I'd have to agree, would really like to see it. Joining a guild solely to play the broker mini-game just doesn't interest me in the slightest--it interests me even less than joining a guild solely to get access to their broker.

All I really want to do is be able to throw my stuff on there and sell it, while simultaneously being able to buy stuff without having to watch seven different loading screens to visit potential brokerages.

Realism certainly isn't an issue--the portal/transitus system is inherent to the game. The personal bank also doesn't take location into account in any way.

In other words, an auction house. Why should they do this, when they have stated they will NOT do this on a megaserver, and the polls on this site show it is FAR from a unanimous wish of the players to have such a thing? Why beat a dead horse? Why not lobby for something they have NOT stated will not be implemented, like a sales chat channel? Work WITHIN what they have stated to be their criteria, instead of whining with the same old tune.

seanolan wrote: »

In other words, an auction house. Why should they do this, when they have stated they will NOT do this on a megaserver, and the polls on this site show it is FAR from a unanimous wish of the players to have such a thing? Why beat a dead horse? Why not lobby for something they have NOT stated will not be implemented, like a sales chat channel? Work WITHIN what they have stated to be their criteria, instead of whining with the same old tune.

We should be able to make our own global channels anyway, I mean that is a pretty basic feature of many MMOs. Then we could make one for LFG, one for selling, etc.

I think it's a refreshing and realistic take on in-game economics. Sure it's not as convenient as the lazier games like WoW and Neverwinter with their "world-wide" auction houses.

But this game isn't those games. I, for one, am glad it's choosing to stand apart from those games in every way it can.

WoW made gamers spoiled and lazy. Prove me wrong.

Nestor wrote: »

wraithguknub18_ESO wrote: »

Every other MMO I have seen has a world wide broker, what is the issue with having one here?

Because every other MMO is parsed out across many servers, where in this game the mega server creates instances that we play in. How would the Auction House work across instances? How would the Auction House work if the entire game population or even faction population is accessing it at roughly the same time?

Those are the technical reasons. The other reasons are posted all over the boards, both for and and against a GAH.

The "technical reasons" are a strawman at best.

What if there was a thing in the game where people are constantly adding and subtracting things from anywhere in the world, with a large portion of the games population using it all at the same time? Oh, wait....that's called the bank. The only difference between the bank and an auction house, from a data perspective, is the fact that every person would be able to see the same one, rather than a different one, which would require some level of dynamic updatability.

I have no idea what instances have to do with accessing an Auction House. They'd do it the same way they do it everywhere, and the same way they access brokers now. They'd access the data base on demand.

The technical reasons are not substantial.

WraithAzraiel wrote: »

Anything that makes this game different from WoW is a good thing.

Let's look at the current differences, solely from the perspective of someone buying or selling(someone kicking in gold to "buy" a merchant stall is in a different meta, to a degree):

Each location has different goods.

"Shopping around" means traveling all over the world, which is nothing more than visiting waypoints and enduring load screens.

No bidding, items aren't actually auctions.

Players are excluded from using it to sell unless they join a guild that keeps one. Further, they must join a guild that keeps one in a proper location to sell the types of goods you want to sell. You join that guild for this purpose, not the purpose of socialization or general gameplay interests(other than selling things, obviously).

No textual search engine.

Things that are the same:

Items are in a database that players access.

"Price fixing" happens--if you deeply undercut someone you're more likely to find it on a competing broker for more money than you are to have sold it to a consumer.

Prices stagnate to a fairly specific number and stay at this price, barring any supply or demand change.

Locations tend to be at population hubs.


In my opinion, these differences don't make it better.

IMO I just think it would be better over all to have a system where everyone can buy and sell without being in a guild. Where you can find what you want without going all over the world.

Of course there are other reasons this would be beneficial but why bother. Im just going to be scorned and ridiculed for wanting this.

The funny thing is someone stated that the polls suggested the majority of players did not want this. However when speaking to my guilds they all seem to want it. Hence I posted.

Also remember the vast majority of players dont bother with the forums. If zos wants a true "poll" of whether the players want this or not they should have an in game poll 1 per account and judge it from there.

But as someone told me no sense beating a dead horse because the vocal minority are going to win every time.

Yall have a nice day now. Ya hear

No idea , but i agree with the idea that with people keep asking , then maybe at some point we will finally get it.

Xaraan...and i dont judge you for how you feel.

Personally I dont care about "immersion" for something like a broker.

As I have also said before it is simply my opinion. That and a buck 25 will get you a cup of coffee.