Maintenance for the week of April 6:
• PC/Mac: No maintenance – April 6

A suggestion for balancing Cloak

  • dsalter
    dsalter
    ✭✭✭✭✭
    ✭✭
    they just need alittle less speed, seeing a guy run off faster than any projectile is an issue of balance in itself. many times have they fail ganked me, i start winning the fight, then they try the whole cloak spam, i detect potion but oh no! little miss speed cloaker is running off so fast i cant even attempt to keep up. gj taking away night silences speed boost stacking with night stalker when it's NB's built in speed thats unbalanced.
    PLEASE REPLY TO ME WITH @dsalter otherwise i'm likely to miss the reply if its not my own thread

    EU - [Arch Mage Dave] Altmer Sorcerer
    Fight back at the crates and boxes, together we can change things.

  • Cathexis
    Cathexis
    ✭✭✭✭✭
    dsalter wrote: »
    they just need alittle less speed, seeing a guy run off faster than any projectile is an issue of balance in itself. many times have they fail ganked me, i start winning the fight, then they try the whole cloak spam, i detect potion but oh no! little miss speed cloaker is running off so fast i cant even attempt to keep up. gj taking away night silences speed boost stacking with night stalker when it's NB's built in speed thats unbalanced.

    I don't honk cloak would work very well without run speed.

    But it should get the same treatment as every other auto escape skill has; compounding casting costs.
    Tome of Alteration Magic I - Reality is an Ancient Dwemer Construct: Everything You Need to Know About FPS
    https://forums.elderscrollsonline.com/en/discussion/520903/tomb-of-fps-alteration-magic-everything-you-need-to-know-about-fps

    Tome of Alteration Magic II - The Manual of the Deceiver: A Beginner's Guide to Thieving
    https://forums.elderscrollsonline.com/en/discussion/462509/tome-of-alteration-mastery-ii-the-decievers-manual-thieving-guide-for-new-characters

    Ultrawide ESO Adventure Screenshots - 7680 x 1080 Resolution
    https://forums.elderscrollsonline.com/en/discussion/505262/adventures-in-ultra-ultrawide-an-ongoing-series
  • killingspreeb16_ESO
    killingspreeb16_ESO
    ✭✭✭✭
    Cathexis wrote: »
    dsalter wrote: »
    they just need alittle less speed, seeing a guy run off faster than any projectile is an issue of balance in itself. many times have they fail ganked me, i start winning the fight, then they try the whole cloak spam, i detect potion but oh no! little miss speed cloaker is running off so fast i cant even attempt to keep up. gj taking away night silences speed boost stacking with night stalker when it's NB's built in speed thats unbalanced.

    I don't honk cloak would work very well without run speed.

    But it should get the same treatment as every other auto escape skill has; compounding casting costs.

    Wel bolt was not possible to stop by drinking a pot or slot a skill (and some other counter) so is a bit different.

    If still good for stamina NB im fine,but then the Magika NB who rely on cloak should get something to stay alive,or they defense is alredy good enough? is something that will need some time to balance or the build can be more than useless.

  • Master_Kas
    Master_Kas
    ✭✭✭✭✭
    ✭✭
    Lets put increasing costs on every skill that gets spammed, shall we not ?

    Bol spam = cost increase
    gdb/scales spam = cost increase
    Shieldspam = cost increase

    Only things without a cost increase = light and heavy attacks .

    :trollface:

    Jokes aside, put cost increase on cloak to and watch nb fall to the bottom. I'm hardly playing latley just waiting for something else to pop up. So nerf away. =)
    Edited by Master_Kas on September 12, 2015 12:19AM
    EU | PC
  • Master_Kas
    Master_Kas
    ✭✭✭✭✭
    ✭✭
    Ezareth wrote: »
    Levo18 wrote: »
    If they nerf cloak nightblades become useless because its a core mechanic of the whole class. A nightblade without cloak is just a sword wielding nobody.

    Cloak is a crutch and there are far better aspects to the NB class than cloak.

    Cloak currently is an issue for everyone not running Piercing Mark but I don't know that I really support nerfing it. I think perhaps the OPs suggestion isn't a terrible idea..and would be a far better solution than the 33% increase on consecutive casts that ZoS is bound to put on it at some point if people don't stop crying about it.

