Do you think ZOS should eliminate animation cancelling?

engramz

dday3six wrote: »

Why do people keep bringing up macros? It's not widely used because it cannot be adjusted to changing conditions. On top of that it's slower than a player actually inputing the actions manually believe it or not. Nearly all instances of players in PVP claiming that macros allowed a player to get off X skills/actions in 1s are misinterpreting the situation. All skills have a 0.9s global cool down that a user cannot bypas with marcos. What happens in these X skills in 1 sec scenarios is lag.

Are you sure about this? What do you make of this video?

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=byUrc7YfMDo

Zendran

No let it stay

engramz wrote: »

dday3six wrote: »

Why do people keep bringing up macros? It's not widely used because it cannot be adjusted to changing conditions. On top of that it's slower than a player actually inputing the actions manually believe it or not. Nearly all instances of players in PVP claiming that macros allowed a player to get off X skills/actions in 1s are misinterpreting the situation. All skills have a 0.9s global cool down that a user cannot bypas with marcos. What happens in these X skills in 1 sec scenarios is lag.

Are you sure about this? What do you make of this video?

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=byUrc7YfMDo

That's a bug from a PTS a while ago, so not sure what you're trying to say with this video.

Also, none of those hits even appear to be doing damage.

engramz

^ Oh ok I didn't know (it was a genuine question).

Zendran

No let it stay

engramz wrote: »

^ Oh ok I didn't know (it was a genuine question).

Oh, alright then. No harm done.

JinMori

No let it stay

raidentenshu_ESO wrote: »

Liofa wrote: »

In case no one posted this .

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ThZtwhYkKSs

Stop trying to kill the game and finding excuses for your low DPS . Thank you .

The game is already been murdered thanks to the developers like Eric Wrobel and their way of thinking. Animations are INCLUDEDinto the game mechanics. Why do you need to cancel it? Why have combat animations at all if animation canceling is encouraged?

Because it's better to have a System that is fun and lead good results when done properly then nothing. Eso combat would be boring without animation cancelling, just imagine how long it would take to re apply buffs and dots, you wouldn't even have the chance to use your spammable ability if there wasn't animation cancelling.
So it boils down to:
it's fun, it make the rotation smooth, it distinguishes eso combat from any other mmo, it leads to great results and satisfaction when you use it properly, it's a system where you can always improve, everyone can use it, and it's impossible to remove it without rewriting all the game vs My feelings are hurt because someone in pvp killed me with animation cancelling or that guy is doing more dps than me( and that triggers me), or i won't use it because i feel like it's an exploit (and i'm such a righteous guy for not using it).

MaxwellC

No let it stay

@RAGUNAnoOne
Nope I need it as a stam dk that doesn't follow the meta of heavy armor and proc sets. I can only heavy attack animation cancel for my kills so please no.

Kalante

No let it stay

Doing so will literally nuke this game's population including the small amount of competitive trial guilds there are left. I got another great idea! How about we also raise the gear to 180cp since yall are asking for the destruction of this game quiet figuratively with out realizing it. Just as raising the cp cap for gear is a sensitive topic... so is talking about animation cancelling. They are a MAJOR cornerstone of this game and they should not be messed with unless it is an improvement to the game.

The_Protagonist

Yes get rid of it

Hey if macros were feasible in the game then yes animation cancelling could have stayed, but since its against TOS, then there is no reason why it should exist.

modaretto

No let it stay

CuzImHarley wrote: »

In my opinion, it gives an unfair advantage, because not even one knows how to do, including me. It gives other a faster attack time than I can match

Well easiest solution for it would be to learn it. Alcast has a nice 101 guide on it. Should take around 5 minutes to watch and apply. If you can't do that why expect others not to use it just because some people can't put that little effort.

I'm a healer, animation cancelling is not about dps at all. It's about git gud at what you do in general. No excuses since it's not some taboo magic passed from generation to generation to the chosen few

Hammy01

Yes get rid of it

In my opinion those who defend AC do so because it is something that they have mastered and it gives them a huge leg up on the competition. Take away AC and more than a few players become average players over night.

I don't like AC because it feels dirty and it is not "even" for all classes... Meaning some players and classes can build around AC and become gods on the battlefield. The "feels dirty" part is because with AC you can make some skills become damn near invisible thus giving players no way to fight back.

But this is just my opinion and others may and will disagree!

Riejael

Anyone have parses of AC and non-AC compared?

The Uninvited

Other (Please explain)

My opinion is light/medium weaving is okay, but a skill still doing damage when cancelled through block/dodge/etcetera isn't.

But it's too late now, some parts of the game have been even balanced around it (vMoL or vMA for instance) to turn back.

So leave it be, or they would have to rework so much which could only result in more bugs/exploits/etcetera.

