Should provisioning writ boxes give perfect roe?

Wrecking_Blow_Spam

The Ambrosia fragments have been outdated for ages and you can buy the recipe for 10k, shouldn't they just remove them or additionally add Roe?

All other craft boxes can reward legandary mats when possible (except alchemy), so wouldn't it make sense to have perfect roe as a drop in provisioning?

I understand it could devalue anglers, but could make the drop rates lower than the other professions. Thoughts?

Taleof2Cities

The Ambrosia Fragments aren’t outdated for new players, @Wrecking_Blow_Spam.

There are other game features that cater to end game crafters ... such as Provisioning Master Writs and Mythic Aetherial Ambrosia.

Wrecking_Blow_Spam

Taleof2Cities wrote: »

The Ambrosia Fragments aren’t outdated for new players, @Wrecking_Blow_Spam.

There are other game features that cater to end game crafters ... such as Provisioning Master Writs and Mythic Aetherial Ambrosia.

There's so many the market is flooded, they seem quite outdated imo. They could Keep them, but I don't see the harm in adding roe

Taleof2Cities

Wrecking_Blow_Spam wrote: »

Taleof2Cities wrote: »

The Ambrosia Fragments aren’t outdated for new players, @Wrecking_Blow_Spam.

There are other game features that cater to end game crafters ... such as Provisioning Master Writs and Mythic Aetherial Ambrosia.

There's so many the market is flooded, they seem quite outdated imo. They could Keep them, but I don't see the harm in adding roe

You said it yourself ... the change would harm the game's fishermen (and fisherwomen).

If ZOS made a change every time a forums thread popped up about the game economy, they wouldn't have time to work on new content.

Kittytravel

Instead of straight adding perfect roe if they wanted to go this route it'd make more sense to add 1-4 fish granted on completion with a chance to get roe from filleting. The reason the amount of fish is so low is because many people use daily writs to supplement their gold and to get surveys/master writs from them.

The fish granted would directly correlate with someones Provisioning capability; Recipe Quality. Keep in mind these are free fish for something players do anyway so there is no reason to make the amount of them enormous; on a fully f2p account without using crowns at all you can still do 9 provisining writs with all alts bringing the total (if all 50 provisioning) to 36 fish which using averages comes out to around 0.36% chance to get one a day. (The drop chance in 1 in 100).

So yeah with all that said no I don't think any of this is necessary; many people don't need to use BiS foods or EXP pots. BiS foods are more for people who are wanting to push leader board ranking and so require it to get the extra little squeeze out.

Tatanko

Taleof2Cities wrote: »

You said it yourself ... the change would harm the game's fishermen (and fisherwomen).

This would be my main concern. We don't need anything else to discourage people from fishing, and this is currently the only tangible reward for that activity outside of achievements.

Dusk_Coven

Wrecking_Blow_Spam wrote: »

All other craft boxes can reward legandary mats when possible (except alchemy), so wouldn't it make sense to have perfect roe as a drop in provisioning?

True but the usage is different. The other gold mats are routinely used for gold writs and just upgrading gear. Perfect Roe, not so much, although there are 40-voucher writs that need it. And you only need 2, compared to 8 for the other types.

ChimpyChumpy

Resurecting to say I got one perfect roe in a jubilee box so there's that at least.

Wrecking_Blow_Spam

ChimpyChumpy wrote: »

Resurecting to say I got one perfect roe in a jubilee box so there's that at least.

So did I, my first ever one