scathing Mage
    10% chance when causing Critical Damage to increase your Spell Damage by 516 for 6 seconds.


    After, testing the set and reading the forums it seems as if the 5 set bonus doesn't proc of DoTs and AOE crits. I was just wondering if it was intended to work like this or is it just a bug?

    My first assumption was that Critical Damage is any critical damage. DoTs and AOE do crit so one can assume that it does proc of DoTs and AOE. Now when you think about it if it were to proc of DoTs and aoe it would be powerful but if you consider that you can't crit people when they have their shields up it is kinda balanced imo.

    So, ZOS can you clarify to us if the set is working as intended and if it is working as intended I think the description should be clarified too.

    It can proc on first tick of Radiant Destruction or Puncturing Sweeps.
    Profanity filter is a crime against the freedom of speech. Also gags.
  • dantator
    dantator
    ✭✭✭
    Runaan wrote: »
    There's more set bonuses that do not proc their passive on DoTs and critical hits on AoE spells. For example, some time ago Sorcerer's Surge was "patched" and it didn't heal the player anymore when causing critical hits on AoE (ex: Liquid Lightning), Valkyn doesn't proc its effect on DoTs too.

    So, pretty much you are implying it's bugged right now?
    +Divine Force+

    +Divines+
  • dantator
    dantator
    ✭✭✭
    Anhedonie wrote: »
    dantator wrote: »
    Hi guys,

    So, if you read the description in the tool tip for the 5 set bonus it is a little unclear.

    (5 items) Scathing Mage
    10% chance when causing Critical Damage to increase your Spell Damage by 516 for 6 seconds.


    After, testing the set and reading the forums it seems as if the 5 set bonus doesn't proc of DoTs and AOE crits. I was just wondering if it was intended to work like this or is it just a bug?

    My first assumption was that Critical Damage is any critical damage. DoTs and AOE do crit so one can assume that it does proc of DoTs and AOE. Now when you think about it if it were to proc of DoTs and aoe it would be powerful but if you consider that you can't crit people when they have their shields up it is kinda balanced imo.

    So, ZOS can you clarify to us if the set is working as intended and if it is working as intended I think the description should be clarified too.

    It can proc on first tick of Radiant Destruction or Puncturing Sweeps.

    Hmm, interesting...
    +Divine Force+

    +Divines+
  • EgoRush
    EgoRush
    ✭✭✭✭
    dantator wrote: »
    Anhedonie wrote: »
    dantator wrote: »
    Hi guys,

    So, if you read the description in the tool tip for the 5 set bonus it is a little unclear.

    (5 items) Scathing Mage
    10% chance when causing Critical Damage to increase your Spell Damage by 516 for 6 seconds.


    After, testing the set and reading the forums it seems as if the 5 set bonus doesn't proc of DoTs and AOE crits. I was just wondering if it was intended to work like this or is it just a bug?

    My first assumption was that Critical Damage is any critical damage. DoTs and AOE do crit so one can assume that it does proc of DoTs and AOE. Now when you think about it if it were to proc of DoTs and aoe it would be powerful but if you consider that you can't crit people when they have their shields up it is kinda balanced imo.

    So, ZOS can you clarify to us if the set is working as intended and if it is working as intended I think the description should be clarified too.

    It can proc on first tick of Radiant Destruction or Puncturing Sweeps.

    Hmm, interesting...

    Yeah for channeled abilities it seems the first tick counts as a hit, where as each subsequent tick is a DoT, hence it can proc on the first hit but not on any after.
    Server: EU Pact
    Guild: Hodor (PvE - www.hodor-guild.eu), Chimaira (PvE)
    Character: Oriantha (Templar Healer), Zelda's Inferno (Dragonknight Tank), The Lumen Sage (Stamina Sorcerer DD), The Umbra Witch (Magicka Nightblade DD), Flirts-With-Boys (Stamina Nightblade DD), Oriantha Ellesidil (Magicka Sorcerer DD/healer), Wariantha (Magicka Warden in the making)

    Current vMA score (Templar): Pending return to game
    World Record for all trials pre-Thieves Guild
    World first V16 Maw of Lorkhaj clear
    World first V16 Maw of Lorkhaj speed run clear
    Returning to the game for Morrowind
Sign In or Register to comment.