Here is a thought, after scouring through the forums and observing the state of the game specifically focusing on the most recent Campaign, I feel that as a community we should discuss some differences in perspective. And turn our eyes to the state of the game.
Upon my scouring, I stumbled upon an interesting notion that interested me in Particular: Population differences.
First off let me begin with this;
Facts: All 3 factions fought well.
Speaking specifically to the Famous Players/leaders (And yes, we must acknowledge each and everyone's own level of Re-known) Differences aside, we all fought well and struggled hard. Surely, on an individual level we can acknowledge this.
Whether we agree with it or not, AD gained the most points during the Campaign.
Speaking bluntly, I'm sure a lot of members of the opposing factions have several opinions that do carry a certain degree of truth as to why AD won.
I constantly see Ebonheart, mention population levels, Daggerfall, mentions the notion that AD guilds lag the server, and again with a degree of truth; both voice concern over the concept of PvDoor.
Now what is the Yellow Perspective? By no means do I speak for all Yellow Players, but I do consider myself one of the primary Leaders in regard to the Unaffiliated Yellow Masses (My pug groups pull members regularly from Top AD guilds even during Guild Hours, and I regularly hear someone in my group thank me for making their first time into PvP a fun adventure--- Atleast twice a week).
What's my Perspective you ask? Ignoring fickle and unsolvable things outside of the community's control; I feel that Yellow wins consistently solely off coordination. The reality of it is, I honestly don't believe that neither EP or DC as a faction works together individually, Better than AD.
And let me tell you why, I am sure if you are reading this you are aware about the FACT that EP had been in the lead the vast majority of this past campaign, and suddenly within the past 7 days, Yellow Caught their second wind, coincidentally during Oceanic hours. During those 7 days my personal Pug group #44 which has been absent for the majority of this campaign.
But during the past 7 days, AD has brought new life into a side of the AD community that has been nearly absent since the end of Wabbajack. That being mobilizing forces as a faction, not as individual guilds. Allow me to clarify, to my knowledge, there are only a handful of strong AD guilds, of those handful only a few of which are sufficient enough to consistently field regular groups. DiE fields a group daily, other them I am not aware of a unified AD guild that fields more than 20 members aside from the newly established Moonlight Guild, on a regular basis. Yet somehow AD remains on the fringes of being population locked for hours a day. What this means we have to acknowledge is, a vast majority of AD players, are not part of a pvp guild, many of them are mainly PVE players/traders. I will go on record and openly admit that AD pugs, are by far, the worst players in the game. Frankly it's more of a hindrance for us field so many inexperienced players. Let's not pretend that some of the Famous players constantly kill 8-15 players on average by them selves in an open zerg, simply becuz the deal enough AoE damage to keep Batswarm up.
But despite them being horrible, we as a faction constantly provide them with direction. Let's be frank majority of the time AD pug groups struggle to even take resources with 15man groups. However, it is undeniable that Group leadership is a strong point of AD, and has many times proved to be our saving grace. Clear example being that last two emp pushes by AD on the closing days, Blue was holding strong, until the leadership of multiple groups were tied in together.
I question, whether or not EP and DC are aware of the reality that almost every moment that an AD group is formed and active in Cyrodiil, they are talking to two or three other group leaders. And information, reports, and plans are being thrown around between 5-6 people, and roles are being assigned? The level of coordination that AD achieves despite them mainly being pug forces is nothing less than astonishing.
I once lead a group of 24 to take Drakelow, and when I arrived 2 other groups of 8 and 17 were waiting for my group to arrive, without my knowledge they moved to support me, to the point they waited for my group to begin the attack, and handed me complete control of their forces.
You can say AD won because of this and that, but I feel that as a community both other factions should strive to become the community that AD has created. And once they do, we can address on how to fix the state of the game as a whole, as a community. Once we get to that point, then I believe PvP will begin to meet the standards that we all have planned for it.
- Sincerely Lady Lightbright
- Dictated and Written under the Influence.