Hist bark all the way.
Song of lamae doesn't even proc unless you fall below 30% health, at which point you're probably already having a pretty bad day.
I know this is an old thread, but just wanted to add that I have had some success with 5x Hist Bark, 4x Night Mother's gaze.
The Hist bark gives the tankiness and dodge ability ( which i really like ), and the Night Mother's Gaze improves your crit chance. Its a pretty deadly combo, depending how you stack it with your other stuff.
AS good as Histbark is, I am also going to put a vote in for Whitestrake's Retribution. On my Nightblade Tank, it's great. I already regenerate stamina fast enough that a block isn't going to drain me, but since my class has no shields, having a shield pop whenever I get into some trouble really helps me out.
Also, if you're looking for a site with all of the set boni, I use this site:
For a Tank, I would go Whitestrakes Retribution 5 piece and Allesia's Bulwark or Hist Bark for the rest.
What I do to pick a set is strip my character of all equipment, and look at the base stats. Then build up what I feel I am lacking in with the crafted sets and Jewelery.
Don't forget the effects Jewelery can have on your character. Have rings and necklace that give Health Regen, then you can skip that crafted set that has that bonus in favor of another one that gives you something you need.
Edited by Nestor on September 22, 2014 2:18PM
Enjoy the game, life is what you really want to be worried about.
PakKat "Everything was going well, until I died"
Gary Gravestink "I am glad you died, I needed the help"