Dev

No let it stay

If you want to put out good dps, you need to learn how to fight, aka:

This is what a lot of the people who put out good dps have done:

1. If pc, get combat metrics. if console, good luck?
2. go to youtube: https://youtube.com/results?search_query=alcast+animation+cancelling
3. then search for your build type. Animation canceling works on all builds, but knowing which abilities to have would help.
   
   not saying you have to use cookie cutter builds, but make sure you know how your gear and abilities work. Wearing skoria and having no dots on any bar is not custom, its crap.
4. find high health mobs like mammoths, giants, or world bosses, and practice
5. practice some more, solo a normal dungeon or two just to really bake in the muscle memory and survivability.
6. if you want to go overboard: quiz your self on where your abilities are when you cant see them. what bar, slot and how to get to it, how to use it and memorize your passives so you can take advantage of them.
   
   sorc overload setups require the extra step of getting out of overload, (overload->bar swap->ult is trickier then it sounds as there is some funky timing).
7. be good

Most if not everyone who really 'cares' about their DPS has done some of the above. In the end it will boil down to your desire to research and practice.

Removing animation canceling does nothing but invalidate all the time and effort people put into the game to satisfy those who haven't.

Qbiken

No let it stay

There´s a big difference between macro and animation canceling.

Ch4mpTW

Yes get rid of it

Lol. This thread was resurrected I see. Hmm... I suppose the interesting posts shall resume.

GawdSB

Sure cause I don't have a clue as to how to do it.

Shad0wfire99

It should stay. However, it should work properly. Once they tried to "balance" ani cancelling, it's been really wonky ever since. I'd rather it stay, but if it becomes completely unreliable, then it should go.

kadar

No let it stay

Liofa wrote: »

In case no one posted this .

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ThZtwhYkKSs

Stop trying to kill the game and finding excuses for your low DPS . Thank you .

Thanks for digging up that video. There we have it. AC is neither an exploit, a bug, nor a cheat.

bulbousb16_ESO

Yes get rid of it

The more tools we take out of the hands of the cheaters, the better off the game will be.

Isellskooma

No let it stay

bulbousb16_ESO wrote: »

The more tools we take out of the hands of the cheaters, the better off the game will be.

Less skill in the game the quicker it dies.

Emmagoldman

Yes get rid of it

Get rid of it except for channeled abilities

Bandit1215

No let it stay

I don't think AC should go, because it is the only thing that is a measure able "skill factor". I do however think zos should have something in game to explain how to use it.

FLuFFyxMuFFiN

No let it stay

Can't beat em? Join em. L2AC. That's what I'm trying to do.

Sigtric

No let it stay

I can't believe this is still going on

srfrogg23

No let it stay

This is an action oriented game. It would really suck to get blasted to pieces by telegraphed attacks constantly because you're locked in an animation and can't roll away or block until the animation is over.

Either that or Zenimax would need to slow all the fights down to accommodate for the fact that their players are going to spend most of their time locked into their attack animations during fights.

Bramir

Yes get rid of it

Too dependent on ping. Get rid of it.

Nifty2g

No let it stay

Bramir wrote: »

Too dependent on ping. Get rid of it.

@Bramir That some kind of joke? I play with 300+ ping and have no issues with animation cancelling

As for this topic, I think they would lose so many players if they got rid of this dynamic playstyle

Sneaky-Snurr

Other (Please explain)

Bramir wrote: »

Too dependent on ping. Get rid of it.

^This. 'Nuff said.

Why aren't ZoS admitting that it's their design flaw and they are too incompetent to fix it since launch?

Before any butthurt players go on the offense to tell me off that I should practice AC, know that you're just wasting your breath (and typing energy!). I can safely say that I am very well-versed with how AC works and I am able to translate that into higher and consistent DPS on each and every one of my character.

Now for players residing in the States and the immediate neighbouring countries have little to no problem at all when executing AC but that is not the case for us players from the Oceanic region and the neighbouring regions that are far away from the States. Typical ping rate for Oceanic players, and I believe I speak for the most of us, is somewhere around 250-310ms on good days. To add, ZoS's servers aren't the most reliable when it comes to stable connections and that will effectively make it very difficult for us to AC.
In contrast, players from the States have a typical ping range between 20-90ms.
Let that sink in.

Nifty2g

No let it stay

Sneaky-Snurr wrote: »

Bramir wrote: »

Too dependent on ping. Get rid of it.

^This. 'Nuff said.

Why aren't ZoS admitting that it's their design flaw and they are too incompetent to fix it since launch?

Before any butthurt players go on the offense to tell me off that I should practice AC, then you're just wasting your breath (and typing energy!). I can safely say that I am very well-versed with how AC works and I am able to translate that into higher and consistent DPS on each and every one of my character.

Now for players residing in the States and the immediate neighbouring countries have little to no problem at all when executing AC but that is not the case for us players from the Oceanic region and the neighbouring regions that are far away from the States. Typical ping rate for Oceanic players, and I believe I speak for the most of us, is somewhere around 250-310ms on good days. To add, ZoS's servers aren't the most reliable when it comes to stable connections and that will effectively make it very difficult for us to AC.
In contrast, players from the States have a typical ping range between 20-90ms.
Let that sink in.

You don't speak for me, sounds like excuses

magnusthorek

Yes get rid of it

Bramir wrote: »

Too dependent on ping. Get rid of it.

That's the most crucial point. Those who master AC would probably not be able to do it as good as they currently do with higher latency.

But when it comes to require it (or the result of it) or rub it in other's faces, there they are ready to do so ¯\_(ツ)_/¯