The Betnikh decision - WARNING - SPOILERS!

Violynne

The ending of Carzog's Demise has me perplexed.

With my second character, I decided to give the treasure to the Covenant (since my first character got scolded by the ship's captain) and now I'm "paying for" this decision.

Question: just how much time could have passed between leaving this island and arriving in Glenumbra such that the device was used against the Orcs? I'm constantly getting berated for my decision and it seems completely out of place given I'm thinking the boat only sailed for a day or two, clearly not enough time for the orb to be used since it was on the boat.

Is there something I'm missing or is this the worst story outcome of the game?

Cadbury

This is the decision I wrestled with,too. Playing as an orc, I decided to destroy the relic because I certainly don't want the Redguard to use it against them once the Covenant falls through. It's bad enough that in the future Orsinium will get nuked over and over again. The way I see it, my decision may have saved them from extinction.

Regarding your question, I don't think it says they used the relic on the Seamount clan then. I do know that in the game Daggerfall, Betnikh goes back to its old name Betony, so I assume the Bretons took it back? (Haven't played Daggerfall myself so this is just speculation)

Violynne

Cadbury wrote: »

Regarding your question, I don't think it says they used the relic on the Seamount clan then.

But that's just it: they do!

I only found this out because I talked to Lumbra (sp) and the mage who I helped get as crew and both berated me for my decision in allowing the Covenant to use the relic!

This perplexed me because 1) they were also on the boat with me and 2) they act as if it happened a while ago despite mere hours of leaving the ship at Glenumbra.

Granted, the decision didn't affect the game in any way, but hearing this was rather shocking.

Cadbury

Oh wow XD

When I first started playing , I used up my limited deletes to try out the different classes. I've ran through DC starting islands four times; two keeping the relic, and the last two destroying it. I'm ashamed to admit it I must have missed where they used it on the seamount orcs. Son of a...

See, this is one of the problems I have with ESO ( well, and the latest ES games in general) is that the NPC's don't react to your race. It's amusing when guards say something like "Watch it, orc" but the fact they treat all of your characters mostly the same kinda dampens the immersion, ya know?

Enodoc

What did Lambur accuse you of? I don't recall any mention of it being used on the Seamount Orcs. Allowing the Covenant to use the relic doesn't mean that they have actually used it yet, it just means that there's the potential for them to use it in the future.

newtinmpls

Oh Daedra Bless it, anyone who thinks it wouldn't be used, and rather soon is quite naive.

Victus

I thought (could be wrong) that you could either destroy the relic or keep it for yourself. One of my characters I chose to not destroy it (he is a little power hungry) and got the usual split-crew reactions. I think the assumption is that it will be given to the DC to use, but hey, I don't recall giving me the option to hand it over

driosketch

Talk to the crew when you meet them in Wayrest. If I recall correctly, if you keep it they use it once on AD forces before it burns out. Destroy it, and the cabin girl's brothers do end up killed in the battle that happens.

Eiagra

What perplexes me is the idea that Captain Kaleen (the Redguard who voted to keep the relic) thought it would be a GOOD idea to turn it over to King Fahara'jad. Moderately late in the Covenant questlines, you end up in Alik'r Desert, where the native Redguards refuse to harm the zombies of their raised dead because it goes against their sacred dogma, and doing so results in one becoming banished and segregated from the rest of their society.

So, a giving the King of Redguards a relic that commands the spirits of the DEAD is a good idea... how?

I never made the decision to keep the relic (I play orcs exclusively), so I was unaware it burned out after being used once against Dominion forces. But regardless of that, I couldn't see any situation where King Farara'jad uses that relic and does not get his head handed to him by the religiously devout amongst his people -- which is to say probably most of them. The potential political ramifications would be shattering.

Even if King Fahara'jad chooses to entomb the relic in the Impervious Vault to keep it out of everyone's hands, the player learns later how much of a fantastic disaster THAT would be over the course of that region's questline.

All in all... Kaleen is freaking crackers, and there's no reason to keep the relic, in my assessment.

That said, I was a little annoyed at Kaleen and Nicolene's attitudes throughout the main questline -- I guess you get nagged at no matter which side you pick -- though at least they chill out a little towards the end.

This is all good, though. I like having a hard decision with no clean-and-clear solution and long-term story-based repercussions. MOAR!

carljokl

My Breton character banished the relic.
My Orc alt took it. (I was curious to see what would happen differently).
Clearly I am doing this wrong.

I was a bit taken back when I destroyed the relic that I seemed to get so chewed out for doing what seemed like the sensible thing. Then with an alt I see what happens if I do things the other way only to seem to get even more chewed out. Damned if I do and damned if I don't.

I actually stumbled across this when trying to figure out for curiosity's sake how Betnik ends up becoming Betony again. ESO establishes that the island used to be Betony and the Orismer conquered it from the Bretons. At some point the Bretons much conquer it back as it is Betony again by the time of the events of Elder Scrolls Daggerfall. It does seem a bit of a wierd place for the Orismer to take over. So close to Daggerfall, it would be thought easy for the Bretons to maintain not to mention being far separated from Orsinium and Wrothgar.

BrianDavion

ORSIMER didn't take it over, a clan of orcs did. the Orcs as a people aren't exactly united

ListerJMC

Recently someone asked me about what happens if you keep the relic since I kept it on one of my alts doing Cadwell's quests to test the outcome, so I took some screenshots of crew member conversations to show her. Every time you run into them in a city's port they may tell you something about what happened because of your decision.

