Can we please get SOME consistency on endeavors creature types?

MreeBiPolar

Seriously. Today's endeavor reads, "Kill 10 Insects or Arachnids". The pop-up explainer reads, "Kill hoarvors, kwama, and other monstrous insects and spiders blah blah blah."

... So what do we have.

Crabs. Nope. Ok, the task does say "insects or arachnids", which is roughly equivalent to "murines and cetaceans" if mapped onto mammals, not arthropods, but, ooook, crustaceans are not mentioned...
Dreughs. Nope. Not sure whether they are "monstrous insects" or "monstrous crustaceans" (or something else, after all, they were more like squids than arthropods in Daggerfall)...
Wasps. Nope. ... Ok. Now that is da***.
Fetcherfly hive. Check. DA*** when compared to wasps.

Now, it gets funnier.

Shroom Beetle. Check. Ok.
Giant scorpion. Check. Ok.
Scorpion 1-hit passive mob. Nope. D*A*****???

Necrotech_Master

as far as im aware the 1hp critters dont count for any endeavors except generic "kill X enemies with class abilities" or "...weapon abilities"

i do agree though that some of the mob categories dont always appear accurate, i just go for one of the ones specifically mentioned in the endeavor help text since those are generally guaranteed to work lol

like barbaric enemies mentions like lamia, but it doesnt work for actual human barbarian enemies

virtus753

They are usually keyed to the types of mobs you have to kill for the character achievements under Nature Slayer and other things for Monster Hunter.

It is not consistent with the real world, because they sometimes change words to suit their own desires (e.g. “humanoid”), but it is generally consistent with the game categories there.

ZOS_Exile

Just wanted to let everyone know that we have moved this thread to a more appropriate section.

spartaxoxo

A really wild one is Kwama don't count as chitinous creatures. LOL

luen79rwb17_ESO

All these silly endeavors should be unified as "Kill X monsters ..." What a pain when it's one of those weird ones and have to deal with half server running around all desperate for a tag

Arafyn

ash hoppers work, in the deadlands

Necrotech_Master

luen79rwb17_ESO wrote: »

All these silly endeavors should be unified as "Kill X monsters ..." What a pain when it's one of those weird ones and have to deal with half server running around all desperate for a tag

yeah like iron or stone atros (especially stone atros since there arent any overland stone atros)

jaws343

MreeBiPolar wrote: »

Seriously. Today's endeavor reads, "Kill 10 Insects or Arachnids". The pop-up explainer reads, "Kill hoarvors, kwama, and other monstrous insects and spiders blah blah blah."

... So what do we have.

Crabs. Nope. Ok, the task does say "insects or arachnids", which is roughly equivalent to "murines and cetaceans" if mapped onto mammals, not arthropods, but, ooook, crustaceans are not mentioned...
Dreughs. Nope. Not sure whether they are "monstrous insects" or "monstrous crustaceans" (or something else, after all, they were more like squids than arthropods in Daggerfall)...
Wasps. Nope. ... Ok. Now that is da***.
Fetcherfly hive. Check. DA*** when compared to wasps.

Now, it gets funnier.

Shroom Beetle. Check. Ok.
Giant scorpion. Check. Ok.
Scorpion 1-hit passive mob. Nope. D*A*****???

Wasps don't work?? I literally did this endeavor only killing wasps in Deshaan. It was the first and only thing I killed in game this morning until the endeavor was complete.

Crabs are not insects... There is no rough equivalence, a crab is not an insect. I believe Dreughs are crustacean esque in ES. Crustaceans are not insects.

whitecrow

I don't know anyone who would think of crabs as arachnids.

Dreugh provide fish so apparently they are crustaceans.

I agree that wasps and fetcherfly swarms should count.

There is an endeavor for non-hostile critters but I forget how it is worded. I wouldn't expect them to count for this, especially since it says "monstrous."

I completed this endeavor by killing the giant frostbite spider and her minions near the beginning of Labyrinthian, twice (doing the group even for the weekly in between.)

MJ202

Regarding consistency...

Nix Hounds - Yes

Nix Ox - No

Necrotech_Master

whitecrow wrote: »

I don't know anyone who would think of crabs as arachnids.

Dreugh provide fish so apparently they are crustaceans.

I agree that wasps and fetcherfly swarms should count.

There is an endeavor for non-hostile critters but I forget how it is worded. I wouldn't expect them to count for this, especially since it says "monstrous."

