Haven't been in IA since it opened as its an unrewarding and monotonous slog (credit to
@StarOfElyon). But jumped back in as I wanted to farm Pyrebrand for a DK build. Its
still a monotonous slog. Here are the top issues with IA, not involving a save point, as I see them. All of these are presuming a solo IA run where someone can at least get to the 3rd Arc:
The amount of Archival Fortunes you get is a joke.
On average, I was getting about 8K by getting up to the 3rd Arc, which took about 40 minutes with an Arcanist. Felt like I was melting things and it was still going slow. As I was there to farm fortunes to buy Pyrebrand gear, 8K equated to 4 pieces of gear. Not great, considering there are heavy, medium, and light versions of all pieces, plus weapons, plus jewelry. And they are random. Oh, but you can get curated pieces they say. Yeah. For 10K per box. So that's going to need a second run or getting through to Arc 4, which I will get to in a minute.
The amount of class gear drops you get is a bigger joke
One piece per Tho'at Replicanum. Woo hoo. Oh, and you can get one from a Marauder. If it shows up. And you beat it. So 3 weapons maximum for 40-ish minutes of work.
The side quests are dumb
The goat is just stupid. Funny, but stupid. The lights are okay, but you can't run, and you are on a time limit. Fun. The tome hunter is annoying, long, and comes with wonky controls. The fight against the woman is okay, but after beating her, the difficulty ramps up to the degree of not worth the effort for the reward. The page hunter is the easiest and really the only one worth the reward, which is insubstantial for all of them. At least they are all optional.
The RNG. Oh... the RNG
Basically, you want harder bosses early. But after several runs, it
feels like you will not get the harder bosses early on a regular basis. I've done about 20 runs in the last week. Got Shadowrend every single time as the first boss on the first stage of Arc 1. Hmm. Got Dranos Velador or Vila Theran as the first boss on the first stage of Arc 2 every time.
Hmmmmmmm. Other than that, it was a grab bag of bosses, sometimes good, sometimes really, really, bad. As in Rakkhat appearing as the first boss on the first stage of Arc 4. Nope. Or get your run derailed by Lady Belin in Arc 2. Yay.
I can live with the RNG of the bosses. Makes it one of the few interesting things in IA. Doesn't make up for Lightbringers showing up in trash fights, but I digress. But the RNG on the uncurated gear boxes you can buy is the real joke. Now, for context, I started with no Pyrebrand gear. In the first 20 boxes I got, 5 of them had a Resto staff. But that isn't the best part. I bought 4 boxes every time and opened them immediately. Every single time, 5 times in a row, one box had a resto staff. Come on. There are 36 total pieces. This isn't random. As for the other 3 boxes each time, those felt totally random and unpredictable.
Either way, spending 8K and playing the "wheel of gear" was better than 10K for one guaranteed piece. Got about 2/3 of the set for 160K in fortunes, so more than I would have got with curated boxes. Even though I continued to get Resto staves like they were going out of style.
Blocking? Bashing? LOL
Either the block bug is back as a whole, or there is a block bug in IA. Sometimes I watched as block dropped. Other times, I watched my Khajiit bash a target like it was a pinata, only to have no effect on the interrupt. Good times.
Up the amount of Archival Fortunes you get. Drop more class gear. There is no other point to do IA for those who aren't score-chasing.