Would you like a Guild Hall added (not quite a house tho)

MEBengalsFan2001

NewBlacksmurf wrote: »

@MEBengalsFan2001
Thanks for the comments....thats a lot to add in considering housing.

Not that its a bad thing but I'm not seeing any desires expressed in the threads for this level of detail
Its seems...and I could be flat out off base...but it seems that people like housing as is (other than storage and player caps) so what the comments I've read identify is that people expected housing to include guild halls and they don't


To me, the guild hall shouldn't be something that detracts from personal housing because that system and the grinding is extremely intense. I can't argue that people should spend more time in another environment to establish a guild hall which technically is nothing more than a phased premade city

Ppl use areas now so do you think many would be open to questing and grinding a guild hall?
asking you and anyone else

I play NW and run a very small guild. It takes a lot of grinding to get any of the items needed to level up the guild. I'm talking 6+ hours with a group of 6+ players for about 25% of one structure if you are lucky with the drops from the adds.

In NW though the Guild Hall can double some of your stats, which is a big increase to damage, health, critical damage and critical chance; those stat boost really show up when you run content. In 2016 NW added a feature where bigger guilds could recruit smaller guilds. I not 100% sure how that works but it truly made many smaller guilds happy, I imagine they get the guild bonus from the bigger guild without losing their guild name. This should not be an issue in ESO as you can have up to 5 guilds.

For ESO housing as being designed is fine for individuals. I want to see a full fledge guild hall area where guilds can work together to build a guild.

Even in DCUO you have to play content to get items to improve league halls and I ran a very successful league in DCUO for almost 3 years.

NewBlacksmurf

OMG yes!

MEBengalsFan2001 wrote: »

NewBlacksmurf wrote: »

@MEBengalsFan2001
Thanks for the comments....thats a lot to add in considering housing.

Not that its a bad thing but I'm not seeing any desires expressed in the threads for this level of detail
Its seems...and I could be flat out off base...but it seems that people like housing as is (other than storage and player caps) so what the comments I've read identify is that people expected housing to include guild halls and they don't


To me, the guild hall shouldn't be something that detracts from personal housing because that system and the grinding is extremely intense. I can't argue that people should spend more time in another environment to establish a guild hall which technically is nothing more than a phased premade city

Ppl use areas now so do you think many would be open to questing and grinding a guild hall?
asking you and anyone else

I play NW and run a very small guild. It takes a lot of grinding to get any of the items needed to level up the guild. I'm talking 6+ hours with a group of 6+ players for about 25% of one structure if you are lucky with the drops from the adds.

In NW though the Guild Hall can double some of your stats, which is a big increase to damage, health, critical damage and critical chance; those stat boost really show up when you run content. In 2016 NW added a feature where bigger guilds could recruit smaller guilds. I not 100% sure how that works but it truly made many smaller guilds happy, I imagine they get the guild bonus from the bigger guild without losing their guild name. This should not be an issue in ESO as you can have up to 5 guilds.

For ESO housing as being designed is fine for individuals. I want to see a full fledge guild hall area where guilds can work together to build a guild.

Even in DCUO you have to play content to get items to improve league halls and I ran a very successful league in DCUO for almost 3 years.

@MEBengalsFan2001

I've played NE and DCUO

I do like that stuff but it seems like the way developers of this game are steering is a different direction. Alsmost to the point where guild hopping is by design rather than being meaningful to stay put.

It's a matter of opinion tho.

So I'm not saying those things wouldn't be absolutely awesome. I'd actually love it but everything here is account bound so it makes having a guild hall like those games not work so well unless they change some things.


Heck maybe if initially (one player suggested this during closed beta)

If player guilds aligned with NPC guilds so as to have these huge faction NPC based alliances that grew and flourished. Add in your comments and man that would be so awesome.

CloneTrooper699

Naah, they need to fix housing

I think they should leave it as player housing but give the guild master the option to set another players home as the guild hall (with permission from that player of coarse), then when you go to social, guilds and select the guild there will be a new option on the UI "travel to Guild hall" which is the chosen players house. You could also have a stat saying how many players are currently at the guild hall.

As long as they continue to expand player housing, adding new features and new houses (Volenfell Housing) I'll be happy.

kevlarto_ESO

OMG yes!

Yes for the Guild Hall, but when it comes to guilds over all this game is very lame on any kind of guild perks or leveling of the guild not a lot of functionality like in other mmo's I am in huge guild think we at going for the island or the cavern and open up the visitors to all guild members, I know there is a limit as to how many people can be in the home at one time so it will never feel like a real guild hall, but a small work around is the best we can do.

NewBlacksmurf

OMG yes!

I wonder if housing will touch Morrowind

Rev Rielle

Other...

I like guild halls, but they can make games feel a little dead (mainly in cities).

MornaBaine

OMG yes!

NewBlacksmurf wrote: »

I wonder if housing will touch Morrowind

Yes, there will be houses available for purchase in Morrowind.

NewBlacksmurf

OMG yes!

MornaBaine wrote: »

NewBlacksmurf wrote: »

I wonder if housing will touch Morrowind

Yes, there will be houses available for purchase in Morrowind.

@MornaBaine

I'm pretty excited and also kinda excited when they announced more houses will be added to the game. I won't speculate too much but maybe....just maybe....guild....houses other than manors (not that I could afford one)

zaria

kwisatz wrote: »

So, small and average guilds wouldn't have any chance to have a guild hall? Even if they can perfectly pay for it? Why?

It's easily understandable why they can't have a store, but even a 10 members guild should have the right to purchase a guild hall if they have the gold -or crowns- for it.

For those who played GW 1, take a look back at the Guild Halls we had:
- we had the ability to purchase an entire island choosing it from a very big panel of biomes and themes
- then we could purchase NPCs for our guild hall: banker, vendors, etc.
- and we had a big pvp zone where we could invite other guilds to fight in
- and others features...

But even a 3 guys guild could have its guild hall.

This, first would simply be to make the larger houses being owned by an guild not an player.
Security if player stop playing and permission rules based on guild status. So you need an rank to remove furniture, perhaps also to add.
Then add the guild hall, higher population cap but perhaps lower furniture count than the mansion.
This is expensive but nothing stop an 3 man guild to buy it, it would feel a bit stupid however.