I would like to discuss a recent and definitive answer a question posed in the recent Variety pack #15:
Is it normal that a horse can continue to sprint even if it runs out of stamina? I think players don’t appreciate that trait, since it seems to do nothing. – Chris J.
Yes, horses can sprint indefinitely without consuming stamina. That said, stamina is still valuable for two other reasons: It protects you from being dismounted when attacked, and if you rapidly press the sprint key you will get big boosts of speed on your mount (but at a much higher stamina cost). Of note, only horse mounts have the endless sprint trait. Other upcoming mount types will have different special traits.
To this I say complete BS. When I personally run out of stamina I drop to a slow jog, why the HELL can a mount run endlessly? This is counter intuitive and utter nonsense. It should work the same way for both mount and horse.
Having the stamina bar be only for a bit of extra speed (which is also a pain to keep tapping) and getting knocked off is not NEARLY as valuable as speed and renders the stat nearly worthless.
To that I would say, give horses invested in stamina permanent armor, making it VERY difficult to unhorse a high stamina horse. Say every 4 pts invested will give you 1 permanent armor which will equal being able to shrug off 1 attack. That alone would make stamina investment (especially in PvP) worth investing in.
For visuals you would get full leather barding at 20 feeds and plate barding at 40 feeds (this would also give those aesthetic people another incentive)