I would like achievement rarity to be added, as long as it is informational only.

Seeing that an achievement is rare can make it feel more meaningful, and it can give achievement hunters another reason to explore old content, attempt harder challenges, or finish obscure objectives. Steam, Xbox, PlayStation, and other platforms already show this kind of information, so it would not feel out of place in ESO.

That said, I would not want extra rewards tied to rarity. The value should be in the information and personal motivation, not in creating another FOMO or prestige grind. Just showing a percentage beside achievements would be enough.

Ideally it would include:

Global completion percentage.

A filter or sort option for rare achievements.

Separate handling for unobtainable/retired achievements so they do not distort the system.

No gameplay advantage or reward attached.

For players who do not care, nothing really changes. For players who like achievement hunting, it adds a small but meaningful layer of motivation.

Gabriel_H wrote: »

Highlighting a "rare" achievement, leads to them not being rare.

But still they exist, on Steam you can find them in any game. If some achievement is easy but rare, yes, it will become not rare pretty fast I suppose, but it is just a part or normalization, because ESO has no rarity system on PC rn, so some rare achievement can be dull and not interesting, so they are not completed because of this and not because they are hard.

I like hunting achievements because it's something I enjoy doing. I don't care how rare they are or what percentage of the playerbase has them. I'd much rather ZOS put the time into something else.

Saying it wouldn't affect anyone else is wrong. I predict that there would be endless discussions here about why a particular achievement is rare (especially if it's not a trifecta or something difficult), and potentially lead to all sorts of wrong conclusions about what's popular in the game and what isn't. We have enough of that here already!