I completed this endeavor by killing the giant frostbite spider and her minions near the beginning of Labyrinthian, twice (doing the group even for the weekly in between.)

i think there is a "kill farm animals" one which might be what your thinking of

Elvenheart

I killed enough spiders with a class ability at the Nilala ruins in Bangkori to do both endeavors very quickly.

Dithieon

I killed wasps in Reaper's March with class abilities,counted towards 2 endeavors.

zaria

Wasps is insects, killed an bunch of them while harvesting.
Critters are the 1 HP stuff like squires, deer, monkeys and small spiders.

Ashryn

Wasps worked for me!
Crabs are not Arachnids!

BahometZ

I think we can afford to give the devs a break regarding the taxonomy of creatures in a fantasy setting.

zaria

Ashryn wrote: »

Wasps worked for me!
Crabs are not Arachnids!

Stuff can only be one thing as this one understand.
So killing Argonains in PvP does not for count killing lizards.

Dalsinthus

jaws343 wrote: »

MreeBiPolar wrote: »

Seriously. Today's endeavor reads, "Kill 10 Insects or Arachnids". The pop-up explainer reads, "Kill hoarvors, kwama, and other monstrous insects and spiders blah blah blah."

... So what do we have.

Crabs. Nope. Ok, the task does say "insects or arachnids", which is roughly equivalent to "murines and cetaceans" if mapped onto mammals, not arthropods, but, ooook, crustaceans are not mentioned...
Dreughs. Nope. Not sure whether they are "monstrous insects" or "monstrous crustaceans" (or something else, after all, they were more like squids than arthropods in Daggerfall)...
Wasps. Nope. ... Ok. Now that is da***.
Fetcherfly hive. Check. DA*** when compared to wasps.

Now, it gets funnier.

Shroom Beetle. Check. Ok.
Giant scorpion. Check. Ok.
Scorpion 1-hit passive mob. Nope. D*A*****???

Wasps don't work?? I literally did this endeavor only killing wasps in Deshaan. It was the first and only thing I killed in game this morning until the endeavor was complete.

Crabs are not insects... There is no rough equivalence, a crab is not an insect. I believe Dreughs are crustacean esque in ES. Crustaceans are not insects.

Yes and no. On Earth insects are in fact a subgroup of crustaceans.

https://decapoda.nhm.org/outreach/InsectCrustaceaNHM.pdf

jaws343

Dalsinthus wrote: »

jaws343 wrote: »

MreeBiPolar wrote: »

Seriously. Today's endeavor reads, "Kill 10 Insects or Arachnids". The pop-up explainer reads, "Kill hoarvors, kwama, and other monstrous insects and spiders blah blah blah."

... So what do we have.

Crabs. Nope. Ok, the task does say "insects or arachnids", which is roughly equivalent to "murines and cetaceans" if mapped onto mammals, not arthropods, but, ooook, crustaceans are not mentioned...
Dreughs. Nope. Not sure whether they are "monstrous insects" or "monstrous crustaceans" (or something else, after all, they were more like squids than arthropods in Daggerfall)...
Wasps. Nope. ... Ok. Now that is da***.
Fetcherfly hive. Check. DA*** when compared to wasps.

Now, it gets funnier.

Shroom Beetle. Check. Ok.
Giant scorpion. Check. Ok.
Scorpion 1-hit passive mob. Nope. D*A*****???

Wasps don't work?? I literally did this endeavor only killing wasps in Deshaan. It was the first and only thing I killed in game this morning until the endeavor was complete.

Crabs are not insects... There is no rough equivalence, a crab is not an insect. I believe Dreughs are crustacean esque in ES. Crustaceans are not insects.

Yes and no. On Earth insects are in fact a subgroup of crustaceans.

https://decapoda.nhm.org/outreach/InsectCrustaceaNHM.pdf

Crustaceans and insects are both a type of arthropod but crustaceans are not insects.

Mik195

Fletcherfly nests and Golems count.

Zephiran23

Various forms of spider daedra don't count either. Checked after fighting my way through to motif boss, there aren't that many, but my count was 0. Not sure if Mephala wold be happy or not.

Dalsinthus

jaws343 wrote: »

Dalsinthus wrote: »

jaws343 wrote: »

MreeBiPolar wrote: »

Seriously. Today's endeavor reads, "Kill 10 Insects or Arachnids". The pop-up explainer reads, "Kill hoarvors, kwama, and other monstrous insects and spiders blah blah blah."

... So what do we have.

