Should siege repair grant AP.

AJ_1988

Just looking for people's thoughts, should siege repairs give AP? Why/why not?

Personally I think they should, it might encourage people to repair unused forward camps so they arnt wasted. There have been plenty of times camps have been put down as a big Zerg approaches a keep but by the time it's placed under attack it's gone due to degrading, as far as I know repairing doesn't allow more people to spawn which is good but if the camp is gone before it can get used it's a waste. A limits would put on siege repair tho is you don't gain ap from your own siege as I could see that being exploited.

My personal opinions. What's yours?

Please no trolls. Keep it civil no answer is right or wrong.

Sandman929

AJ_1988 wrote: »

Just looking for people's thoughts, should siege repairs give AP? Why/why not?

Personally I think they should, it might encourage people to repair unused forward camps so they arnt wasted. There have been plenty of times camps have been put down as a big Zerg approaches a keep but by the time it's placed under attack it's gone due to degrading, as far as I know repairing doesn't allow more people to spawn which is good but if the camp is gone before it can get used it's a waste. A limits would put on siege repair tho is you don't gain ap from your own siege as I could see that being exploited.

My personal opinions. What's yours?

Please no trolls. Keep it civil no answer is right or wrong.

It wouldn't be hard to exploit heal a friends siege all day either.

Stovahkiin

Eh, like the post above said, I think quite a few people would exploit this a lot. Besides, the majority of people just buy new siege anyway, since the cost to repair a siege weapon all the way back up is pretty much the same as buying a new one.

Turelus

Sandman929 wrote: »

AJ_1988 wrote: »

Just looking for people's thoughts, should siege repairs give AP? Why/why not?

Personally I think they should, it might encourage people to repair unused forward camps so they arnt wasted. There have been plenty of times camps have been put down as a big Zerg approaches a keep but by the time it's placed under attack it's gone due to degrading, as far as I know repairing doesn't allow more people to spawn which is good but if the camp is gone before it can get used it's a waste. A limits would put on siege repair tho is you don't gain ap from your own siege as I could see that being exploited.

My personal opinions. What's yours?

Please no trolls. Keep it civil no answer is right or wrong.

It wouldn't be hard to exploit heal a friends siege all day either.

Spending AP to make less AP. The same as repairing walls etc. there is no benefit for this other than leaderboard boosting which there are faster ways to do (like actually doing PvP)

AJ_1988

That has already crossed my mind, but as said ^ would be like wall/door repairs. Maybe even have a limit on how much you can repair. It's just that I rarely see them used, I love them they are real handy when defending against rams as them you always have oils up.

I dunno I guess I'm just different lol.

Ackwalan

Turelus wrote: »

Sandman929 wrote: »

AJ_1988 wrote: »

Just looking for people's thoughts, should siege repairs give AP? Why/why not?

Personally I think they should, it might encourage people to repair unused forward camps so they arnt wasted. There have been plenty of times camps have been put down as a big Zerg approaches a keep but by the time it's placed under attack it's gone due to degrading, as far as I know repairing doesn't allow more people to spawn which is good but if the camp is gone before it can get used it's a waste. A limits would put on siege repair tho is you don't gain ap from your own siege as I could see that being exploited.

My personal opinions. What's yours?

Please no trolls. Keep it civil no answer is right or wrong.

It wouldn't be hard to exploit heal a friends siege all day either.

Spending AP to make less AP. The same as repairing walls etc. there is no benefit for this other than leaderboard boosting which there are faster ways to do (like actually doing PvP)

You can buy repair kits with gold.

Eirella

No

Turelus

Ackwalan wrote: »

Turelus wrote: »

Sandman929 wrote: »

AJ_1988 wrote: »

Just looking for people's thoughts, should siege repairs give AP? Why/why not?

Personally I think they should, it might encourage people to repair unused forward camps so they arnt wasted. There have been plenty of times camps have been put down as a big Zerg approaches a keep but by the time it's placed under attack it's gone due to degrading, as far as I know repairing doesn't allow more people to spawn which is good but if the camp is gone before it can get used it's a waste. A limits would put on siege repair tho is you don't gain ap from your own siege as I could see that being exploited.

My personal opinions. What's yours?

Please no trolls. Keep it civil no answer is right or wrong.

It wouldn't be hard to exploit heal a friends siege all day either.

Spending AP to make less AP. The same as repairing walls etc. there is no benefit for this other than leaderboard boosting which there are faster ways to do (like actually doing PvP)

You can buy repair kits with gold.

So you're converting gold to AP, for what purpose?

If you want something from the AP store then you'd do better buying it from a player or just going out and capturing some locations on a PUG.

I don't think someone can abuse AP gained from siege repair any more than they can abuse the current repair kits.