WoW's PvP is <<<<<

I've allways disliked the concept of wow-style BGs. Some would say "well add a mini-Cyrodiil then" to which i'd answer that it won't make much of a difference since action is almost allways centered around 1-3 keeps regardless.

Its honestly not very hard to find action in Cyrodiil, only thing is that you can't actually "win". It's still very possible to just go out and have a couple of good fights though.

The changes to campaign numbers should solve this problem.

The issue isnt the map size, I can find a fight in a short period of time no problem. The issue is finding a campaign where fighting is going on. To many empty or dominated low pop campaigns, so you have to flip between them to find one that has fights.

OMG no! A small battle ground encourages Zerg mentality on the battlefield. That is the problem with GW2 right now! The battlefield is so small that it only takes 1-3 minutes to run across it, allowing smaller units little or no chance to take meaningful targets such as keeps and towers. If anything make it larger, not smaller.