Personally I believe underdog bonuses are needed in some situations, but at the same time can be very detrimental to small scale pvp. For instance, if your alliance is severely under populated, you will completely dominate in small scale pvp of lets say 4on4 or 10v10 or even more so in 2v2 and 1v1 skirmishes. Underdog bonuses, if not applied properly will ruin pvp for soloers and gank squads on the larger populated alliances.
Therefore I think underdog bonuses should apply in areas within cyrodiil, not just zone wide.
The implementation of this of course is a little tricky and you will always have some instances of overlap where it's not exactly fair, but it will be a lot better than zone wide bonuses in my opinion.
What does everyone else think?
Edited by Kiljaz on 31 May 2014 04:13
Underdog Bonuses and server count 19 votes
Underdog bonuses for entire zone
Locational underdog bonuses such as within 1000 meters of each keep.
2 votes
Underdog bonuses are a bad idea.
1 vote
No underdog bonuses and reduce server count down to 4 servers.