I bet you’ve got inner light on your bar
It’s bugged and reduces your crit (this happened a couple of patches ago)
maddiniiLuna wrote: »Is the Staff part of a Set Piece? Which maybe gives Critical change like Mothers Sorrow staff?
ETA: OP, if you’re on PC/Mac, try testing on a dummy with Combat Metrics. If I remember right, the crit rate can be misreported even in the CMX stats, so you will have to count the number of crit hits and divide by the total number of hits to find your true crit rate. Let us know if that percentage is about what you expect (which means it’s just a UI error) or if it’s being accurately reported (in which case something more is going on).