    Out of curiosity, how do you stay alive vs good/better players without cloak in the new patch, with the nerf to block and dodgeroll? Atm I'm specced alot into magicka to be able to use cloak more since you can run OOS pretty quickly with ccbreaks/attacking/rolling. If cloak gets nerfed, I think nb will be in a very bad spot.

    Healdebuffs makes vigor/rally very bad, so not enough to keep you alive with all befouled enchants and healdebuffs.

    Sorry if I misspelled something ^^
    Edited by Master_Kas on September 12, 2015 12:23AM
    EU | PC
  • Poxheart
    Poxheart
    ✭✭✭✭✭
    JDar wrote: »
    It's a strong ability that nightblades are supposed to have. Not a crutch. Why do you think it is the first ability in the skill tree?

    You say this like Nightblades don't have two other skill lines. Why don't you see Nightblades make claims about Assasin's Blade or Strife being class defining skills? Because neither of those skills are crutches that help bad players punch above their skill level, that's why.
    JDar wrote: »
    Edit: I think calling it a crutch is even more dubious as I try to imagine playing a magicka melee class in light armor with no cloak just healing ward and fear in a game of high physical damage. Sorcs and templars wear light armor also but they have shields and burst heals.You're supposed to use it, especially given the devs made it proc Shadow Barrier and synergize with Concealed Weapon/Surprise Attack. Vigor is a crutch, cloak is not.

    It's convenient how you ignored Shadow Image, a skill that's equally good as Cloak as an escape tool. The difference being it takes more skill to be effective (meaning you can't spam it the way you can Cloak). Also, activating any skill in the shadow tree is supposed* to proc Shadow Barrier, which (by the way) gets increased duration based each piece of heavy armor equipped, so get out of here with that magicka Nightblades only wear light armor nonsense.
    JDar wrote: »
    Why don't you take cloak off your bar and let me know how far you get, since you don't need it then? :)

    Just because I use the skill doesn't mean I can't acknowledge how strong it is.


    *I put that caveat in because this is ZoS afterall; there's no telling how accurate the tool tip for Shadow Barrier really is.
    Unsubbed and no longer playing, but still checking the Alliance War forum for the lulz.

    Pox Dragon Knight
    Poxheart Nightblade
    The Murder Hobo Dragon Knight - Blackwater Blade
    Knights of the WhiteWolf
  • CP5
    CP5
    ✭✭✭✭✭
    ✭✭✭
    Poxheart wrote: »
    JDar wrote: »
    It's a strong ability that nightblades are supposed to have. Not a crutch. Why do you think it is the first ability in the skill tree?

    You say this like Nightblades don't have two other skill lines. Why don't you see Nightblades make claims about Assasin's Blade or Strife being class defining skills? Because neither of those skills are crutches that help bad players punch above their skill level, that's why.
    JDar wrote: »
    Edit: I think calling it a crutch is even more dubious as I try to imagine playing a magicka melee class in light armor with no cloak just healing ward and fear in a game of high physical damage. Sorcs and templars wear light armor also but they have shields and burst heals.You're supposed to use it, especially given the devs made it proc Shadow Barrier and synergize with Concealed Weapon/Surprise Attack. Vigor is a crutch, cloak is not.

    It's convenient how you ignored Shadow Image, a skill that's equally good as Cloak as an escape tool. The difference being it takes more skill to be effective (meaning you can't spam it the way you can Cloak). Also, activating any skill in the shadow tree is supposed* to proc Shadow Barrier, which (by the way) gets increased duration based each piece of heavy armor equipped, so get out of here with that magicka Nightblades only wear light armor nonsense.
    JDar wrote: »
    Why don't you take cloak off your bar and let me know how far you get, since you don't need it then? :)

    Just because I use the skill doesn't mean I can't acknowledge how strong it is.


    *I put that caveat in because this is ZoS afterall; there's no telling how accurate the tool tip for Shadow Barrier really is.

    All the nb's claiming that cloak is the only thing their class has, and that without it they are worthless... I don't know what exactly to say right now (almost 3am after a long day so should be asleep not writing) but the class has so much going for it that if a nb says they are squishy or need to be able to always evade their enemies I would want to point out all of their options. But then they would cloak away before I finished listing them all.
  • Lava_Croft
    Lava_Croft
    ✭✭✭✭✭
    ✭✭✭✭
    Nerfing Cloak will only lead to more DragonBlades.

