[BUG] 1.6.1 Blue VR5 recipe better than Purple VR10 recipe!

kkampaseb17_ESO · February 2015

Grandmam's Roast Rabbit - +3432 Health and Stamina and additional +3120 Stamina.

If this recipe works as advertised it provides far more benefit than a purple VR10. Unfortunately, I cannot test it since I don't have the materials for it.

I am inclined to believe this is a bug since Health and Stamina have the same value in the first part of the recipe while all the other recipes are scaled properly between Health and Stamina/Magicka by 1.1x.

Robbmrp · February 2015

kkampaseb17_ESO wrote: »

Grandmam's Roast Rabbit - +3432 Health and Stamina and additional +3120 Stamina.

If this recipe works as advertised it provides far more benefit than a purple VR10. Unfortunately, I cannot test it since I don't have the materials for it.

I am inclined to believe this is a bug since Health and Stamina have the same value in the first part of the recipe while all the other recipes are scaled properly between Health and Stamina/Magicka by 1.1x.

I believe this is correct. Since your adding a 3rd buff with the Purple V10 recipe it is a lower buff than for 2 stats. You must take the lower buff for all 3 stats. I believe that the 2 stat recipes on the live server give a higher buff for it's 2 stats than purple 3 stat ones.

Terminus · February 2015

Robbmrp wrote: »

I believe this is correct. Since your adding a 3rd buff with the Purple V10 recipe it is a lower buff than for 2 stats. You must take the lower buff for all 3 stats. I believe that the 2 stat recipes on the live server give a higher buff for it's 2 stats than purple 3 stat ones.

Ay, here is a picture confirming how the system is supposed to work (I don't know what level these provisioning recipes are, but was assuming they are all VR10)

kkampaseb17_ESO · February 2015

What you show is correct. However, the specific blue recipe I mentioned gives 3 stat. 2 times Stamina and one time Health.

Tarukmockto · February 2015

@kkampaseb17_ESO: Any chance you could post a screenshot of the recipe in question?

kkampaseb17_ESO · February 2015

Yes will try to do this at some point today

Nybling · February 2015

there is no VR10 food. It's the VR5 purple food with a new level slapped on so they can say OH LOOK GUYS, WE ADDED VR10 FOOD.

This is not a bug, it's completely intentional.

Rosveen · February 2015

Maybe it's a tooltip bug.

kkampaseb17_ESO · February 2015

Nybling wrote: »

there is no VR10 food. It's the VR5 purple food with a new level slapped on so they can say OH LOOK GUYS, WE ADDED VR10 FOOD.

This is not a bug, it's completely intentional.

I think you didn't understand my post. You rather focused on the VR10 of the purple recipe.

The blue recipe says" GRANDMAM'S ROAST RABBIT - RANK 5 - Increase Max Health and Stamina by 3432 and Max Stamina by 3120 for 1 hour.

There are 2 Stamina increases.

Rosveen wrote: »

Maybe it's a tooltip bug.

It could be. I don't have the mats to craft it and check.

ThePonzzz · February 2015

It only increases health 3432 and stamina by 3120. It doesn't say health and stamina, AND stamina. At least not a few days ago.

kkampaseb17_ESO · February 2015

I checked when I posted the stats (6 February) and it said exactly what I typed. I will check again tomorrow and see if there is any change.

ThePonzzz · February 2015

Definitely sounds like a tooltip bug with 1.6.1.