I, like many, signed up for the console beta a long time ago when signups opened. As I didn't get an email this past weekend, I assume that I'm not lucky enough to get into the closed console beta. Normally, I wouldn't have a problem with it as it's the luck of the draw at the end of the day.
However, given that Zenimax/Bethesda were happy enough to take money well in advance from people who bought their recent console upgrade edition, I think they should give everyone who has done this access to the console beta also.
At the end of the day, the people who have pre-purchased the console version directly are clearly people who want the game on console a lot and therefore it makes perfect sense to give them beta access; it's obvious that they're going to play the heck out of the beta and give Zenimax/Bethesda the feedback that they need from running the beta in the first place, compared to someone who got a key but might not even bother downloading it.
I'm assuming of course that this is a proper beta for actual feedback purposes, and not just a marketing tool to entice new platers who haven't already pre-purchased...