    Fun gameplay.
    Edited by Lava_Croft on September 12, 2015 11:22AM
  • Digiman
    Digiman
    ✭✭✭✭✭
    Cloak isn't unbalanced, actually it's fine the way it is. It doesn't stop spells in flight and works well as a great escape tool.

    As long as the spell isn't changed to constantly remove debuffs, stuns and snares and avoid damage it's balanced.
  • Master_Kas
    Master_Kas
    ✭✭✭✭✭
    ✭✭
    Lava_Croft wrote: »
    Nerfing Cloak will only lead to more DragonBlades.

    Fun gameplay.

    What do you mean with dragonblades? Just wanna see if it's the same thing I'm imagening.

    1h shield nbs? :trollface:
    EU | PC
  • killingspreeb16_ESO
    killingspreeb16_ESO
    ✭✭✭✭
    CP5 wrote: »
    Poxheart wrote: »
    JDar wrote: »
    It's a strong ability that nightblades are supposed to have. Not a crutch. Why do you think it is the first ability in the skill tree?

    You say this like Nightblades don't have two other skill lines. Why don't you see Nightblades make claims about Assasin's Blade or Strife being class defining skills? Because neither of those skills are crutches that help bad players punch above their skill level, that's why.
    JDar wrote: »
    Edit: I think calling it a crutch is even more dubious as I try to imagine playing a magicka melee class in light armor with no cloak just healing ward and fear in a game of high physical damage. Sorcs and templars wear light armor also but they have shields and burst heals.You're supposed to use it, especially given the devs made it proc Shadow Barrier and synergize with Concealed Weapon/Surprise Attack. Vigor is a crutch, cloak is not.

    It's convenient how you ignored Shadow Image, a skill that's equally good as Cloak as an escape tool. The difference being it takes more skill to be effective (meaning you can't spam it the way you can Cloak). Also, activating any skill in the shadow tree is supposed* to proc Shadow Barrier, which (by the way) gets increased duration based each piece of heavy armor equipped, so get out of here with that magicka Nightblades only wear light armor nonsense.
    JDar wrote: »
    Why don't you take cloak off your bar and let me know how far you get, since you don't need it then? :)

    Just because I use the skill doesn't mean I can't acknowledge how strong it is.


    *I put that caveat in because this is ZoS afterall; there's no telling how accurate the tool tip for Shadow Barrier really is.

    All the nb's claiming that cloak is the only thing their class has, and that without it they are worthless... I don't know what exactly to say right now (almost 3am after a long day so should be asleep not writing) but the class has so much going for it that if a nb says they are squishy or need to be able to always evade their enemies I would want to point out all of their options. But then they would cloak away before I finished listing them all.

    All the other class that claiming cloak is impossible to counter and without detect pot Nb are impossible to kill,pick a counter slot it in your bar and GG you can now finally counter cloak!since youre a sorc daedric curse/bolt escape work well against Cloak.

    And yes NB are squishi.
  • CP5
    CP5
    ✭✭✭✭✭
    ✭✭✭
    CP5 wrote: »
    Poxheart wrote: »
    JDar wrote: »
    It's a strong ability that nightblades are supposed to have. Not a crutch. Why do you think it is the first ability in the skill tree?

    You say this like Nightblades don't have two other skill lines. Why don't you see Nightblades make claims about Assasin's Blade or Strife being class defining skills? Because neither of those skills are crutches that help bad players punch above their skill level, that's why.
    JDar wrote: »
    Edit: I think calling it a crutch is even more dubious as I try to imagine playing a magicka melee class in light armor with no cloak just healing ward and fear in a game of high physical damage. Sorcs and templars wear light armor also but they have shields and burst heals.You're supposed to use it, especially given the devs made it proc Shadow Barrier and synergize with Concealed Weapon/Surprise Attack. Vigor is a crutch, cloak is not.

    It's convenient how you ignored Shadow Image, a skill that's equally good as Cloak as an escape tool. The difference being it takes more skill to be effective (meaning you can't spam it the way you can Cloak). Also, activating any skill in the shadow tree is supposed* to proc Shadow Barrier, which (by the way) gets increased duration based each piece of heavy armor equipped, so get out of here with that magicka Nightblades only wear light armor nonsense.
    JDar wrote: »
    Why don't you take cloak off your bar and let me know how far you get, since you don't need it then? :)

    Just because I use the skill doesn't mean I can't acknowledge how strong it is.


    *I put that caveat in because this is ZoS afterall; there's no telling how accurate the tool tip for Shadow Barrier really is.