This is how Neramo explains what happens (I wish I could have given it to him just saying - what could possibly go wrong? ). In short though the Covenant tinkers with it and use it to defend themselves against a Dominion attack, killing the Dominion forces but rendering the relic useless in the process. It is not used against the orcs.

Eiagra

I was wondering how the other line went. Gosh, he's not salty at all, is he? :P

Also, that was random seeing an old post brought up. I didn't even know I had this tracked until I saw notifications for it, lol.

dodgehopper_ESO

Eiagra wrote: »

What perplexes me is the idea that Captain Kaleen (the Redguard who voted to keep the relic) thought it would be a GOOD idea to turn it over to King Fahara'jad. Moderately late in the Covenant questlines, you end up in Alik'r Desert, where the native Redguards refuse to harm the zombies of their raised dead because it goes against their sacred dogma, and doing so results in one becoming banished and segregated from the rest of their society.

So, a giving the King of Redguards a relic that commands the spirits of the DEAD is a good idea... how?

I never made the decision to keep the relic (I play orcs exclusively), so I was unaware it burned out after being used once against Dominion forces. But regardless of that, I couldn't see any situation where King Farara'jad uses that relic and does not get his head handed to him by the religiously devout amongst his people -- which is to say probably most of them. The potential political ramifications would be shattering.

Even if King Fahara'jad chooses to entomb the relic in the Impervious Vault to keep it out of everyone's hands, the player learns later how much of a fantastic disaster THAT would be over the course of that region's questline.

All in all... Kaleen is freaking crackers, and there's no reason to keep the relic, in my assessment.

That said, I was a little annoyed at Kaleen and Nicolene's attitudes throughout the main questline -- I guess you get nagged at no matter which side you pick -- though at least they chill out a little towards the end.

This is all good, though. I like having a hard decision with no clean-and-clear solution and long-term story-based repercussions. MOAR!

@Eiagra I 100% agree. I just wish I could deal with Kaleen and Nicolene permanently. If this were a game like Morrowind or Oblivion, I'd surely push them off the cliff, defenestrate them, accidentally poison them with nightshade, or otherwise knock them into the well. These two NPC's deserve execution and are only going to mean harm to the covenant as well as everyone else on Nirn. They're toxic and need destroyd.

Also, I can't possibly find a good reason to use the relic. Think about it, no matter who or what your character is, this is a relic of Molag Bal, the guy who you just escaped from and have a vendetta against. Why help him?

ListerJMC

Eiagra wrote: »

I was wondering how the other line went. Gosh, he's not salty at all, is he? :P

Also, that was random seeing an old post brought up. I didn't even know I had this tracked until I saw notifications for it, lol.

Yeah he is soooo bitter and salty over not being able to study the relic! If you keep the relic he still complains it's such a shame he didn't get to study it. I really wanted to give it to him just for fun .

And wow I didn't even realise this thread was that old, I just saw it on "Recent Discussions"!

undefeatdgaul

gotta destroy that thing

WhiteCoatSyndrome

Concur that it should be destroyed. It's fueled by souls--Nicolene can gripe as much as she likes; I don't hear her offering her OWN soul to feed the thing.

It's bad that I remember her trying to guilt trip me about her brothers dying and still feel no sympathy for her.

WreckfulAbandon

WhiteCoatSyndrome wrote: »

Concur that it should be destroyed. It's fueled by souls--Nicolene can gripe as much as she likes; I don't hear her offering her OWN soul to feed the thing.

It's bad that I remember her trying to guilt trip me about her brothers dying and still feel no sympathy for her.

Nicolene is the worst NPC in the game

Ok, maybe the invincible guards are a little worse.

Curragraigue

Eiagra wrote: »

What perplexes me is the idea that Captain Kaleen (the Redguard who voted to keep the relic) thought it would be a GOOD idea to turn it over to King Fahara'jad. Moderately late in the Covenant questlines, you end up in Alik'r Desert, where the native Redguards refuse to harm the zombies of their raised dead because it goes against their sacred dogma, and doing so results in one becoming banished and segregated from the rest of their society.

So, a giving the King of Redguards a relic that commands the spirits of the DEAD is a good idea... how?

I never made the decision to keep the relic (I play orcs exclusively), so I was unaware it burned out after being used once against Dominion forces. But regardless of that, I couldn't see any situation where King Farara'jad uses that relic and does not get his head handed to him by the religiously devout amongst his people -- which is to say probably most of them. The potential political ramifications would be shattering.

Even if King Fahara'jad chooses to entomb the relic in the Impervious Vault to keep it out of everyone's hands, the player learns later how much of a fantastic disaster THAT would be over the course of that region's questline.

All in all... Kaleen is freaking crackers, and there's no reason to keep the relic, in my assessment.

That said, I was a little annoyed at Kaleen and Nicolene's attitudes throughout the main questline -- I guess you get nagged at no matter which side you pick -- though at least they chill out a little towards the end.

This is all good, though. I like having a hard decision with no clean-and-clear solution and long-term story-based repercussions. MOAR!

Honoured Dead are dead Redguards. The relic brings back dead Ayleids so shouldn't be a problem for them.

SilverAnna

I think it is funny, later you meet Captain Kaleen and Nicolene again. Kaleen has gotten herself into trouble and you have to save her, after she told you she never wants to see you again. Hehe. I loved it.