This is an old debate now. And notice the no votes are split over two options, bit of a bias there.
With transmute getting the perfect setup is way easier.
However many people will agree with this one, not saying its right but it always was a popular request pre transmute.
What if you got to choose one gold weapon the first time you completed the “flawless conqueror” achievement. It would mean more skill based incentive for those who can’t seem to get their weapon of choice.