    All the nb's claiming that cloak is the only thing their class has, and that without it they are worthless... I don't know what exactly to say right now (almost 3am after a long day so should be asleep not writing) but the class has so much going for it that if a nb says they are squishy or need to be able to always evade their enemies I would want to point out all of their options. But then they would cloak away before I finished listing them all.

    All the other class that claiming cloak is impossible to counter and without detect pot Nb are impossible to kill,pick a counter slot it in your bar and GG you can now finally counter cloak!since youre a sorc daedric curse/bolt escape work well against Cloak.

    And yes NB are squishi.

    The class runs as you build them. If you put all your eggs in one basket with cloak of course you'll see your class as easy to kill when countered. Also I have to say, if you are invisible, moving at or above sprint speed, not even including fear or teleporting, that telling people to "just spam aoe's" is a funny idea. But yes, nb is easy to counter and stop, when I play mine I only rarely die.
  • killingspreeb16_ESO
    killingspreeb16_ESO
    ✭✭✭✭
    CP5 wrote: »
    CP5 wrote: »
    Poxheart wrote: »
    JDar wrote: »
    It's a strong ability that nightblades are supposed to have. Not a crutch. Why do you think it is the first ability in the skill tree?

    You say this like Nightblades don't have two other skill lines. Why don't you see Nightblades make claims about Assasin's Blade or Strife being class defining skills? Because neither of those skills are crutches that help bad players punch above their skill level, that's why.
    JDar wrote: »
    Edit: I think calling it a crutch is even more dubious as I try to imagine playing a magicka melee class in light armor with no cloak just healing ward and fear in a game of high physical damage. Sorcs and templars wear light armor also but they have shields and burst heals.You're supposed to use it, especially given the devs made it proc Shadow Barrier and synergize with Concealed Weapon/Surprise Attack. Vigor is a crutch, cloak is not.

    It's convenient how you ignored Shadow Image, a skill that's equally good as Cloak as an escape tool. The difference being it takes more skill to be effective (meaning you can't spam it the way you can Cloak). Also, activating any skill in the shadow tree is supposed* to proc Shadow Barrier, which (by the way) gets increased duration based each piece of heavy armor equipped, so get out of here with that magicka Nightblades only wear light armor nonsense.
    JDar wrote: »
    Why don't you take cloak off your bar and let me know how far you get, since you don't need it then? :)

    Just because I use the skill doesn't mean I can't acknowledge how strong it is.


    *I put that caveat in because this is ZoS afterall; there's no telling how accurate the tool tip for Shadow Barrier really is.

    All the nb's claiming that cloak is the only thing their class has, and that without it they are worthless... I don't know what exactly to say right now (almost 3am after a long day so should be asleep not writing) but the class has so much going for it that if a nb says they are squishy or need to be able to always evade their enemies I would want to point out all of their options. But then they would cloak away before I finished listing them all.

    All the other class that claiming cloak is impossible to counter and without detect pot Nb are impossible to kill,pick a counter slot it in your bar and GG you can now finally counter cloak!since youre a sorc daedric curse/bolt escape work well against Cloak.

    And yes NB are squishi.

    The class runs as you build them. If you put all your eggs in one basket with cloak of course you'll see your class as easy to kill when countered. Also I have to say, if you are invisible, moving at or above sprint speed, not even including fear or teleporting, that telling people to "just spam aoe's" is a funny idea. But yes, nb is easy to counter and stop, when I play mine I only rarely die.

    My nb is not moving faster than some one who sprint,and i can only cloak 3 time in a row(if i need fear for example well only 2 cloak) so not so much i can't evade people forever i need to rotate dodge roll/block/cloak im not just pressing cloak,slow +aoe will spot a nb easily,sometime you get away other you die,cloak have alredy many counter in game detect pot are not the only one,if you have a problem with magika NB stacking speed is another thing cloak alone is fine and can be countred by many things.
  • xXNesTXx
    xXNesTXx
    ✭✭✭
    April fools already happened...