Crabs. Nope. Ok, the task does say "insects or arachnids", which is roughly equivalent to "murines and cetaceans" if mapped onto mammals, not arthropods, but, ooook, crustaceans are not mentioned...
Dreughs. Nope. Not sure whether they are "monstrous insects" or "monstrous crustaceans" (or something else, after all, they were more like squids than arthropods in Daggerfall)...
Wasps. Nope. ... Ok. Now that is da***.
Fetcherfly hive. Check. DA*** when compared to wasps.

Now, it gets funnier.

Shroom Beetle. Check. Ok.
Giant scorpion. Check. Ok.
Scorpion 1-hit passive mob. Nope. D*A*****???

Wasps don't work?? I literally did this endeavor only killing wasps in Deshaan. It was the first and only thing I killed in game this morning until the endeavor was complete.

Crabs are not insects... There is no rough equivalence, a crab is not an insect. I believe Dreughs are crustacean esque in ES. Crustaceans are not insects.

Yes and no. On Earth insects are in fact a subgroup of crustaceans.

https://decapoda.nhm.org/outreach/InsectCrustaceaNHM.pdf

Crustaceans and insects are both a type of arthropod but crustaceans are not insects.

Both are arthropods, yes. Some crustaceans like crabs are not insects, yes. But all insects are a subgroup of crustaceans. So some crustaceans are also insects. This is a relatively new discovery and is not how many of us learned about arthropod taxonomy going through school.

perfiction

Also Argonians not counting towards reptile monsters endeavors.

jaws343

Dalsinthus wrote: »

jaws343 wrote: »

Dalsinthus wrote: »

jaws343 wrote: »

MreeBiPolar wrote: »

Seriously. Today's endeavor reads, "Kill 10 Insects or Arachnids". The pop-up explainer reads, "Kill hoarvors, kwama, and other monstrous insects and spiders blah blah blah."

... So what do we have.

Crabs. Nope. Ok, the task does say "insects or arachnids", which is roughly equivalent to "murines and cetaceans" if mapped onto mammals, not arthropods, but, ooook, crustaceans are not mentioned...
Dreughs. Nope. Not sure whether they are "monstrous insects" or "monstrous crustaceans" (or something else, after all, they were more like squids than arthropods in Daggerfall)...
Wasps. Nope. ... Ok. Now that is da***.
Fetcherfly hive. Check. DA*** when compared to wasps.

Now, it gets funnier.

Shroom Beetle. Check. Ok.
Giant scorpion. Check. Ok.
Scorpion 1-hit passive mob. Nope. D*A*****???

Wasps don't work?? I literally did this endeavor only killing wasps in Deshaan. It was the first and only thing I killed in game this morning until the endeavor was complete.

Crabs are not insects... There is no rough equivalence, a crab is not an insect. I believe Dreughs are crustacean esque in ES. Crustaceans are not insects.

Yes and no. On Earth insects are in fact a subgroup of crustaceans.

https://decapoda.nhm.org/outreach/InsectCrustaceaNHM.pdf

Crustaceans and insects are both a type of arthropod but crustaceans are not insects.

Both are arthropods, yes. Some crustaceans like crabs are not insects, yes. But all insects are a subgroup of crustaceans. So some crustaceans are also insects. This is a relatively new discovery and is not how many of us learned about arthropod taxonomy going through school.

Crustaceans are distinctly different from Hexapods, which are what insects are classified as.

MreeBiPolar

jaws343 wrote: »

Crustaceans are distinctly different from Hexapods, which are what insects are classified as.

Wrong. Just plain wrong. Insects also include a lot of non-hexapods. E.g., centipedes.

MreeBiPolar

Necrotech_Master wrote: »

as far as im aware the 1hp critters dont count for any endeavors except generic "kill X enemies with class abilities" or "...weapon abilities"

That's exactly why the shroom beetle surprised me

SydneyGrey

I got it by killing those giant beetles in Stros M'Kai.

FlopsyPrince

luen79rwb17_ESO wrote: »

All these silly endeavors should be unified as "Kill X monsters ..." What a pain when it's one of those weird ones and have to deal with half server running around all desperate for a tag

You mean one of the Atronarch ones where those are only in a very limited number of places?

FlopsyPrince

perfiction wrote: »

Also Argonians not counting towards reptile monsters endeavors.

But salamanders (amphibians, not reptiles) do!

MreeBiPolar

I think it's the one where it says you to hunt for stone atros in Craglorn, but if there are any there outside trials or quest areas, they are too well hidden. I recall I just went to Moongrave Fane for those.