CassandraGemini wrote: »
While I agree that the comment does come off as unnecessarily aggressive and could have been worded differently, the general point made is not wrong. It's exactly what I was thinking as well when I read the OP. Why would someone be so intent on using a particular name again, when they can't even remember that name? If I like a name so much that I want to reuse it, then I'd know what it was, wouldn't I? And if I can't even remember what I named my characters why would I want to reuse one of their names? Doesn't make a whole lot of sense to me either.
CassandraGemini wrote: »
While I agree that the comment does come off as unnecessarily aggressive and could have been worded differently, the general point made is not wrong. It's exactly what I was thinking as well when I read the OP. Why would someone be so intent on using a particular name again, when they can't even remember that name? If I like a name so much that I want to reuse it, then I'd know what it was, wouldn't I? And if I can't even remember what I named my characters why would I want to reuse one of their names? Doesn't make a whole lot of sense to me either.
CassandraGemini wrote: »
While I agree that the comment does come off as unnecessarily aggressive and could have been worded differently, the general point made is not wrong. It's exactly what I was thinking as well when I read the OP. Why would someone be so intent on using a particular name again, when they can't even remember that name? If I like a name so much that I want to reuse it, then I'd know what it was, wouldn't I? And if I can't even remember what I named my characters why would I want to reuse one of their names? Doesn't make a whole lot of sense to me either.
Memory problems? Tricky spelling? It's easier to pick one when you have whole list
before you? I don't think "why" matters or anyone's business, honestly.