    This thread can't be serious....
    Edited by xXNesTXx on September 13, 2015 1:50AM
    EU PS4 Ebonheart Pact

    NB Stam VR16 Breton
    NB Stam VR16 Khajiit
    NB Mag VR16 Breton
    Templar Mag VR16 Nord
    Sorc Mag VR8 High Elf
    DK Stam VR10 Red Guard
  • iTzStevey
    iTzStevey
    ✭✭✭
    I think it should be the the same as streak,its an escape ability and all escape abilities should be treated the same. You can pretty much perma cloak from lvl 10,all you need is regen drinks.
  • BalticBlues
    BalticBlues
    ✭✭✭✭✭
    ✭✭✭
    If the Shield Breaker set really was necessary to weaken shield users,
    we now also could use a Cloak Breaker set to weaken cloak users.

    I am tired of having to sacrifice time for collecting herbs to detect NBs,
    I also do not like having to sacrifice TWO slots for radiant magelight to detect NBs,

    With the Shield Breaker set, NBs have to sacrifice nothing to wreck shields.
    With a Cloak Breaker set, other classes then also would have to sacrifice nothing to wreck cloaks.

    Fair treatment to all classes, please. :p

    EDIT: To make myself clear, the Shield Breaker set IMHO is the worst thing that did happen to the game lately, and a Cloak Breaker set would be equally damaging to the game.This post was do demonstrate to NBs the consequences about what happens if a positive skill (shield, cloak) is inverted into a negative outcome by a simple destruction set: it invalidates the skill...
    Edited by BalticBlues on September 13, 2015 8:20AM
  • JDar
    JDar
    ✭✭✭✭✭
    rb2001 wrote: »
    I feel like cloak is the few things NBs even have that's competitive anymore. Just a feeling.

    People seem to have forgotten about Mass Hysteria -- or maybe people finally did L2P.

    Most of my excapes come about after successfully using Mass Hysteria, but nobody complains about that any more, and it never got nerfed.

    But yes, other than that, what is there? Strife can be reflected and absorbed, Sap Essence is not feared by people, Veiled Strike is just average with the 50% damage buff.

    The things making nightblades so powerful has more to do with weapon skills and medium armor abilities than the actual class itself, which is something Wrobel needs to think about before nerfing cloak can ever be put on the table.

    I don't think it's fair that nightblades can use powerful weapon abilities that have fewer counters than magic damage while STILL being able to cast two of the most powerful spells in the game easily.
    Edited by JDar on September 13, 2015 10:32AM
  • JDar
    JDar
    ✭✭✭✭✭
    Cathexis wrote: »
    dsalter wrote: »
    they just need alittle less speed, seeing a guy run off faster than any projectile is an issue of balance in itself. many times have they fail ganked me, i start winning the fight, then they try the whole cloak spam, i detect potion but oh no! little miss speed cloaker is running off so fast i cant even attempt to keep up. gj taking away night silences speed boost stacking with night stalker when it's NB's built in speed thats unbalanced.

    I don't honk cloak would work very well without run speed.

    But it should get the same treatment as every other auto escape skill has; compounding casting costs.

    Another problem is that Cloak has other uses, like increasing spell/weapon damage and providing an armor bonus (Shadow Barrier passive), so if you nerf Cloak, you're nerfing overall DPS and survivability as well. So yes nerfing Cloak will ruin the class.
  • killingspreeb16_ESO
    killingspreeb16_ESO
    ✭✭✭✭
    If the Shield Breaker set really was necessary to weaken shield users,
    we now also could use a Cloak Breaker set to weaken cloak users.

    I am tired of having to sacrifice time for collecting herbs to detect NBs,
    I also do not like having to sacrifice TWO slots for radiant magelight to detect NBs,

    With the Shield Breaker set, NBs have to sacrifice nothing to wreck shields.
    With a Cloak Breaker set, other classes then also would have to sacrifice nothing to wreck cloaks.

    Fair treatment to all classes, please. :p

    EDIT: To make myself clear, the Shield Breaker set IMHO is the worst thing that did happen to the game lately, and a Cloak Breaker set would be equally damaging to the game.This post was do demonstrate to NBs the consequences about what happens if a positive skill (shield, cloak) is inverted into a negative outcome by a simple destruction set: it invalidates the skill...

    I want to know what cloak breaker set will do ,please don't say break cloak for every nightbalde in the area or something stupid like that

    Cloak have alredy counter in the game while shieldstacking no,this set combined with melee weapon only is alredy fine.

    Edited by killingspreeb16_ESO on September 13, 2015 1:16PM
  • blur
    blur
    ✭✭✭✭
    Isbilen wrote: »
    It is no secret to anyone who isn't a forum-Nightblade that Cloak in it's current state is just ridiculous. Area damage spells are supposed to work as a counter to Cloak, but even if you activate the longest range spell you have slotted as soon as you aee the Nightblade cloak, he can be in another IC district before the animation on your area spell has even begun playing. The solution to balancing Cloak is not buffing detection potions back to how they were, applying magicka penalties for consecutive use or halting recovery whilst Cloak is active. To balance Cloak, all that needs to be done is make sneak speed bonuses such as Dark Stalker only affect normal sneak and not the Nightblade Cloak ability.

    I am a Stamina Sorc.

    Nightblades are fine, Vamp is fine, Cloak is fine and not OP.

    All classes have the ability to slot radiant magelight or use potions.
    All classes have the option to slot a skill that provides major expedition (40% movement speed).

    I wanted to take your post seriously but then I read:
    even if you activate the longest range spell you have slotted as soon as you aee the Nightblade cloak, he can be in another IC district before the animation on your area spell has even begun playing
    This is an outright lie. Cloak lasts 2.9 seconds at Rank 4 with 2 points in the Dark Veil passive. Don't blame an ability for your poor decisions/playstyle.

    The truth of the matter is you would rather nerf this class ability so it doesn't work as intended. It's meant to be used as an escape mechanism. Does it work 100% of the time? No, it does not . Yet you would see it nerfed even more. Nerfing an ability for doing it's job is a stupid notion. Asking to nerf another class because you are being myopic or too lazy to slot counters is another foolish notion. Everything you have suggested is a bold nerf to the class, magicka-wise and Stamina. In fact Stamina nightblades would be wrecked by your proposal(s).

    Normally I am reticent to post in terrible like these, as I wish to not bump. Nonetheless I feel I must when I see players whining and lying about something in order to motivate ZOS to make a change predicated on said whining and lying. I find it strange that conniving threads like these still show up when DKs and Templars are currently dominating IC.
  • kadar
    kadar
    ✭✭✭✭✭
    This is another silly thread where people who play a certain class/way demand that the people who play the other class/way get a nerf. What probably happened was a NB or two got away from the OP in Cyrodiil. You can do something I can't? Hmm. Nerf it.

    The longer I peruse these forums the more I am convinced that unless you play as BOTH sides of the argument or at least TRY to be objective, your opinions are not only unhelpful, they are invalid.
  • BalticBlues
    BalticBlues
    ✭✭✭✭✭
    ✭✭✭
    I want to know what cloak breaker set will do,
    please don't say break cloak for every nightbalde in the area or something stupid like that

    This is easy.

    The Shield Breaker set punishes people for wearing a shield.
    The Cloak Breaker set punishes people for wearing a cloak.

    Shield Breaker set (as it is now):
    Attacks deal Unresistable Damage against enemies with a damage shield.
    (OP, because it inverts shields into damage, making them useless)

    Cloak Breaker set (as it is possible):
    Attacking enemies cannot use cloak for 15 seconds (after their last hit on the set wearer)
    (not OP, because cloaks are still valuable for attacking, but limited against cheap escapes) ;)

    If the terrible OP Shield Breaker set really has to stay in the game,
    here my suggestion for a better function, similar to the Cloak Breaker set:

    Shield Breaker set:
    Once you hit a certain shield, the shield wearer's skill to recast this shield type is disabled for 15 seconds (in other words: as long as you hit, this shield type cannot be recasted). This way, shields would still be valuable, but limited against endless recasting and cheap escapes.

    Edited by BalticBlues on September 13, 2015 7:24PM
  • killingspreeb16_ESO
    killingspreeb16_ESO
    ✭✭✭✭
    I want to know what cloak breaker set will do,
    please don't say break cloak for every nightbalde in the area or something stupid like that

    This is easy.

    The Shield Breaker set punishes people for wearing a shield.
    The Cloak Breaker set punishes people for wearing a cloak.

    Shield Breaker set (as it is now):
    Attacks deal Unresistable Damage against enemies with a damage shield.
    (OP, because it inverts shields into damage, making them useless)

    Cloak Breaker set (as it is possible):
    Attacking enemies cannot use cloak for 15 seconds (after their last hit on the set wearer)
    (not OP, because cloaks are still valuable for attacking, but limited against cheap escapes) ;)

    If the terrible OP Shield Breaker set really has to stay in the game,
    here my suggestion for a better function, similar to the Cloak Breaker set:

    Shield Breaker set:
    Once you hit a certain shield, the shield wearer's skill to recast this shield type is disabled for 15 seconds (in other words: as long as you hit, this shield type cannot be recasted). This way, shields would still be valuable, but limited against endless recasting and cheap escapes.

    except shieldbrekaer is not make you vulnerable to everyone so a bit different,while i think is bad design if ZoS don't change shieldstacking or make another counter i take what i get
  • Isbilen
    Isbilen
    ✭✭✭✭✭
    This is another silly thread where people who play a certain class/way demand that the people who play the other class/way get a nerf. What probably happened was a NB or two got away from the OP in Cyrodiil. You can do something I can't? Hmm. Nerf it.

    The longer I peruse these forums the more I am convinced that unless you play as BOTH sides of the argument or at least TRY to be objective, your opinions are not only unhelpful, they are invalid.

    Seriously, 100% invisibility with 100000% movement speed, complete immunity from any single-target skill, immunity to agroing NPCs in areas like the sewer, a stronger version of Purge, the ability to enter and leave combat at will, damage boosts, and so much more in a cheap spammable ability. Something nedds to be done about it, and I would prefer that it not be magicka penalties as they will punish stamina builds more.

    [Moderator Note: Edited per our rules on Rude and Insulting comments]
    Edited by ZOS_Alex on September 14, 2015 3:54PM
  • eNumbra
    eNumbra
    ✭✭✭✭✭
    Isbilen wrote: »
    with 100000% movement speed, .

    Damn, have I been using the wrong morph again?
  • Lava_Croft
    Lava_Croft
    ✭✭✭✭✭
    ✭✭✭✭
    Isbilen wrote: »
    This is another silly thread where people who play a certain class/way demand that the people who play the other class/way get a nerf. What probably happened was a NB or two got away from the OP in Cyrodiil. You can do something I can't? Hmm. Nerf it.

    The longer I peruse these forums the more I am convinced that unless you play as BOTH sides of the argument or at least TRY to be objective, your opinions are not only unhelpful, they are invalid.

    Seriously, 100% invisibility with 100000% movement speed, complete immunity from any single-target skill, immunity to agroing NPCs in areas like the sewer, a stronger version of Purge, the ability to enter and leave combat at will, damage boosts, and so much more in a cheap spammable ability. Something nedds to be done about it, and I would prefer that it not be magicka penalties as they will punish stamina builds more.
    I'm in need of that LOL button now.

    Also, what morph of Shadow Cloak gives a speed buff?

    [Moderator Note: Edited quote to match moderated version]
    Edited by ZOS_Alex on September 14, 2015 3:54PM
  • BrassRazoo
    BrassRazoo
    ✭✭✭✭✭
    When a Sorcerer says Shield Breaker is killing Sorcerers as they need shields to survive, the Nightblades laugh it up and say deal with it.
    The same Nightblades now say if you nerf cloak you will kill Nightblades, it's balanced, learn to counter, it's not fair!
    Total hypocrisy.
  • killingspreeb16_ESO
    killingspreeb16_ESO
    ✭✭✭✭
    BrassRazoo wrote: »
    When a Sorcerer says Shield Breaker is killing Sorcerers as they need shields to survive, the Nightblades laugh it up and say deal with it.
    The same Nightblades now say if you nerf cloak you will kill Nightblades, it's balanced, learn to counter, it's not fair!
    Total hypocrisy.

    Ye except for cloak there are counter,for Shields?no
  • eNumbra
    eNumbra
    ✭✭✭✭✭
    BrassRazoo wrote: »
    When a Sorcerer says Shield Breaker is killing Sorcerers as they need shields to survive, the Nightblades laugh it up and say deal with it.
    The same Nightblades now say if you nerf cloak you will kill Nightblades, it's balanced, learn to counter, it's not fair!
    Total hypocrisy.
    except that there's already a dozen or so counters for cloak.
  • Domander
    Domander
    ✭✭✭✭✭
    Xeven wrote: »
    Im already slotting stuff to counter all the things.

    2 slots and 10% magicka is a ridiculous suggestion. Thats right I get 7% with inner light. -3% with magelight. Do the math.

    Ignorance.....

    The - 5% from that ability is usable magicka, not total... so your math is complete trash.

    But it's not like you even need it to counter cloak. I do this with aoe and then use detect pots when out of aoe range.
Sign In or Register to comment.